Suggestions for 18" rims for 63 winters
Nokian WR A.W.P. 2 SUV 235/65 R17 108 V snow traction rated 29.1"
I need suggestions for a nice 18" rim. The designer series brochure only shows 19" and 20" ML rims. The ML 500 18" rim is ok but will not stand out.
Well there doesn't seem to be much point in a 2nd set of 19" rims so it comes down to the Pirelli S&I 275/40 R20 and the Nokian WRAWP 2 SUV 275/40 R20. Both are 106 V. I went to four different tire stores today and carried out an unscientific survey. I should say up front that I have Nokian all purpose tires on an SUV already and love them so I am likely biased. I have never owned Pirelli.
#1) Kaltire (the only guys who carry the Nokian line). They said Nokian superior (suprise, suprise). Pointed out that Nokian are all weather and still outperform on ice and snow. 100,000 km warranty - $458 per tire Cdn
#2) Fountain Tire - Used to carry Pirelli now only carry Goodyear. Can't carry Nokian as they are exclusive to Kaltire. Both guys working there own Nokians and swear by them. They said Pirelli was excellent but Nokian was in a different league. Wished they could carry Nokian line.
#3) 1st Unamed Pirelli dealer - guy there said he has been selling Pirelli for twenty years, he would love to sell me the Pirelli's but felt Nokian's were clearly better. He said Kaltire spent millions and years developing the Nokians and they were simply the best. When I pointed out that Pirelli was the factory choice he said that they probably paid for the privalege. Someone on this forum did point out earlier that Pirelli made these tire specifically for the ML63 though.
#4) 2nd Unamed Pirelli dealer - said Nokians were crap as they weren't performance rated. I pointed out they were V rated, the same as the Pirelli, he countered that they weren't ZR rated (but could not explain what this meant). Price was $537 Cdn per tire.
I don't believe I am going to be able to take my local inevstigation any further as there are no more Pirelli dealers nearby, and I need to get a life.
I am strongly leaning to the Nokian's because our winters tend to have cycles of snow, melt, freeze, melt followed by long periods of dry pavement. I believe the Nokians will last longer and provide reasonable safety.
http://www.tirerack.com/wheels/Displ...Silver+Painted
http://www.tirerack.com/wheels/Displ...Silver+Painted
I ordered the AT Italia because they will take the MB crests.
Trending Topics
Please let us know what you decide to do. I am waiting on an October build 63 to replace a Cayenne TT. I have been doing the tire swap, because I didn't want to buy wheels for a leased vehicle, but now I have the winter tires already, which are 255/55 18's, and I would consider wheels instead of tires because the tires have at least one season left, and possibly 2, and the cost of switching every season is $100 anyway, so new wheels and one mounting could make sense (I could switch the wheels myself). Thanks.
The Best of Mercedes & AMG
CHeck out some other stores usualy dealers make HUGE mark ups on anything they can get for you.
Eye-Candy,
If I remember correctly, the proper tire size for 19s is 295/45/19 on all corners.
As to the 18" dilemma. The latest response I had was from customer service at MB Canada who referenced a technical data sheet that stated 19" AMG wheels were required to clear the brakes. Of course, the proof is in the pudding. As 18" would allow for much narrower tires (? Nokian 235/60 R 18)and better sidewall thickness... I am pregnant with anticpation for the results of Black and Tan's investigation.
Thanks, I am just trying to help a fellow ML63 owner out. I am going to get myself the 19s from AMG accessories, not only they are worry free, but also 100% OEM compatible. As of the winter tires, I think I am going with what European ML63s are using, 295/45/19, which should be thick enough for everyday NYC driving. Wish I could get myself some 50 or 55 series tires for the streets like my 04 Forester XT, which rolls on 225/55/17. 400bhp with no worries about pot holes, it's all good.
Last edited by 2MANYCARS; Sep 28, 2006 at 01:39 AM.
Will all the Pirelli Scorpion Ice & Snow tire sizes above fit safely (no need for spacers, etc.) on the stock 20" wheel that comes with the ML63?
Thank you ahead of time for replying.
- A-Train


