Anybody gone from S Class to GLS?
#1
MBWorld Fanatic!
Thread Starter
Anybody gone from S Class to GLS?
So my S560 is at the dealer for a valve cover leak repair, and I have a GLS 450 loaner. We test drove GLSs for my wife but living with the car for a couple days gives you a new perspective. I like a lot of things about it, its not as solid and dynamic as the S Class, but it rides well and obviously has a lot more capability and practicality. I always think about going to an SUV but I have never pulled the trigger. I love the high driving position.
I would get a 580, I miss the V8...its about $15,000 cheaper than an S580 build, but the discounts are much better on the S Class so if anything at the end of the day the GLS is a little more expensive.
Has anybody gone from an S Class or other similar sedan to a GLS? Would be interested in your thoughts.
Here's the loaner in my garage, fits great, hatch still opens in the back and everything
I would get a 580, I miss the V8...its about $15,000 cheaper than an S580 build, but the discounts are much better on the S Class so if anything at the end of the day the GLS is a little more expensive.
Has anybody gone from an S Class or other similar sedan to a GLS? Would be interested in your thoughts.
Here's the loaner in my garage, fits great, hatch still opens in the back and everything
The following users liked this post:
Splaktar (05-31-2024)
#2
MBWorld Fanatic!
If you don't care about the 2nd (no exec seats on the GLE) and 3rd rows (3rd row on GLS is much more usable than GLE), a GLE rides the same but IMO more dynamic vs the GLS. Something to consider since the GLE driver's seat environment is virtually no different vs the GLS.
*Also E-ABC isn't an option on GLE anymore.
*Also E-ABC isn't an option on GLE anymore.
Last edited by wildta; 05-29-2024 at 04:22 PM.
#3
MBWorld Fanatic!
Thread Starter
I actually had a GLE loaner for a week when this issue with the S Class was diagnosed, I prefer the GLS...I like big cars and IMO the GLS looks better
#4
Your loaner looks no newer than my MY23 GLS450 (MY24 has a bigger grille).
My gut feeling is the S Class is still the better car w/more stuff standard compared to the GLS, IMHO.
My gut feeling is the S Class is still the better car w/more stuff standard compared to the GLS, IMHO.
#5
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: Texas
Posts: 1,619
Likes: 0
Received 93 Likes
on
74 Posts
2014 S550 - SOLD, 2014 GL550 - SOLD, 2014 GL63 AMG, 2015 S63 AMG Sedan, 2015 S63 AMG Coupe
I have both S63 and a GLS63. While they are 2 different vehicles, I love the GLS. It has more room and is a fun to drive.
The following 2 users liked this post by sam9187:
OldManAndHisCar (06-06-2024),
Splaktar (05-31-2024)
#6
Super Member
As much as Mercedes like to claim that the GLS is the S Class of SUVs, it ain't. I've had 4 S class and 4 GLS, and the S class experience always leaves me feeling cosseted and comfortable. The GLS600 Maybach comes close though. I too love the high riding form factor of the GLS.
#7
Out Of Control!!
Join Date: Dec 2019
Posts: 14,549
Received 2,795 Likes
on
2,377 Posts
PFL205.064 with M276.823 (Oil pump solenoid defeated)
As much as Mercedes like to claim that the GLS is the S Class of SUVs, it ain't. I've had 4 S class and 4 GLS, and the S class experience always leaves me feeling cosseted and comfortable. The GLS600 Maybach comes close though. I too love the high riding form factor of the GLS.
Trending Topics
#8
MBWorld Fanatic!
Thread Starter
As much as Mercedes like to claim that the GLS is the S Class of SUVs, it ain't. I've had 4 S class and 4 GLS, and the S class experience always leaves me feeling cosseted and comfortable. The GLS600 Maybach comes close though. I too love the high riding form factor of the GLS.
The following users liked this post:
Splaktar (05-31-2024)
#9
Senior Member
Steve, you may recall that I enjoyed the 2015 S550 that I bought in 2019 so much that I broke my 20 year string of MDXs, and in November 2022 purchased a 2020 GLS 450. As an aside, before I bought the S550 I had several older LS sedans as an extra vehicle in the stable. I am very happy with the GLS. The GLS is a very solid and comfortable SUV, with great technology. I will say, however, that the S550 is a smoother ride, even being a 2015.
I have been daily driving SUVs since a 1996 Yukon, generally just commuting and on road trips. The GLS is obviously head and shoulders above the MDX on all fronts, so I am very satisfied. Your big decision is that you have been daily driving Lexus and MB sedans, and you may spend several hours a day in your vehicle. Is the GLS going to provide sufficient comfort and luxury compared to what you have been used to?
I have been daily driving SUVs since a 1996 Yukon, generally just commuting and on road trips. The GLS is obviously head and shoulders above the MDX on all fronts, so I am very satisfied. Your big decision is that you have been daily driving Lexus and MB sedans, and you may spend several hours a day in your vehicle. Is the GLS going to provide sufficient comfort and luxury compared to what you have been used to?
The following users liked this post:
SW20S (05-30-2024)
#10
MBWorld Fanatic!
Thread Starter
I remember!
I don't spend as much time in my vehicle as I used to, daily driving is maybe 30 minutes a day. The long stints spent in it are for road trips...
I don't spend as much time in my vehicle as I used to, daily driving is maybe 30 minutes a day. The long stints spent in it are for road trips...
#11
Out Of Control!!
Join Date: Dec 2019
Posts: 14,549
Received 2,795 Likes
on
2,377 Posts
PFL205.064 with M276.823 (Oil pump solenoid defeated)
Steve, you may recall that I enjoyed the 2015 S550 that I bought in 2019 so much that I broke my 20 year string of MDXs, and in November 2022 purchased a 2020 GLS 450. As an aside, before I bought the S550 I had several older LS sedans as an extra vehicle in the stable. I am very happy with the GLS. The GLS is a very solid and comfortable SUV, with great technology. I will say, however, that the S550 is a smoother ride, even being a 2015.
I have been daily driving SUVs since a 1996 Yukon, generally just commuting and on road trips. The GLS is obviously head and shoulders above the MDX on all fronts, so I am very satisfied. Your big decision is that you have been daily driving Lexus and MB sedans, and you may spend several hours a day in your vehicle. Is the GLS going to provide sufficient comfort and luxury compared to what you have been used to?
I have been daily driving SUVs since a 1996 Yukon, generally just commuting and on road trips. The GLS is obviously head and shoulders above the MDX on all fronts, so I am very satisfied. Your big decision is that you have been daily driving Lexus and MB sedans, and you may spend several hours a day in your vehicle. Is the GLS going to provide sufficient comfort and luxury compared to what you have been used to?
Last edited by W205C43PFL; 05-31-2024 at 08:25 AM.
#12
Could tires plays a role by chance, what tires does the vehicle come equipped and they are not run flats right? What cold tire pressures are inflated to and is it based on the values on the gas fuel door? Just curious : ) Want to see if we can improve the ride for you.
#13
Out Of Control!!
Join Date: Dec 2019
Posts: 14,549
Received 2,795 Likes
on
2,377 Posts
PFL205.064 with M276.823 (Oil pump solenoid defeated)
#14
Senior Member
Could tires plays a role by chance, what tires does the vehicle come equipped and they are not run flats right? What cold tire pressures are inflated to and is it based on the values on the gas fuel door? Just curious : ) Want to see if we can improve the ride for you.
The 15 S550 has staggard 20” summer run flats (the Goodyear OEM tire). The GLS was purchased as CPO and apparently was originally a special order. MSRP 105k with 3D Burmester, E-ABC, etc, but oddly has the standard 19” wheels (Conti CC LX25 tire).
Don’t get me wrong, the GLS is a great ride, I just believe the S550 is smoother, even with the run flats, which most folks seem not to like.
#15
Out Of Control!!
Join Date: Dec 2019
Posts: 14,549
Received 2,795 Likes
on
2,377 Posts
PFL205.064 with M276.823 (Oil pump solenoid defeated)
I inflate tires to fuel door values. Sometimes a couple pounds higher on GLS if loaded heavily for trips.
The 15 S550 has staggard 20” summer run flats (the Goodyear OEM tire). The GLS was purchased as CPO and apparently was originally a special order. MSRP 105k with 3D Burmester, E-ABC, etc, but oddly has the standard 19” wheels (Conti CC LX25 tire).
Don’t get me wrong, the GLS is a great ride, I just believe the S550 is smoother, even with the run flats, which most folks seem not to like.
The 15 S550 has staggard 20” summer run flats (the Goodyear OEM tire). The GLS was purchased as CPO and apparently was originally a special order. MSRP 105k with 3D Burmester, E-ABC, etc, but oddly has the standard 19” wheels (Conti CC LX25 tire).
Don’t get me wrong, the GLS is a great ride, I just believe the S550 is smoother, even with the run flats, which most folks seem not to like.
#16
MBWorld Fanatic!
Thread Starter
Could tires plays a role by chance, what tires does the vehicle come equipped and they are not run flats right? What cold tire pressures are inflated to and is it based on the values on the gas fuel door? Just curious : ) Want to see if we can improve the ride for you.
#17
Member
Join Date: Jan 2024
Location: Melbourne, FL
Posts: 93
Received 41 Likes
on
27 Posts
2024 GLS 580, 2022 Sprinter-based Winnebago View 24D
If you don't care about the 2nd (no exec seats on the GLE) and 3rd rows (3rd row on GLS is much more usable than GLE), a GLE rides the same but IMO more dynamic vs the GLS. Something to consider since the GLE driver's seat environment is virtually no different vs the GLS.
*Also E-ABC isn't an option on GLE anymore.
*Also E-ABC isn't an option on GLE anymore.
#18
Out Of Control!!
Join Date: Dec 2019
Posts: 14,549
Received 2,795 Likes
on
2,377 Posts
PFL205.064 with M276.823 (Oil pump solenoid defeated)
It’s not that the GLS rides poorly, it rides very well it just doesn’t ride as well as the S Class. It’s also nowhere near as solid and locked in at highway speeds. The S Class feels better the faster you go and the GLS doesn’t want to be driven much over 85 or so in sport mode. In comfort it’s over 75 it feels unhappy.
I mean, don't SUVs in general don't ride as nice on the highway as sedans (or so I heard)
The following users liked this post:
EWL5 (05-31-2024)
#20
MBWorld Fanatic!
Thread Starter
No, S Class rides better on poor roads. It just rides better in every situation. GLS is more capable in poor weather and obviously offroad, its all about tradeoffs. The S Class is probably the best riding car in the world so saying it doesnt ride as well as the S Class is not really an issue with it, it rides very well.
The following users liked this post:
TNS550 (05-31-2024)
#21
Out Of Control!!
Join Date: Dec 2019
Posts: 14,549
Received 2,795 Likes
on
2,377 Posts
PFL205.064 with M276.823 (Oil pump solenoid defeated)
No, S Class rides better on poor roads. It just rides better in every situation. GLS is more capable in poor weather and obviously offroad, its all about tradeoffs. The S Class is probably the best riding car in the world so saying it doesnt ride as well as the S Class is not really an issue with it, it rides very well.
#22
MBWorld Fanatic!
Thread Starter
I took a bunch of people out to lunch in it yesterday and they raved about it…
#23
MBWorld Fanatic!
I'm average height so I never noticed that when I rented a GLS for a weekend trip before deciding it was too big for me. But that makes sense for those bigger than me.
#24
Out Of Control!!
Join Date: Dec 2019
Posts: 14,549
Received 2,795 Likes
on
2,377 Posts
PFL205.064 with M276.823 (Oil pump solenoid defeated)
Or if you want a Range Rover in that case... aside from the issues it might have I guess.
Let's start a shopping list, shall we : )
#25
MBWorld Fanatic!
There is really no comparison in driving dynamic as you noted earlier. Even comparing our 2020 450 to my former 2014 E350, the E was hands down a far more superior highway speed demon cruiser. MB sedans are a unique animal that truly can’t be replicated by an SUV. That being said, in terms of a large SUV that isn’t going to see much beyond the pavement, the GLS is hard to beat. Ours has been good to us. Not great, but pretty damn good. Annoyances have been our only issue and they have been far and few. We’re at 70k on the clock, and it’s still solid. Lots of I95 time between NC and DC. It’s excellent on long cruises, planted but at the expense of the rear tires lasting only 25k miles. Lots of room in the back too, and easy to get in/out for all ages. I would definitely consider the 7 seat configuration, the bench is excellent in the back.
Ours is plenty worn in now. Stil on original brake pads too, but they’re getting close. The transmission is getting a little eager to shift even with new fluid installed at 50k miles. Seems jumpy and getting a little harsh. Likely heading back for another flush service. Never a problem with rotor warp wobble, and we’ve had some hard stops at highway speeds. We usually drive in “eco” mode because the 48v makes it able to in the smoothest fashion possible. I personally think the V8 is not worth the cost. The 450 can boogie when called upon for sure.
my only advice Steve - watch the low profile tires! You’re on the side of DC known for those potholes! We’re on the 21’s staggered and have been ok with a few pothole hits that would have bent the snot out of those old AMG 18’ wheels in my old E. Our rims are chewed up those on the edges. Gave up trying to save them.
it’s very good in bad weather too. Snow isn’t a concern, and does very well in heavy rain at highway speeds. Also does well in heavy crosswinds.
It’s no S class, and if that level of luxury is what you’re after then the GLS will disappoint. I’d say it’s probably 70% of the S class in that regard.
Ours is plenty worn in now. Stil on original brake pads too, but they’re getting close. The transmission is getting a little eager to shift even with new fluid installed at 50k miles. Seems jumpy and getting a little harsh. Likely heading back for another flush service. Never a problem with rotor warp wobble, and we’ve had some hard stops at highway speeds. We usually drive in “eco” mode because the 48v makes it able to in the smoothest fashion possible. I personally think the V8 is not worth the cost. The 450 can boogie when called upon for sure.
my only advice Steve - watch the low profile tires! You’re on the side of DC known for those potholes! We’re on the 21’s staggered and have been ok with a few pothole hits that would have bent the snot out of those old AMG 18’ wheels in my old E. Our rims are chewed up those on the edges. Gave up trying to save them.
it’s very good in bad weather too. Snow isn’t a concern, and does very well in heavy rain at highway speeds. Also does well in heavy crosswinds.
It’s no S class, and if that level of luxury is what you’re after then the GLS will disappoint. I’d say it’s probably 70% of the S class in that regard.
The following users liked this post:
Splaktar (06-01-2024)