Car Locked Me Out With Key, Phone and Wallet Inside
#1
Member
Thread Starter
Car Locked Me Out With Key, Phone and Wallet Inside
This is a first: I was at the gas station and stepped out of my car to fill up. I left my phone, wallet and keys inside the car with the car turned off. (I use my Apple Watch to pay for gas). The car then locked itself with everything inside. I had no way to open the car! I was able to call my buddy on my Apple Watch to have him sign in to MercedesMe on his phone, and after multiple attempts, he was able to unlock my car. To say I was p(ssed off is a huge understatement. I called Mercedes Customer Service and explained the situation. Nice lady by the way, and I apologized up front for being an ***, but I was really mad. I was holding up the gas pump and worse, I was locked out of my damn car! She proceeded to tell me that that was by design and the car will lock itself in this scenario to protect itself. I asked if I had called Customer Service, would she have been able to unlock the car? She said no, they would have sent someone to jimmy the door and get me in. I told her this was a horrible design flaw not only because it can lock the owner out of their car, but it is a horrible security feature; not for the car, but for its owner. I said, what if my wife had been at a remote gas station in the middle of nowhere and this happened to her? And she didn't have an Apple Watch to call to someone? There are no payphones anymore, and she would have had to find someone nearby with a phone so she could call me or someone to help. The Customer Servicer person' response was "You should always take your key with you when you exit the vehicle". No sh)t.
Obviously, I'm still worked up over this and usually know better than to write something when I'm mad, but this really got me going.
I thought it was impossible to lock your keys in the car, so has anyone else ever had this happen?
Obviously, I'm still worked up over this and usually know better than to write something when I'm mad, but this really got me going.
I thought it was impossible to lock your keys in the car, so has anyone else ever had this happen?
Last edited by Mem30306; 05-27-2024 at 02:17 PM.
The following 2 users liked this post by Mem30306:
MBS63AMG (05-30-2024),
Streamliner (05-27-2024)
#2
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Feb 2002
Location: 2000 ft over the Fl coast in a B-17
Posts: 5,814
Received 255 Likes
on
183 Posts
This is a first: I was at the gas station and stepped out of my car to fill up. I left my phone, wallet and keys inside the car with the car turned off. (I use my Apple Watch to pay for gas). The car then locked itself with everything inside. I had no way to open the car! I was able to call my buddy on my Apple Watch to have him sign in to MercedesMe on his phone, and after multiple attempts, he was able to unlock my car. To say I was p(ssed off is a huge understatement. I called Mercedes Customer Service and explained the situation. Nice lady by the way, and I apologized up front for being an ***, but I was really mad. I was holding up the gas pump and worse, I was locked out of my damn car! She proceeded to tell me that that was by design and the car will lock itself in this scenario to protect itself. I asked if I had called Customer Service, would she have been able to unlock the car? She said no, they would have sent someone to jimmy the door and get me in. I told her this was a horrible design flaw not only because it can lock the owner out of their car, but it is a horrible security feature; not for the car, but for its owner. I said, what if my wife had been at a remote gas station in the middle of nowhere and this happened to her? And she didn't have an Apple Watch to call to someone? There are no payphones anymore, and she would have had to find someone nearby with a phone so she could call me or someone to help. The Customer Servicer person' response was "You should always take your key with you when you exit the vehicle". No sh)t.
Obviously, I'm still worked up over this and usually know better than to write something when I'm mad, but this really got me going.
I thought it was impossible to lock your keys in the car, so has anyone else ever had this happen?
Obviously, I'm still worked up over this and usually know better than to write something when I'm mad, but this really got me going.
I thought it was impossible to lock your keys in the car, so has anyone else ever had this happen?
The following users liked this post:
Streamliner (05-27-2024)
#3
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Nov 2018
Location: San Francisco Bay Area
Posts: 8,543
Received 3,890 Likes
on
2,602 Posts
2019 C63CS
What is the situation that the customer service rep referenced? The only situation I'm aware of in which the car locks itself is if it was locked and then you unlock it, but don't open one of the front doors within 30 seconds. It then relocks itself as it assumes it was accidently unlocked. Similar to a butt-dial if you have your phone in your pocket. It doesn't seem like this was the situation, though, since your key etc. was inside of the car.
The only other thing to keep in mind, is that this and the last generation of key fobs have motion sensors in them and they automatically deactivate after two minutes if they don't sense any motion. This is to prevent relay attacks. This also means that the car no longer detects your key fob if you let it sit inside of the car and you could accidently lock it in for example if you press the close and lock button on the trunk. I've almost locked in my key and phone this way a few times after a bike ride, but luckily the fob was still awake and so the trunk popped back open after a couple of seconds to retrieve it.
Definitely curious about the sequence of events that lead to this.
The only other thing to keep in mind, is that this and the last generation of key fobs have motion sensors in them and they automatically deactivate after two minutes if they don't sense any motion. This is to prevent relay attacks. This also means that the car no longer detects your key fob if you let it sit inside of the car and you could accidently lock it in for example if you press the close and lock button on the trunk. I've almost locked in my key and phone this way a few times after a bike ride, but luckily the fob was still awake and so the trunk popped back open after a couple of seconds to retrieve it.
Definitely curious about the sequence of events that lead to this.
The following users liked this post:
Mem30306 (05-27-2024)
#4
Member
Thread Starter
Thanks @superswiss - This is likely the scenario that occurred. I had left the gym so only had on gym shorts with no pockets and placed my keyfob in the cup holder. So, it had been stationary for a while. I got out of the car and closed the door behind me. The doors locked and set this process in motion.
With that said, there have been MANY times I've left my phone, key and wallet in the car and left it unlocked for hours at a time. I'm really uncertain what caused the car to lock itself this time.
If this is indeed a "feature", there have been many times when I'd like to lock the key in my car, such as a bike ride, run or otherwise don't want to take the key with me. I'll have my phone with me and can unlock the car with MercedesMe upon my return. But touching the handle to lock the doors has never worked for me, but it appears I must wait two minutes for the key to go idle, then the car will lock itself? Or will I need to touch the handle to then lock the doors?
With that said, there have been MANY times I've left my phone, key and wallet in the car and left it unlocked for hours at a time. I'm really uncertain what caused the car to lock itself this time.
If this is indeed a "feature", there have been many times when I'd like to lock the key in my car, such as a bike ride, run or otherwise don't want to take the key with me. I'll have my phone with me and can unlock the car with MercedesMe upon my return. But touching the handle to lock the doors has never worked for me, but it appears I must wait two minutes for the key to go idle, then the car will lock itself? Or will I need to touch the handle to then lock the doors?
Last edited by Mem30306; 05-27-2024 at 02:55 PM.
#5
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Nov 2018
Location: San Francisco Bay Area
Posts: 8,543
Received 3,890 Likes
on
2,602 Posts
2019 C63CS
Thanks @superswiss - This is likely the scenario that occurred. I had left the gym so only had on gym shorts with no pockets and placed my keyfob in the cup holder. So, it had been stationary for a while. I got out of the car and closed the door behind me. The doors locked and set this process in motion.
If this is indeed a "feature", there have been many times when I'd like to lock the key in my car, such as a bike ride, run or otherwise don't want to take the key with me. I'll have my phone with me and can unlock the car with MercedesMe upon my return. But touching the handle to lock the doors has never worked for me, but it appears I must wait two minutes for the key to go idle, then the car will lock itself? Or will I need to touch the handle to then lock the doors?
If this is indeed a "feature", there have been many times when I'd like to lock the key in my car, such as a bike ride, run or otherwise don't want to take the key with me. I'll have my phone with me and can unlock the car with MercedesMe upon my return. But touching the handle to lock the doors has never worked for me, but it appears I must wait two minutes for the key to go idle, then the car will lock itself? Or will I need to touch the handle to then lock the doors?
I'm not sure if this actually works, but the only other situation I could think of is if you press the lock button on the inside of the door and then slam the door shut. But I thought it won't let you do that while the door is open. Just curious, did it actually lock, or did it just retract the door handles? The latter would make a lot more sense. If the fob went to sleep, then the door handles retract, but the car is not locked. You can swipe across the handle to extend them again as shown in the video below.
Last edited by superswiss; 05-27-2024 at 03:08 PM.
#6
Member
Thread Starter
The car was definitely locked with the door handles retracted. When my buddy logged in to MercedesMe on his phone, he attempted to unlock the doors, but couldn't. He kept getting "processing" on his phone. He then tried to start the car, and I got the notification on my watch that he did, but the car never started. The door handles popped out at one point, and although I could pull on the handles, the doors wouldn't open. The car was honestly acting as if I was inside the car and someone was attempted to get inside the car.
I tried swiping the door handles, press the unlock divot on the handle, tried to open the trunk, nadda. My buddy then suggested that I stop trying to get in the car and let it sit for a bit. After a couple of minutes, he was then able to unlock the car and I could get in. He was seconds away from driving to my location with my second key (which he has for emergencies), but thankfully he didn't need to do that.
As an aside - you know how this forum lists related topics below the one you're reading. It did the same for me on this topic, and it appears others have chimed in on a similar scenario. The name of his post was "Self Locking" Self Locking - MBWorld.org Forums
I tried swiping the door handles, press the unlock divot on the handle, tried to open the trunk, nadda. My buddy then suggested that I stop trying to get in the car and let it sit for a bit. After a couple of minutes, he was then able to unlock the car and I could get in. He was seconds away from driving to my location with my second key (which he has for emergencies), but thankfully he didn't need to do that.
As an aside - you know how this forum lists related topics below the one you're reading. It did the same for me on this topic, and it appears others have chimed in on a similar scenario. The name of his post was "Self Locking" Self Locking - MBWorld.org Forums
Last edited by Mem30306; 05-27-2024 at 03:19 PM.
#7
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Nov 2018
Location: San Francisco Bay Area
Posts: 8,543
Received 3,890 Likes
on
2,602 Posts
2019 C63CS
More and more sounds like a malfunction, rather than a feature and customer support doesn't seem to have a clue about what's going on. The fact that remote start didn't seem to work, either, also indicates that something was malfunctioning. There have been several reports with these newfangled retractable door handles having issues. In that related thread, several posters also pointed out that the door handles could simply have retracted, but the doors weren't actually locked. I have noticed that retracting and extending the door handles even makes a similar sound as locking/unlocking. So far haven't run into issues with them myself. Just had an EQS 580 loaner for about a week and they worked properly. I did have an S 500 loaner at one point last year and I do remember the door handles kept extending and retracting for seemingly no reason. It never locked my out, but FWIW I always had the fob in my pocket.
The following users liked this post:
Mem30306 (05-27-2024)
Trending Topics
#8
Member
Thread Starter
I suppose what really got me mad was if I had been out in the middle of nowhere and this happened, and I didn't have my Apple Watch with me, my only recourse would have been to walk somewhere to find a phone, or to flag down someone on the road and ask to use their phone. Short of that, if a phone was miles away, or if I was injured, etc., the only recourse would have been to break a window to gain access to the car.
Except for when I had my blowout at night on 285 here in Atlanta, my car has never stranded me. But this could have gone wrong quickly in the above-mentioned scenario. I work in technology, so I know technology isn't foolproof, so my takeaway from this event is to do as the customer service agent suggested and always take my key with me.
Except for when I had my blowout at night on 285 here in Atlanta, my car has never stranded me. But this could have gone wrong quickly in the above-mentioned scenario. I work in technology, so I know technology isn't foolproof, so my takeaway from this event is to do as the customer service agent suggested and always take my key with me.
Last edited by Mem30306; 05-27-2024 at 04:42 PM.
#9
Super Member
![](https://mbworld.org/forums/images/ranks/veteran_army.png)
![](https://mbworld.org/forums/images/ranks/veteran_navy.png)
Not for nothing, but I never leave my keys in my car unless I have the top down, or at least 1 window open. Once burned, twice shy.
The following users liked this post:
dmatre (05-27-2024)
#12
Member
Thread Starter
#13
Member
Thread Starter
The car was actually locked. What's strange about the whole thing is that the lights on the instrument panel were light up as if I was in the car. That's the assumption my buddy and I made was that somehow the car thought I was inside. We think that's the reason the doors locked and wouldn't let him start the car. I've tried on several occasions over the weekend to replicate the issue, but can't.
#14
Member
This happened to me once, and I have debugged it to the key and the iPhone being next to each other in the cupholder. It basically pretty much renders the key useless, and the car is unable to detect the fact that it is inside. The car did not lock itself though, I think I somehow ended up doing that as I hit the lock button on the trunk. Same could have happened with the handle too, but my situation was the trunk button.
You can run an experiment. Approach a locked car, with the key and your iphone next to each other in hand, and see if the keyless entry works. If it does, then that is not it, but for me, it never does. MY18 S560 FWIW...
You can run an experiment. Approach a locked car, with the key and your iphone next to each other in hand, and see if the keyless entry works. If it does, then that is not it, but for me, it never does. MY18 S560 FWIW...
#15
Thanks for posting that video. I noticed when the handles retract back in the door and I walk to it the handles don't pop out. I then attempt to swipe the handle like the video suggests but half of the time it doesn't work.
On another occasion I drove by buddies to get their car from the car hauler after a Rally and left my car running with keyfob in my pocket. It was running at least 10 minutes while we were talking to the driver. Said our good byes and walked towards the car and noticed the handles retracted back in. Swiped the handle and nothing. Even tried pressing the unlock button on the fob and nothing. Then tried swiping the rears and the front handles and the unlock and after what seemed like 15 seconds, the handles popped out. Any idea?
On another occasion I drove by buddies to get their car from the car hauler after a Rally and left my car running with keyfob in my pocket. It was running at least 10 minutes while we were talking to the driver. Said our good byes and walked towards the car and noticed the handles retracted back in. Swiped the handle and nothing. Even tried pressing the unlock button on the fob and nothing. Then tried swiping the rears and the front handles and the unlock and after what seemed like 15 seconds, the handles popped out. Any idea?
#16
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Europe
Posts: 6,382
Received 295 Likes
on
247 Posts
223.168 & 213.012 & 906.633 & 214.005
This happened to me once, and I have debugged it to the key and the iPhone being next to each other in the cupholder. It basically pretty much renders the key useless, and the car is unable to detect the fact that it is inside. The car did not lock itself though, I think I somehow ended up doing that as I hit the lock button on the trunk. Same could have happened with the handle too, but my situation was the trunk button.
You can run an experiment. Approach a locked car, with the key and your iphone next to each other in hand, and see if the keyless entry works. If it does, then that is not it, but for me, it never does. MY18 S560 FWIW...
You can run an experiment. Approach a locked car, with the key and your iphone next to each other in hand, and see if the keyless entry works. If it does, then that is not it, but for me, it never does. MY18 S560 FWIW...
I understand the iPhone next to the key may make the key "disappear" but the car still should never lock doors itself except the scenario superswiss explained earlier or while you are driving and doors are set to be locked at certain speed.
There must be a SW/HW bug involved, hopefully someone can replicate the complete sequence to trigger the fault (it can then be fixed and/or avoided).
#17
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: CT
Posts: 1,414
Received 83 Likes
on
55 Posts
BMW, Tesla, Mercedes, Porsche, Cadillac
Thanks for posting that video. I noticed when the handles retract back in the door and I walk to it the handles don't pop out. I then attempt to swipe the handle like the video suggests but half of the time it doesn't work.
On another occasion I drove by buddies to get their car from the car hauler after a Rally and left my car running with keyfob in my pocket. It was running at least 10 minutes while we were talking to the driver. Said our good byes and walked towards the car and noticed the handles retracted back in. Swiped the handle and nothing. Even tried pressing the unlock button on the fob and nothing. Then tried swiping the rears and the front handles and the unlock and after what seemed like 15 seconds, the handles popped out. Any idea?
On another occasion I drove by buddies to get their car from the car hauler after a Rally and left my car running with keyfob in my pocket. It was running at least 10 minutes while we were talking to the driver. Said our good byes and walked towards the car and noticed the handles retracted back in. Swiped the handle and nothing. Even tried pressing the unlock button on the fob and nothing. Then tried swiping the rears and the front handles and the unlock and after what seemed like 15 seconds, the handles popped out. Any idea?
The following users liked this post:
crabman (05-30-2024)
#18
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: CT
Posts: 1,414
Received 83 Likes
on
55 Posts
BMW, Tesla, Mercedes, Porsche, Cadillac
But you shouldn't be able to lock the car from the trunk button if you don't have your key with you?
I understand the iPhone next to the key may make the key "disappear" but the car still should never lock doors itself except the scenario superswiss explained earlier or while you are driving and doors are set to be locked at certain speed.
There must be a SW/HW bug involved, hopefully someone can replicate the complete sequence to trigger the fault (it can then be fixed and/or avoided).
I understand the iPhone next to the key may make the key "disappear" but the car still should never lock doors itself except the scenario superswiss explained earlier or while you are driving and doors are set to be locked at certain speed.
There must be a SW/HW bug involved, hopefully someone can replicate the complete sequence to trigger the fault (it can then be fixed and/or avoided).
#19
Member
On both my 2018 S560 and 2021 GLS450, once the trunk is open, it does not need the key in the vicinity to close and lock the vehicle. It just will not do that if the key is actually in the vehicle cabin somewhere.
#20
Thank you for sharing, Quad. I'll try that next time it happens.
#21
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Nov 2018
Location: San Francisco Bay Area
Posts: 8,543
Received 3,890 Likes
on
2,602 Posts
2019 C63CS
![](https://cimg5.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.mbworld.org-vbulletin/956x702/screenshot_2024_05_29_102503_53109d51a740d11199ad5d3730a7a25a99cb29bd.jpg)
The following users liked this post:
Mem30306 (05-29-2024)
#22
Member
Thread Starter
After reading through these posts, here is what MAY have happened - I'll need to test to see if I can duplicate so MBUSA can be made aware:
- I exited the car leaving my wallet in the storage area in the center console, my phone and key were against each other in the side area next to the cup holders (actually touching each other), but my phone was not in the charging area.
- I did not lock the doors, but I did open the trunk either from the trunk release button on the driver's door or from the latch release on the trunk (I can't remember which) then got out some items out of the trunk that I tossed in the trashcan near the gas pumps
- What I did next may be the key (no pun intended) - I either touched the close button on the trunk lid or I touched the lock button on the trunk lid
- After I finished refueling, I realized the doors were locked.
#23
Junior Member
I think it’s smart to keep a spare key in a safe place, but not inside the car. Some people carry a spare in their wallet or hide it in a magnetic box under the car. Just be aware that hiding it under the car can be a bit risky.
#24
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Europe
Posts: 6,382
Received 295 Likes
on
247 Posts
223.168 & 213.012 & 906.633 & 214.005
After reading through these posts, here is what MAY have happened - I'll need to test to see if I can duplicate so MBUSA can be made aware:
- I exited the car leaving my wallet in the storage area in the center console, my phone and key were against each other in the side area next to the cup holders (actually touching each other), but my phone was not in the charging area.
- I did not lock the doors, but I did open the trunk either from the trunk release button on the driver's door or from the latch release on the trunk (I can't remember which) then got out some items out of the trunk that I tossed in the trashcan near the gas pumps
- What I did next may be the key (no pun intended) - I either touched the close button on the trunk lid or I touched the lock button on the trunk lid
- After I finished refueling, I realized the doors were locked.
The following users liked this post:
Mem30306 (05-29-2024)
#25
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Nov 2018
Location: San Francisco Bay Area
Posts: 8,543
Received 3,890 Likes
on
2,602 Posts
2019 C63CS
Originally Posted by Diesel Benz
I just tried this, the lock button on the trunk lid does nothing when I did not have the key with me. The close trunk button did work but doors remained open.
Last edited by superswiss; 05-29-2024 at 03:57 PM.