Prototype parts
#26
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: Gilroy
Posts: 341
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
1 Post
GLK Matte Silver|MB Arts strut tower brace|MB Arts rear brace|Shaved door and bumper trim|K&N's|
Why two tubes? What size is that tubing, 3/4"? How about a single piece of 1 1/2" or 1 3/4" in the center with the 3/4" "loops" on the ends attached to the plates? You could probably get away with DOM tubing to be more cost effective too. Looks good so far. I like the detail on the strut plates.
Thank you for the compliment. Just as a reminder the Brace in the picture is just a prototype. The production models will be much more solid with different cross braces.
#27
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: Gilroy
Posts: 341
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
1 Post
GLK Matte Silver|MB Arts strut tower brace|MB Arts rear brace|Shaved door and bumper trim|K&N's|
My fabricator has been designing/building racecars for 33 years and has been driving them for the past 29 years. Every part we make will be built up to racecar standards.
#28
MBWorld Fanatic!
I tend to agree with others. It might easier to bend single tube, but I think it's much easier to twist two parallel tubes, in your case the 3 braces take all of the twisting force not the tubes themselves. I'm sure it would not matter if it's single or twin tube model for dynamics. But from reliability standpoint I can see those little braces connecting the two tubes snapping if not welded well from the twisting force.
Also, racecar is different from an SUV by about 1,500 pounds if not more. Plus, race cars have rolling cage and no doors which increases rigity dramatically. If you really want to make it strong, why not go with CF, unless it's a lot more expensive.
How much do you plan on selling it for?
Also, racecar is different from an SUV by about 1,500 pounds if not more. Plus, race cars have rolling cage and no doors which increases rigity dramatically. If you really want to make it strong, why not go with CF, unless it's a lot more expensive.
How much do you plan on selling it for?
#29
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: Gilroy
Posts: 341
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
1 Post
GLK Matte Silver|MB Arts strut tower brace|MB Arts rear brace|Shaved door and bumper trim|K&N's|
I tend to agree with others. It might easier to bend single tube, but I think it's much easier to twist two parallel tubes, in your case the 3 braces take all of the twisting force not the tubes themselves. I'm sure it would not matter if it's single or twin tube model for dynamics. But from reliability standpoint I can see those little braces connecting the two tubes snapping if not welded well from the twisting force.
Also, racecar is different from an SUV by about 1,500 pounds if not more. Plus, race cars have rolling cage and no doors which increases rigity dramatically. If you really want to make it strong, why not go with CF, unless it's a lot more expensive.
How much do you plan on selling it for?
Also, racecar is different from an SUV by about 1,500 pounds if not more. Plus, race cars have rolling cage and no doors which increases rigity dramatically. If you really want to make it strong, why not go with CF, unless it's a lot more expensive.
How much do you plan on selling it for?
As far as carbon fiber goes of course it is more expensive don't you look at any websites or magazines. If I made a carbon brace it would go for about $1000 like other companies that make them for BMW. Besides if it were carbon I would have to make it in 3 sections. 2 mounting plates with brackets so the crossbrace could connect to it and the crossbrace itself. There would have to be 2 bolts per side side to connect the brace with the plates. To me a solid bar with no extra hardware is much strong than a multi piece brace.
Thanks once again NYCGLK
Last edited by GLK4MATIC; 05-01-2009 at 10:06 PM.
#30
MBWorld Fanatic!
Hey, I just shared my observations, not trying to knock your or your fabricator's experience. I don't build car frames, I don't do welding so I have no idea how that stuff is made. I just see two tubes welded by three braces, and that didn't look right to me just like it didn't look right to others. It very well can be very strong. Also I know that CF material costs more, I just have not idea how much more. My last car had CF hood by Carbon Creations that cost 500 bux, didn't expect a CF brace to be a $1000.
#31
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: Gilroy
Posts: 341
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
1 Post
GLK Matte Silver|MB Arts strut tower brace|MB Arts rear brace|Shaved door and bumper trim|K&N's|
Hey, I just shared my observations, not trying to knock your or your fabricator's experience. I don't build car frames, I don't do welding so I have no idea how that stuff is made. I just see two tubes welded by three braces, and that didn't look right to me just like it didn't look right to others. It very well can be very strong. Also I know that CF material costs more, I just have not idea how much more. My last car had CF hood by Carbon Creations that cost 500 bux, didn't expect a CF brace to be a $1000.
taken at 32-35 mph with ease. The only thing I feel reaching it's limit are the tires. MB did an amazing job with their suspension design and I just topped it off by helping the struts stay inline.
#32
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: Gilroy
Posts: 341
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
1 Post
GLK Matte Silver|MB Arts strut tower brace|MB Arts rear brace|Shaved door and bumper trim|K&N's|
Renntechs W204 prices:
I got a person from Renntech to give me pricing on their rear strut tower brace,which comes out in the next couple of weeks. I was told it will be between $1000-$1300 each. When the front brace comes out it will be about the same price and as of right now they are planning on selling them as a pair only so $2000-$2600. The downfall to their rear bar are the quick release pins...not as strong as a bolted or welded bar since there is flex/play in the pin area.
I got a person from Renntech to give me pricing on their rear strut tower brace,which comes out in the next couple of weeks. I was told it will be between $1000-$1300 each. When the front brace comes out it will be about the same price and as of right now they are planning on selling them as a pair only so $2000-$2600. The downfall to their rear bar are the quick release pins...not as strong as a bolted or welded bar since there is flex/play in the pin area.
#33
Member
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: Los Angeles, CA
Posts: 104
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
2010 Mercedes Benz GLK; Black; Appearance Package; Multimedia Package; Panorama Roof;
Renntech struts too much
Renntechs W204 prices:
I got a person from Renntech to give me pricing on their rear strut tower brace,which comes out in the next couple of weeks. I was told it will be between $1000-$1300 each. When the front brace comes out it will be about the same price and as of right now they are planning on selling them as a pair only so $2000-$2600. The downfall to their rear bar are the quick release pins...not as strong as a bolted or welded bar since there is flex/play in the pin area.
I got a person from Renntech to give me pricing on their rear strut tower brace,which comes out in the next couple of weeks. I was told it will be between $1000-$1300 each. When the front brace comes out it will be about the same price and as of right now they are planning on selling them as a pair only so $2000-$2600. The downfall to their rear bar are the quick release pins...not as strong as a bolted or welded bar since there is flex/play in the pin area.
Way too much for a strut bar!
Let us know when you will start selling your struts.
I'm getting one
#34
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: Gilroy
Posts: 341
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
1 Post
GLK Matte Silver|MB Arts strut tower brace|MB Arts rear brace|Shaved door and bumper trim|K&N's|
I will be posting pics of the new bar this evening. And should be ready for orders anyday now. Sorry I have'nt been quicker with the process, but I am working on multiple parts for our GLK's. Trying to make the strongest parts that I can.