oil filter spindle shaft broken
Thread Starter
Newbie
Joined: Mar 2012
Posts: 1
Likes: 0
C240 1999
oil filter spindle shaft broken
I accidentally broke the oil filter spindle shaft/ Oil Filter holder. Can I continue driving my car, or does it need to be replaced. it would cost the equivalent of $50 in South Africa.
Please advise as soon as possible.
Thank much appreciated.
Please advise as soon as possible.
Thank much appreciated.
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 1,152
Likes: 29
From: Sydney, Australia
190D 2.5 (x2), 190E 2.6, W202 C240,W202 C43 (C55), W210 E55, W212 E250CDI
You'll need to change it, If you manage to "fix" it and it breaks whilst driving (and this time you won't know) you'll have no or low oil pressure. Just change it.
Newbie
Joined: Jun 2018
Posts: 1
Likes: 0
2010 C200 Wagon
My mechanic broke my oil filter spindle, but said nothing
After getting my car (2010 C-200) back from an oil change, it made quite a racket when I was decelerating (down a slope or slowing for traffic) like a bolt was loose or the timing chain was coming off the sprockets. CEL light came on. I feared the worst after reading about how many M271 engines have the timing chain issues. The ODB scanner says fault P0011 - "advanced timing bank 1 intake". I took it back to the mechanic who kept it for two weeks, claiming he didnt hear anything and the CEL cleared itself. But after swapping out sensors and magnets (DIY) with no improvement, I decided to check the oil filter and its seals. Drained the oil, opened the oil filter housing and it was in two pieces. I'm hoping that none of the plastic bits went into the engine. Seems the mechanic didnt use a torque wrench, or ?, or do these things just get brittle and break after 8 years? Ordered a new one for US$35 via ebay. Hoping this is the only problem.
I live in the sticks in Japan, and the dealer is 2 hours away, so I tend to use local mechanics which are usually good. Will update. Will fix DIY.
I live in the sticks in Japan, and the dealer is 2 hours away, so I tend to use local mechanics which are usually good. Will update. Will fix DIY.
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Oct 2009
Posts: 1,924
Likes: 38
cl600
After getting my car (2010 C-200) back from an oil change, it made quite a racket when I was decelerating (down a slope or slowing for traffic) like a bolt was loose or the timing chain was coming off the sprockets. CEL light came on. I feared the worst after reading about how many M271 engines have the timing chain issues. The ODB scanner says fault P0011 - "advanced timing bank 1 intake". I took it back to the mechanic who kept it for two weeks, claiming he didnt hear anything and the CEL cleared itself. But after swapping out sensors and magnets (DIY) with no improvement, I decided to check the oil filter and its seals. Drained the oil, opened the oil filter housing and it was in two pieces. I'm hoping that none of the plastic bits went into the engine. Seems the mechanic didnt use a torque wrench, or ?, or do these things just get brittle and break after 8 years? Ordered a new one for US$35 via ebay. Hoping this is the only problem.
I live in the sticks in Japan, and the dealer is 2 hours away, so I tend to use local mechanics which are usually good. Will update. Will fix DIY.
I live in the sticks in Japan, and the dealer is 2 hours away, so I tend to use local mechanics which are usually good. Will update. Will fix DIY.
Newbie
Joined: Jul 2014
Posts: 2
Likes: 1
From: Japan
2010 C200 wagon
w204 oil filter housing on ebay
I would search "w204 oil filter housing" on ebay. I bought one from a Hong Kong vendor, and it was the identical part and came in MB packaging. It came with o-rings, but I swapped them with the ones that came with the filter which were beefier. Free shipping took 10 days. It works and all is good now! The fault codes P0011 and P0014 have not returned. I will change my own oil from now on.
