Dealerships at MSRP vs. Shameful Upchargers
#101
Member
Join Date: Mar 2018
Location: Maryland
Posts: 228
Received 42 Likes
on
36 Posts
2023 S580 (current), 2019 Range Rover HSE V6 (current),2021 S580, 2018 S560 4Matic, 2015 S550 4Matic
I was wondering if anyone had any updates on dealers charging MSRP or maybe (hopefully) giving some kind of discount on the new S class. I am currently shopping around for one for my parents and so far the local dealerships I enquired from in Florida are all at MSRP and trying to make it sound like they are doing a godsend that they are not charging a market adjustment 🙄
The following users liked this post:
makris0000 (02-22-2022)
#107
Out Of Control!!
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: North Scottsdale, AZ
Posts: 15,903
Received 4,447 Likes
on
3,154 Posts
'71 Pinto
Dealer discretion they're doing it because they can. FWIW I have never, nor will I ever pay MSRP or above – ever. No one buys, or leases away goes the mark ups! In a lease? Buy it out – wait it out!
Last edited by konigstiger; 02-19-2022 at 10:18 AM.
The following 4 users liked this post by konigstiger:
#108
Junior Member
I paid a 10k premium over MSRP for mine. Then again, I got out of my old lease with cash out my way so kind of a wash.
The way I see it, an S class isn't a necessity. It's purely because I want one. As such, I am not giving away a year or two of my life driving anything less than what I desire. I could be dead tomorrow, or by the time the premium vanishes. Money comes and goes. Time is what truly comes a at premium.
The way I see it, an S class isn't a necessity. It's purely because I want one. As such, I am not giving away a year or two of my life driving anything less than what I desire. I could be dead tomorrow, or by the time the premium vanishes. Money comes and goes. Time is what truly comes a at premium.
The following 5 users liked this post by mwilson122:
far2000 (02-23-2022),
Jmcintire217 (02-19-2022),
Martsman (02-19-2022),
Ormond2004 (02-20-2022),
retiredandhappy (02-20-2022)
#109
Out Of Control!!
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: North Scottsdale, AZ
Posts: 15,903
Received 4,447 Likes
on
3,154 Posts
'71 Pinto
Each to ‘his’ own.
The following users liked this post:
drose224 (02-21-2022)
#110
MBWorld Fanatic!
To me, why would I pay a markup on the lot if I can order and pay MSRP? May as well plan ahead and order.
#111
Member
I placed an order and deposit 18 months ago with a local dealer. Last week I got this email ---- My reaction is WTF" I confirmed that your position in the queue from the 2021 list carried over into the 2022 G63 list and you are in position number one for the next G63 allocation. I think it only makes sense to stay with the order after having waited this long. I’ve had many conversations with my GSM, Richard, specifically about your order and a couple other orders that I placed. We really don’t know what condition the SUV market or the economy or the world will be in on the week that it arrives so I think it makes sense to let it get built and work with him on his “fair market price” when it comes in."
#112
Super Member
I placed an order and deposit 18 months ago with a local dealer. Last week I got this email ---- My reaction is WTF" I confirmed that your position in the queue from the 2021 list carried over into the 2022 G63 list and you are in position number one for the next G63 allocation. I think it only makes sense to stay with the order after having waited this long. I’ve had many conversations with my GSM, Richard, specifically about your order and a couple other orders that I placed. We really don’t know what condition the SUV market or the economy or the world will be in on the week that it arrives so I think it makes sense to let it get built and work with him on his “fair market price” when it comes in."
The following users liked this post:
Ormond2004 (03-30-2022)
#113
Super Member
Join Date: Nov 2021
Location: Hong Kong, China
Posts: 893
Received 396 Likes
on
265 Posts
2021 S450 4Matic
If it is a matter of principle, even $1 markup over the MSRP is not acceptable.
Personally, I do not go this far.
I am not eager to say I do not mind any markup at all. But I am also not eager to say I would never buy a car with a markup.
Afterall, it is MSRP which is just a suggestion only.
A dealer can markup or he can give a discount. He has the freedom to do so and I have the freedom to buy from him or somebody else or not buy at all.
I would consider, case by case, how much the markup is and how long I want to wait (buying off the lot vs ordering) and then decide if I would accept a markup.
Personally, I do not go this far.
I am not eager to say I do not mind any markup at all. But I am also not eager to say I would never buy a car with a markup.
Afterall, it is MSRP which is just a suggestion only.
A dealer can markup or he can give a discount. He has the freedom to do so and I have the freedom to buy from him or somebody else or not buy at all.
I would consider, case by case, how much the markup is and how long I want to wait (buying off the lot vs ordering) and then decide if I would accept a markup.
Last edited by bishop64; 02-20-2022 at 01:00 AM.
#114
Member
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Miami, Florida
Posts: 176
Likes: 0
Received 25 Likes
on
7 Posts
S580, GTC, GL550, NEW S550, S63 (Sold), S550 (Sold), ML350, C230
Mb of Cutler Bay
If you are in South Florida Bill Ussery Mercedes Benz in Coral Gables and Cutler Bay is a class act!!! While my father would take me to the original Coral Gables location I now frequent the Cutler Bay location because Luis Gutierrez (company lifer and GM) foments an incredible customer service based culture.
ask for Joe Maya and tell him Prio sent you!
ask for Joe Maya and tell him Prio sent you!
There is more to it than just MSRP unless you pay cash. They can add points to the interest rate on financing, or they can add to the money factor on a lease. On the E63S that I've ordered, then later canceled due to delays, they told me I got $5k off but after they have increased the MF over the standard MB MF, it ended up being a wash. I got MSRP in the end. When I pointed this out to them, I was told take it or leave it. Just FYI.
Having said that. I am on the opinion that this is still a free market. Now that they are selling less vehicles, I don't blame them for tryin to make up elsewhere. Again, my opinion. I am waiting for things to chill a bit, and also waiting for more options to come available. It seams to me the S580 in the USA is a bare bone car at the moment. I mean the freaking AMG package does not have the AMG steering wheel. I also don't see the option for the amazing 3D HUD. Both must have in my mind.
Edit:
Ohh and since this is a thread specific to mentioning dealerships. Add:
Mercedes Benz of Coconut Creek (Autonation) for hiking both MSRP and MF or interest rate. I have never once had a good experience with any Autonation MB location (they have like 3 around here near Ft Lauderdale). Three times I walked in to get a Benz. Once a S430 many years ago. Once an SL550. This last time an E63S (since the S580 was not out). Not once was I able to drive out with a new car. I will try Palm Beach next or go out of state with a broker.
Having said that. I am on the opinion that this is still a free market. Now that they are selling less vehicles, I don't blame them for tryin to make up elsewhere. Again, my opinion. I am waiting for things to chill a bit, and also waiting for more options to come available. It seams to me the S580 in the USA is a bare bone car at the moment. I mean the freaking AMG package does not have the AMG steering wheel. I also don't see the option for the amazing 3D HUD. Both must have in my mind.
Edit:
Ohh and since this is a thread specific to mentioning dealerships. Add:
Mercedes Benz of Coconut Creek (Autonation) for hiking both MSRP and MF or interest rate. I have never once had a good experience with any Autonation MB location (they have like 3 around here near Ft Lauderdale). Three times I walked in to get a Benz. Once a S430 many years ago. Once an SL550. This last time an E63S (since the S580 was not out). Not once was I able to drive out with a new car. I will try Palm Beach next or go out of state with a broker.
#116
Member
I do think it's funny seeing people saying things like "I will never pay MSRP or higher for a car" and bashing dealers for doing this when they are selling half the cars they used to, and everything in the world costs more than it used to. Meanwhile, we have all literally received tens upon tens of thousands of dollars in discounts on cars we have purchased/leased over the years due to the previous "market conditions" and were happy to beat the crap out of dealers to get the prices we wanted. Now, trade-ins are worth more than ever and most of us can pull equity and make thousands from our existing leases, which almost never happened back in the day.
"But nooooo, I will wait two years to get the car I want rather than pay the actual price of the car!" And by then, your trade will be worth less, there will be no equity in your lease, and the base price of the car you want will have increased by a few thousand bucks.
Last edited by LOGOSDJ; 02-22-2022 at 04:03 PM.
#117
Out Of Control!!
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: North Scottsdale, AZ
Posts: 15,903
Received 4,447 Likes
on
3,154 Posts
'71 Pinto
You do understand it is a discretionary dealer markup. Anyway, I say again to each his own. I understand in this day and age those who think differently are immediately called out and considered wrong but hey, I was never a sheeple. You want it, willing to pay for it, so be it and best of luck. This time around, after my wife I who mind you have been simultaneously leasing from the same dealer for the last 12 years … will not.
Last edited by konigstiger; 02-22-2022 at 03:56 PM.
#118
MBWorld Fanatic!
Exactly. Ordering cars is the future and is actually the better way to buy a car in terms of being able to get exactly what you want in the car with zero compromises. You don't miss out on anything you wanted, nor do you pay for additional options you didn't want. If you have the luxury of time, ordering is the way to go. Some people might be desperate or under pressure to get a car immediately, which sucks for them. They totaled their current car, existing lease is over, or they just impatient as hell. Then you are subject to the current market conditions. If you are "cutting the line" compared to almost everyone else these days, it makes sense you might pay a little more.
I do think it's funny seeing people saying things like "I will never pay MSRP or higher for a car" and bashing dealers for doing this when they are selling half the cars they used to, and everything in the world costs more than it used to. Meanwhile, we have all literally received tens upon tens of thousands of dollars in discounts on cars we have purchased/leased over the years due to the previous "market conditions" and were happy to beat the crap out of dealers to get the prices we wanted. Now, trade-ins are worth more than ever and most of us can pull equity and make thousands from our existing leases, which almost never happened back in the day.
"But nooooo, I will wait two years to get the car I want rather than pay the actual price of the car!" And by then, your trade will be worth less, there will be no equity in your lease, and the base price of the car you want will have increased by a few thousand bucks.
I do think it's funny seeing people saying things like "I will never pay MSRP or higher for a car" and bashing dealers for doing this when they are selling half the cars they used to, and everything in the world costs more than it used to. Meanwhile, we have all literally received tens upon tens of thousands of dollars in discounts on cars we have purchased/leased over the years due to the previous "market conditions" and were happy to beat the crap out of dealers to get the prices we wanted. Now, trade-ins are worth more than ever and most of us can pull equity and make thousands from our existing leases, which almost never happened back in the day.
"But nooooo, I will wait two years to get the car I want rather than pay the actual price of the car!" And by then, your trade will be worth less, there will be no equity in your lease, and the base price of the car you want will have increased by a few thousand bucks.
#119
MBWorld Fanatic!
Exactly. Ordering cars is the future and is actually the better way to buy a car in terms of being able to get exactly what you want in the car with zero compromises. You don't miss out on anything you wanted, nor do you pay for additional options you didn't want. If you have the luxury of time, ordering is the way to go. Some people might be desperate or under pressure to get a car immediately, which sucks for them. They totaled their current car, existing lease is over, or they just impatient as hell. Then you are subject to the current market conditions. If you are "cutting the line" compared to almost everyone else these days, it makes sense you might pay a little more.
I do think it's funny seeing people saying things like "I will never pay MSRP or higher for a car" and bashing dealers for doing this when they are selling half the cars they used to, and everything in the world costs more than it used to. Meanwhile, we have all literally received tens upon tens of thousands of dollars in discounts on cars we have purchased/leased over the years due to the previous "market conditions" and were happy to beat the crap out of dealers to get the prices we wanted. Now, trade-ins are worth more than ever and most of us can pull equity and make thousands from our existing leases, which almost never happened back in the day.
"But nooooo, I will wait two years to get the car I want rather than pay the actual price of the car!" And by then, your trade will be worth less, there will be no equity in your lease, and the base price of the car you want will have increased by a few thousand bucks.
I do think it's funny seeing people saying things like "I will never pay MSRP or higher for a car" and bashing dealers for doing this when they are selling half the cars they used to, and everything in the world costs more than it used to. Meanwhile, we have all literally received tens upon tens of thousands of dollars in discounts on cars we have purchased/leased over the years due to the previous "market conditions" and were happy to beat the crap out of dealers to get the prices we wanted. Now, trade-ins are worth more than ever and most of us can pull equity and make thousands from our existing leases, which almost never happened back in the day.
"But nooooo, I will wait two years to get the car I want rather than pay the actual price of the car!" And by then, your trade will be worth less, there will be no equity in your lease, and the base price of the car you want will have increased by a few thousand bucks.
Did you just offer to pay MSRP when you could have paid less because "Hey, thats fair!"?
The following users liked this post:
LOGOSDJ (02-22-2022)
#120
I believe if you and your wife have been leasing from the same dealer for 12 years (back of the envelope math - 8 leases!) your dealer should consider offering you a discount on this Mercedes, regardless of current market conditions. Your loyalty and relationship over 12 years should be valued and rewarded. That’s my opinion.
The following users liked this post:
Ormond2004 (03-30-2022)
#121
MBWorld Fanatic!
I believe if you and your wife have been leasing from the same dealer for 12 years (back of the envelope math - 8 leases!) your dealer should consider offering you a discount on this Mercedes, regardless of current market conditions. Your loyalty and relationship over 12 years should be valued and rewarded. That’s my opinion.
#122
Super Member
Join Date: Nov 2021
Location: Hong Kong, China
Posts: 893
Received 396 Likes
on
265 Posts
2021 S450 4Matic
Maybe the best way is to order online (Tesla style?) or even pay online? Then, one can even avoid the hassle of dealing with the salesman and save a trip to the dealership.
#123
Junior Member
And this comes from someone who's had a decade-long relationship with my salesperson, who is a true gentleman. Despite this, I'd rather do all online and skip the dealership altogether. When my wife got her Tesla a couple of years ago, the whole purchasing experience was an eye-opener; why can't all makers be like that?
The following 2 users liked this post by mwilson122:
MBS63AMG (05-07-2022),
Ormond2004 (03-30-2022)
#124
Member
Apologies if you had read this in another post but want to warn anyone in mid ohio to avoid this dealership. My G63 that is now in production and when they told me that I needed to pay market value I sent a nasty complaint to the GM. Well they told me to stick it, its either take it like a good boy and pay up or do business elsewhere. If you are in Mid Ohio don't do business with these guys. Extortion!! Feel free to give them a bad google review
Mr. Santini –
I apologize for the delayed response - we investigated the circumstances surrounding the order for a 2021 Mercedes-Benz G 63W4- unless you have something else documented, it appears that all we have in writing is a copy of what we refer to as a ‘build sheet’ not an agreement, we actually are relying on the verbal agreements/communication made back in December 2020. As I’m sure you understand, we were not able to obtain or fufill the order on a 2021 G63W4 ( the vehicle Kenneth Stuart (Ken) has been telling you about is going to be a 2022 model)….MBUSA has not released the pricing on the 2022’s as of yet.
When we accepted your deposit, it was pre-pandemic- there was no reason to believe we could not fufill your order…our industry was turned upside down once Covid 19 hit – mostly due to severe supply shortages. As an industry, our total sales numbers dropped precipitously – ‘some’ of this was offset by holding more gross profit on a per vehicle basis although the G Wagon was already in short supply back in December 2020 when you first gave us a deposit.
Ken suggested that it may be better if we communicated via telephone although since you already wrote that you’ve been speaking to an attorney regarding the order, accusing us of both racketeering and / or extortion, I told him the more we have ‘in writing’ the better. So here we are, in writing, acknowledging that we could not deliver you the specific vehicle you ordered.
I certainly apologize that we are not able to provide you with the vehicle you ordered and for any subsequent miscommunication…we will return whatever monies you may have given us as a deposit / partial payment.
Thank you and have a nice weekend.
Marc Wigler
President & General Manager
Crown Automotive Group of Dublin
Mr. Santini –
I apologize for the delayed response - we investigated the circumstances surrounding the order for a 2021 Mercedes-Benz G 63W4- unless you have something else documented, it appears that all we have in writing is a copy of what we refer to as a ‘build sheet’ not an agreement, we actually are relying on the verbal agreements/communication made back in December 2020. As I’m sure you understand, we were not able to obtain or fufill the order on a 2021 G63W4 ( the vehicle Kenneth Stuart (Ken) has been telling you about is going to be a 2022 model)….MBUSA has not released the pricing on the 2022’s as of yet.
When we accepted your deposit, it was pre-pandemic- there was no reason to believe we could not fufill your order…our industry was turned upside down once Covid 19 hit – mostly due to severe supply shortages. As an industry, our total sales numbers dropped precipitously – ‘some’ of this was offset by holding more gross profit on a per vehicle basis although the G Wagon was already in short supply back in December 2020 when you first gave us a deposit.
Ken suggested that it may be better if we communicated via telephone although since you already wrote that you’ve been speaking to an attorney regarding the order, accusing us of both racketeering and / or extortion, I told him the more we have ‘in writing’ the better. So here we are, in writing, acknowledging that we could not deliver you the specific vehicle you ordered.
I certainly apologize that we are not able to provide you with the vehicle you ordered and for any subsequent miscommunication…we will return whatever monies you may have given us as a deposit / partial payment.
Thank you and have a nice weekend.
Marc Wigler
President & General Manager
Crown Automotive Group of Dublin
#125
Newbie
Join Date: Apr 2022
Location: North East Pennsylvania
Posts: 3
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
S580 2022
March 2022
Let's get a list of dealerships that are at MSRP (and may very well likely give you off MSRP) vs. Dealerships who insist on going forward with this ridiculous upcharging trend.
The more information we as buyers have the more power we have. THERE IS NO S-CLASS SHORTAGE. Each dealership I spoke to had multiple on the lot ane numerous at VPC or en route. Plently also had 2022's at VPC or being built without a customer's name attached to it.
Upcharge Wall of Shame:
Mercedes Benz of Massapequa
Benzel-Busch Mercedes
Silver Star Mercedes (+$15k lol)
Mercedes Benz of Kansas City !!!!!
At MSRP:
Mercedes-Benz Manhattan
Rallye Mercedes
White Plains Mercedes
MB Southampton (Purchased here; few grand off)
Please add to this list by copy pasting it and adding your information.
The more information we as buyers have the more power we have. THERE IS NO S-CLASS SHORTAGE. Each dealership I spoke to had multiple on the lot ane numerous at VPC or en route. Plently also had 2022's at VPC or being built without a customer's name attached to it.
Upcharge Wall of Shame:
Mercedes Benz of Massapequa
Benzel-Busch Mercedes
Silver Star Mercedes (+$15k lol)
Mercedes Benz of Kansas City !!!!!
At MSRP:
Mercedes-Benz Manhattan
Rallye Mercedes
White Plains Mercedes
MB Southampton (Purchased here; few grand off)
Please add to this list by copy pasting it and adding your information.