2021 GLE 450 checking oil level
02-03-2022, 11:58 AM
#26
Super Member
I haven't worked at AECOM, but I have worked with EPA onsite in the Ann Arbor test facility, on both mobile and fixed source emissions testing, and methods. And with Region 8 on other Air and Water Quality issues.
I am VERY familiar with e-testing. Dipsticks and other crankcase leaks are measured during the testing procedure. BTW this includes transmission and differential vents, not just dipsticks. I'm sure you have heard of Charcoal Canisters, which have been around for decades - an early version of containing non-combustion emissions sources. That emphasis hasn't gone away.
Your analogy about the Fire Ants is appropriate. Fire Ants can take down an elephant, and the EPA counts those ants.
A manufacturer that doesn't pay attention to all emissions sources, especially in this day of "eliminate ICE's," probably is on the way out.
Mercedes has put a lot of money into designing their oil change procedures, dipstick replacement, and related consumables - Germany is much stricter than the US on their Tier XX requirements. It's certainly NOT a cost-saving measure.
edit to add: And my earlier comment about underhood aerodynamics applies here, too. Making an access to the dipstick, and the structure itself, is a consideration. As engines get more compact, that airflow becomes more important.
I am VERY familiar with e-testing. Dipsticks and other crankcase leaks are measured during the testing procedure. BTW this includes transmission and differential vents, not just dipsticks. I'm sure you have heard of Charcoal Canisters, which have been around for decades - an early version of containing non-combustion emissions sources. That emphasis hasn't gone away.
Your analogy about the Fire Ants is appropriate. Fire Ants can take down an elephant, and the EPA counts those ants.
A manufacturer that doesn't pay attention to all emissions sources, especially in this day of "eliminate ICE's," probably is on the way out.
Mercedes has put a lot of money into designing their oil change procedures, dipstick replacement, and related consumables - Germany is much stricter than the US on their Tier XX requirements. It's certainly NOT a cost-saving measure.
edit to add: And my earlier comment about underhood aerodynamics applies here, too. Making an access to the dipstick, and the structure itself, is a consideration. As engines get more compact, that airflow becomes more important.
02-03-2022, 01:39 PM
#27
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Oct 2009
Location: Colorado
Posts: 4,834
Received 1,606 Likes
on
1,182 Posts
'21 AMG53 wDPP & ARC, 19 GLC300 - Former- 10&14 ML BlueTecs, 20 GLE450 E-ABC, 15 Cayenne D, 17 Macan
My first "no dipstick' car was our '03 C240, which required the car to sit for a few minutes before it reported an oil level. Service intervals also varied according to usage - short hops would have you coming in sooner, and all highway mileage would delay the oil change. Mercedes has abandoned that algorithm, and now sticks to mileage and time, not driving habits.
I miss a dipstick, especially knowing the smell and feel of the oil.
But I used to keep cars for a few hundred thousand miles, and now I'm less enthusiastic over 100,000 miles on any modern car.
