SL/R231: Auxiliary Battery Type?
#26
Member
I have been told by the Shop Foreman @ my dealer that the best way to keep a maintenance charge on the SL is via the main battery in the trunk so my trickle charger is connected to the main batt posts.
I suspect that the jump posts in the engine compartment bypass the main and aux battery and likely connect only to the starter ckt thereby protecting the main and aux batteries from an overcurrent surge when jump starting.
I may be wrong but, if someone has a circuit schematic maybe we can figure this out.
I suspect that the jump posts in the engine compartment bypass the main and aux battery and likely connect only to the starter ckt thereby protecting the main and aux batteries from an overcurrent surge when jump starting.
I may be wrong but, if someone has a circuit schematic maybe we can figure this out.
I’ll check it out the next time I’m in the trunk and report back.
Re: charging from jump posts. As most here are maintaining/charging our batteries via the jump posts under the hood, I’m guessing the jump posts are connect directly to the main battery.
#28
Member
I have a set of shop docs now and have been studying the wiring diagrams relative to this topic.
The Aux battery (official name is: "ECO Start/Stop function additional battery") is normally isolated from the main battery and most of the loads in the car by a relay controlled by a computer. It's not clear from the drawings what happens when the car is shut down, but my guess is that the Aux battery remains isolated from the main battery by that relay. The Aux battery does have two modules directly connected to it. Those are the Ignition module (the one behind the START button) and a module on the transmission that controls gear selection. This is to allow the car to recognize the key fob and then allow shifting the transmission out of Park if the main battery is dead. Those modules are always connected so there probably is a very small draw from the Aux battery when the car is shut down.
The apparent main function of the Aux battery is to support the ECO start/stop function, which probably almost no one uses. If you're using that feature and the engine shuts off at a stop light then when re-start is required the computer opens a relay at the main battery to isolate it from all loads except the starter. At the same time, the computer closes the relay to the Aux battery so that it takes over handling all the loads in the car, except the starter, while the engine is re-starting. The stated purpose is to prevent voltage sag for loads in the car during the re-start, which would be noticeable as dimming of lights, etc.
The docs do state that the system will charge the Aux battery whenever the engine is running, but only if the Aux battery voltage is below a threshold value. It would do this by closing the Aux battery relay. Otherwise, the Aux battery remains isolated along with the 2 modules connected to it.
The Aux battery (official name is: "ECO Start/Stop function additional battery") is normally isolated from the main battery and most of the loads in the car by a relay controlled by a computer. It's not clear from the drawings what happens when the car is shut down, but my guess is that the Aux battery remains isolated from the main battery by that relay. The Aux battery does have two modules directly connected to it. Those are the Ignition module (the one behind the START button) and a module on the transmission that controls gear selection. This is to allow the car to recognize the key fob and then allow shifting the transmission out of Park if the main battery is dead. Those modules are always connected so there probably is a very small draw from the Aux battery when the car is shut down.
The apparent main function of the Aux battery is to support the ECO start/stop function, which probably almost no one uses. If you're using that feature and the engine shuts off at a stop light then when re-start is required the computer opens a relay at the main battery to isolate it from all loads except the starter. At the same time, the computer closes the relay to the Aux battery so that it takes over handling all the loads in the car, except the starter, while the engine is re-starting. The stated purpose is to prevent voltage sag for loads in the car during the re-start, which would be noticeable as dimming of lights, etc.
The docs do state that the system will charge the Aux battery whenever the engine is running, but only if the Aux battery voltage is below a threshold value. It would do this by closing the Aux battery relay. Otherwise, the Aux battery remains isolated along with the 2 modules connected to it.
The following 3 users liked this post by jmattioni:
#29
Member
The only reason I mentioned that was I read somewhere not to do a battery test using a multimeter via the engine compartment because there will be resistance in the the cables. So would the same resistance be felt when using a battery charger.
#30
Member
I have a set of shop docs now and have been studying the wiring diagrams relative to this topic.
The Aux battery (official name is: "ECO Start/Stop function additional battery") is normally isolated from the main battery and most of the loads in the car by a relay controlled by a computer. It's not clear from the drawings what happens when the car is shut down, but my guess is that the Aux battery remains isolated from the main battery by that relay. The Aux battery does have two modules directly connected to it. Those are the Ignition module (the one behind the START button) and a module on the transmission that controls gear selection. This is to allow the car to recognize the key fob and then allow shifting the transmission out of Park if the main battery is dead. Those modules are always connected so there probably is a very small draw from the Aux battery when the car is shut down.
The apparent main function of the Aux battery is to support the ECO start/stop function, which probably almost no one uses. If you're using that feature and the engine shuts off at a stop light then when re-start is required the computer opens a relay at the main battery to isolate it from all loads except the starter. At the same time, the computer closes the relay to the Aux battery so that it takes over handling all the loads in the car, except the starter, while the engine is re-starting. The stated purpose is to prevent voltage sag for loads in the car during the re-start, which would be noticeable as dimming of lights, etc.
The docs do state that the system will charge the Aux battery whenever the engine is running, but only if the Aux battery voltage is below a threshold value. It would do this by closing the Aux battery relay. Otherwise, the Aux battery remains isolated along with the 2 modules connected to it.
The Aux battery (official name is: "ECO Start/Stop function additional battery") is normally isolated from the main battery and most of the loads in the car by a relay controlled by a computer. It's not clear from the drawings what happens when the car is shut down, but my guess is that the Aux battery remains isolated from the main battery by that relay. The Aux battery does have two modules directly connected to it. Those are the Ignition module (the one behind the START button) and a module on the transmission that controls gear selection. This is to allow the car to recognize the key fob and then allow shifting the transmission out of Park if the main battery is dead. Those modules are always connected so there probably is a very small draw from the Aux battery when the car is shut down.
The apparent main function of the Aux battery is to support the ECO start/stop function, which probably almost no one uses. If you're using that feature and the engine shuts off at a stop light then when re-start is required the computer opens a relay at the main battery to isolate it from all loads except the starter. At the same time, the computer closes the relay to the Aux battery so that it takes over handling all the loads in the car, except the starter, while the engine is re-starting. The stated purpose is to prevent voltage sag for loads in the car during the re-start, which would be noticeable as dimming of lights, etc.
The docs do state that the system will charge the Aux battery whenever the engine is running, but only if the Aux battery voltage is below a threshold value. It would do this by closing the Aux battery relay. Otherwise, the Aux battery remains isolated along with the 2 modules connected to it.
I just confirmed on my vehicle that the aux battery is not charged when a maintenance charger is connected to either the jump posts under the hood or to the main battery posts, so you’re right: the aux is isolated. However, your last para suggests that the aux may charge from the above locations if it goes below its threshold voltage. I could confirm one way or another by draining the aux to say 11 volts or so, but that won’t happen any time soon.
Again, thanks for your post; It’s the best explanation I've read so far.
#31
Member
All that being said, a purest would measure and charge directly from the battery's posts as I probably would if it was convenient.
The following users liked this post:
rorywquin (11-21-2020)
#32
Member
I just confirmed on my vehicle that the aux battery is not charged when a maintenance charger is connected to either the jump posts under the hood or to the main battery posts, so you’re right: the aux is isolated. However, your last para suggests that the aux may charge from the above locations if it goes below its threshold voltage. I could confirm one way or another by draining the aux to say 11 volts or so, but that won’t happen any time soon.
I'm not sure about the Aux battery handling only light loads. The wiring shows it connected to the main bus during the re-start. The Aux battery probably has enough juice to handle the load for the 1-2 seconds required to re-start the engine. The overview description (copy attached) states that "Active Comfort functions are not switched off". The system does detect if the Aux battery is weak by monitoring the voltage when it takes over the load. It'll disable the function for a period of time, and activate charging of the Aux battery, if the bus voltage dips too much during the re-start (also in the overview attached - at the very bottom of the doc).
#33
Member
Yes, it's possible that the computer would enable charging of the Aux battery while the car is off if a charging voltage (>13V) is present, but I'm not convinced that would happen. I did a measurement at the Aux battery with a charger connected to the jumper terminals and saw no effect. Then again my Aux battery is fully charged and measured >12.5V. The logic for this would be in software, so only MB can say for sure.
I'm not sure either, but I agree it’s not likely.
I'm not sure about the Aux battery handling only light loads. The wiring shows it connected to the main bus during the re-start. The Aux battery probably has enough juice to handle the load for the 1-2 seconds required to re-start the engine. The overview description (copy attached) states that "Active Comfort functions are not switched off". The system does detect if the Aux battery is weak by monitoring the voltage when it takes over the load. It'll disable the function for a period of time, and activate charging of the Aux battery, if the bus voltage dips too much during the re-start (also in the overview attached - at the very bottom of the doc).
I'm not sure either, but I agree it’s not likely.
I'm not sure about the Aux battery handling only light loads. The wiring shows it connected to the main bus during the re-start. The Aux battery probably has enough juice to handle the load for the 1-2 seconds required to re-start the engine. The overview description (copy attached) states that "Active Comfort functions are not switched off". The system does detect if the Aux battery is weak by monitoring the voltage when it takes over the load. It'll disable the function for a period of time, and activate charging of the Aux battery, if the bus voltage dips too much during the re-start (also in the overview attached - at the very bottom of the doc).
Thanks again for the info. I did the Airforce and NASA thing (32 yrs) and eat this stuff up.
#34
MBWorld Fanatic!
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2015
Location: Hagerstown MD
Posts: 1,376
Received 422 Likes
on
312 Posts
2015 SL400; 2019 X5M40i
The ability to shift out of Park when the main battery is dead is an important feature. I have already heard about some C8 Corvette owners stranded with a dead battery and unable to get their car up on a flatbed because they couldn't get the transmission out of park.
Last edited by rmorin49; 02-09-2021 at 07:21 AM.
The following users liked this post:
jmattioni (11-18-2020)
#35
Member
hornethandler: The main battery is directly tied to all loads EXCEPT for the Ignition module and Transmission module, which are tied directly to the Aux battery and get isolated along with it. What actually happens when the car is off depends on what the computer does with the ECO start/stop relay, but as best I can tell the Aux battery (and its two loads) are isolated. So a healthy Aux battery is pretty important if you want to start your car or get the trans into Neutral.
There are a few overview documents in the shop docs, like the one I posted. I should point out that the simplified diagrams in that ECO overview are not entirely correct relative to the actual wiring diagrams. For one they have the batteries in backwards in those diagrams. Despite that it's still a reasonably accurate overview.
My background is in EE. I'm now retired, but did consulting for most of my career.
There are a few overview documents in the shop docs, like the one I posted. I should point out that the simplified diagrams in that ECO overview are not entirely correct relative to the actual wiring diagrams. For one they have the batteries in backwards in those diagrams. Despite that it's still a reasonably accurate overview.
My background is in EE. I'm now retired, but did consulting for most of my career.
#37
Member
For storage this is basically what the MB shop docs say to do:
1. Ensure all batteries are fully charged (includes main and aux batteries)
2. Disconnect ground cables on both batteries
With the ground cables removed they recommend checking battery charge only every 6 months. So this would get you through a typical Winter in most places.
If you don't disconnect a battery then they recommend checking the battery charge every 6 weeks. The Aux battery does have a small load on it so the 6-week rule would apply to it as well if it isn't disconnected.
There's no guidance in the shop docs that I can find on using battery maintainers, though I don't see why they wouldn't be OK. The catch is that you may need to have two - one for each battery. It must be a battery maintainer (e.g., battery tender). A regular dumb charger left on a battery would eventually overcharge it causing damage to the battery.
If you store your car for the Winter it seems like the safest approach would be to follow the MB guidance and disconnect both batteries. If you rent a storage location they may require you to do this anyway. Only a depleted battery is really susceptible to freezing in most locations. Then again, if you're somewhere temps often get well below 0F you should probably consider removing the batteries. The biggest risk of a battery freezing is that it cracks open and leaks acid, though I don't think AGM batteries would leak as badly as the old wet batteries.
I drive my SL in the Winter as long as it's not snowing and the roads are clear. If you drive it at least once every 6 weeks or so you shouldn't have to do anything special to the batteries if they're healthy.
1. Ensure all batteries are fully charged (includes main and aux batteries)
2. Disconnect ground cables on both batteries
With the ground cables removed they recommend checking battery charge only every 6 months. So this would get you through a typical Winter in most places.
If you don't disconnect a battery then they recommend checking the battery charge every 6 weeks. The Aux battery does have a small load on it so the 6-week rule would apply to it as well if it isn't disconnected.
There's no guidance in the shop docs that I can find on using battery maintainers, though I don't see why they wouldn't be OK. The catch is that you may need to have two - one for each battery. It must be a battery maintainer (e.g., battery tender). A regular dumb charger left on a battery would eventually overcharge it causing damage to the battery.
If you store your car for the Winter it seems like the safest approach would be to follow the MB guidance and disconnect both batteries. If you rent a storage location they may require you to do this anyway. Only a depleted battery is really susceptible to freezing in most locations. Then again, if you're somewhere temps often get well below 0F you should probably consider removing the batteries. The biggest risk of a battery freezing is that it cracks open and leaks acid, though I don't think AGM batteries would leak as badly as the old wet batteries.
I drive my SL in the Winter as long as it's not snowing and the roads are clear. If you drive it at least once every 6 weeks or so you shouldn't have to do anything special to the batteries if they're healthy.
#38
Member
However, I may be wrong about no power being consumed from the aux. See above post from jmattioni.
Last edited by hornethandler; 11-18-2020 at 12:26 PM. Reason: Additional info
#39
Member
For storage this is basically what the MB shop docs say to do:
1. Ensure all batteries are fully charged (includes main and aux batteries)
2. Disconnect ground cables on both batteries
With the ground cables removed they recommend checking battery charge only every 6 months. So this would get you through a typical Winter in most places.
If you don't disconnect a battery then they recommend checking the battery charge every 6 weeks. The Aux battery does have a small load on it so the 6-week rule would apply to it as well if it isn't disconnected.
There's no guidance in the shop docs that I can find on using battery maintainers, though I don't see why they wouldn't be OK. The catch is that you may need to have two - one for each battery. It must be a battery maintainer (e.g., battery tender). A regular dumb charger left on a battery would eventually overcharge it causing damage to the battery.
If you store your car for the Winter it seems like the safest approach would be to follow the MB guidance and disconnect both batteries. If you rent a storage location they may require you to do this anyway. Only a depleted battery is really susceptible to freezing in most locations. Then again, if you're somewhere temps often get well below 0F you should probably consider removing the batteries. The biggest risk of a battery freezing is that it cracks open and leaks acid, though I don't think AGM batteries would leak as badly as the old wet batteries.
I drive my SL in the Winter as long as it's not snowing and the roads are clear. If you drive it at least once every 6 weeks or so you shouldn't have to do anything special to the batteries if they're healthy.
1. Ensure all batteries are fully charged (includes main and aux batteries)
2. Disconnect ground cables on both batteries
With the ground cables removed they recommend checking battery charge only every 6 months. So this would get you through a typical Winter in most places.
If you don't disconnect a battery then they recommend checking the battery charge every 6 weeks. The Aux battery does have a small load on it so the 6-week rule would apply to it as well if it isn't disconnected.
There's no guidance in the shop docs that I can find on using battery maintainers, though I don't see why they wouldn't be OK. The catch is that you may need to have two - one for each battery. It must be a battery maintainer (e.g., battery tender). A regular dumb charger left on a battery would eventually overcharge it causing damage to the battery.
If you store your car for the Winter it seems like the safest approach would be to follow the MB guidance and disconnect both batteries. If you rent a storage location they may require you to do this anyway. Only a depleted battery is really susceptible to freezing in most locations. Then again, if you're somewhere temps often get well below 0F you should probably consider removing the batteries. The biggest risk of a battery freezing is that it cracks open and leaks acid, though I don't think AGM batteries would leak as badly as the old wet batteries.
I drive my SL in the Winter as long as it's not snowing and the roads are clear. If you drive it at least once every 6 weeks or so you shouldn't have to do anything special to the batteries if they're healthy.
Do you know what load is on the Aux when the vehicle is off?
#40
MBWorld Fanatic!
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2015
Location: Hagerstown MD
Posts: 1,376
Received 422 Likes
on
312 Posts
2015 SL400; 2019 X5M40i
I have 2 CTEK Model 4.3 maintainers, one for each battery. I put them on if the car will sit for more than a week. I use the under hood post for the main battery and a pigtail on the auxiliary battery that was installed by the previous owner.
#41
Member
Do you know what load is on the Aux when the vehicle is off?
#43
Super Member
#44
I live in Massachusetts. The car sits from November until April. In that case I would leave a trickle charger on each battery. During the spring and summer, sometimes the vehicle sits a week at a time. Which battery would you suggest I leave the trickle on for the spring and summer months? 2016 SL550.
#45
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Jan 2017
Location: God's County (Yorkshire)
Posts: 1,040
Received 233 Likes
on
189 Posts
Shanks’s Pony
I live in Massachusetts. The car sits from November until April. In that case I would leave a trickle charger on each battery. During the spring and summer, sometimes the vehicle sits a week at a time. Which battery would you suggest I leave the trickle on for the spring and summer months? 2016 SL550.
#46
Member
I live in Massachusetts. The car sits from November until April. In that case I would leave a trickle charger on each battery. During the spring and summer, sometimes the vehicle sits a week at a time. Which battery would you suggest I leave the trickle on for the spring and summer months? 2016 SL550.
#47
Member
I live in Massachusetts. The car sits from November until April. In that case I would leave a trickle charger on each battery. During the spring and summer, sometimes the vehicle sits a week at a time. Which battery would you suggest I leave the trickle on for the spring and summer months? 2016 SL550.
The question of whether the Aux battery (Aux) accepts a charge from an external source (trickle/maintenance charger) connected to the jump posts under the hood is much discussed. From the posts at 23, 24, 28, and 30 above, it appears we’re getting close to understanding. What is confirmed is that the Aux battery does not accept a charge from the battery jump posts under the hood for a trickle/maintenance charge; however, there is speculation the Aux may take a charge from the posts if the Aux falls below a set minimum, but that is not yet verified.
However, there is a solution that makes our battery concerns completely go away: Drive it like you stole it and you'll always be fully charged!
#48
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Jan 2017
Location: God's County (Yorkshire)
Posts: 1,040
Received 233 Likes
on
189 Posts
Shanks’s Pony
@hornethandler
Apologies for the large type - tried a few times to change - no joy.
My understanding from the below is that if the aux battery voltage is too low, a relay closes and puts the aux into the charging circuit. Ergo charging from jumpstarter posts will also charge a low aux. This has been my experience when not using my car for a while and the amber ECO light comes on (i.e. Stop/Start not available because of low AUX battery), I'll put the car on charger and the amber light will eventually be extinguished indicating that the aux has been charged....
Why would MB have a setup with two batteries where a Heath Robinson setup is needed to get the AUX batteries charged while the vehicle is not in use for long periods? Does not make any sense.Charging from the jump starter posts is proven to work for me.
C Dual Battery Systems
The dual battery system isolates all power supply sensitive electrical components which may be affected by low voltage from the primary battery during the engine starting phase.
Two contact switches are used to change the power supply into two separate circuits when an engine start is required.
Electrical power is then supplied to the sensitive electrical components from the secondary battery when an engine start is in progress.
The primary battery supplies power to the starter motor and maintains essential power to the Engine Management System (EMS) which is essential for engine starting.
Primary and secondary battery voltages are monitored to ensure sufficient voltage is available for the next start event and charge can be supplied to the secondary battery when required.
IC Dual Battery System Components
System components:
1. Starter motor2. Primary battery
3. Power & EMS loads
4. Field effect transistor
5. Contact switch 1
6. Contact switch 2
7. Secondary battery
8. Sensitive loads
9. Alternator
IC Dual Battery System Operation
System Conditions – Start Required
• Contact 1 open• Contact 2 closed
The primary battey supplies the starter motor and the secondary battery supports power supply sensitive components
System Conditions – Engine Running
• Contact 1 closed• Contact 2 open
The primary battery is being charged by the alternator and the secondary battery is isolated from the circuit.
If the system detects a low auxiliary battery voltage contact 2 will remain closed once the engine is running to enable the auxiliary battery to be fully charged by the alternator.
Once the auxiliary battery is fully charged contact 2 will open to prevent damage to the axuiliary battery and reduce alternator and consequently engine loads to save fuel and reduce emissions.
Last edited by rorywquin; 04-30-2021 at 08:36 AM.
The following users liked this post:
hornethandler (04-30-2021)
#49
Member
@hornethandler
Apologies for the large type - tried a few times to change - no joy.
My understanding from the below is that if the aux battery voltage is too low, a relay closes and puts the aux into the charging circuit. Ergo charging from jumpstarter posts will also charge a low aux. This has been my experience when not using my car for a while and the amber ECO light comes on (i.e. Stop/Start not available because of low AUX battery), I'll put the car on charger and the amber light will eventually be extinguished indicating that the aux has been charged....
Why would MB have a setup with two batteries where a Heath Robinson setup is needed to get the AUX batteries charged while the vehicle is not in use for long periods? Does not make any sense.Charging from the jump starter posts is proven to work for me.
C Dual Battery Systems
The dual battery system isolates all power supply sensitive electrical components which may be affected by low voltage from the primary battery during the engine starting phase.
Two contact switches are used to change the power supply into two separate circuits when an engine start is required.
Electrical power is then supplied to the sensitive electrical components from the secondary battery when an engine start is in progress.
The primary battery supplies power to the starter motor and maintains essential power to the Engine Management System (EMS) which is essential for engine starting.
Primary and secondary battery voltages are monitored to ensure sufficient voltage is available for the next start event and charge can be supplied to the secondary battery when required.
IC Dual Battery System Components
System components:
1. Starter motor2. Primary battery
3. Power & EMS loads
4. Field effect transistor
5. Contact switch 1
6. Contact switch 2
7. Secondary battery
8. Sensitive loads
9. Alternator
IC Dual Battery System Operation
System Conditions – Start Required
• Contact 1 open• Contact 2 closed
The primary battey supplies the starter motor and the secondary battery supports power supply sensitive components
System Conditions – Engine Running
• Contact 1 closed• Contact 2 open
The primary battery is being charged by the alternator and the secondary battery is isolated from the circuit.
If the system detects a low auxiliary battery voltage contact 2 will remain closed once the engine is running to enable the auxiliary battery to be fully charged by the alternator.
Once the auxiliary battery is fully charged contact 2 will open to prevent damage to the axuiliary battery and reduce alternator and consequently engine loads to save fuel and reduce emissions.
Also, thanks for the diagrams, I’ll add them to the one provide by jmattioni in post 32 above, and provided here again for convenience.
Last edited by hornethandler; 04-30-2021 at 09:43 AM.