SL/R231: Why are keys so expensive????
Today -- I called several (5) local MBZ dealerships to get a quote for a new key. Oh my God. I almost died. The best price I could find was $432 for the fob + $133 for the "blade" (I'm assuming that's the metal key in the fob) + $270 to program it. $887 with tax, and I have to drive the car to them (50 miles each way). I asked if I could send them a photo of the VIN from the door of the car and a copy of my registration, but No. They need to see the actual car. I was told that's in case I'm trying to steal an ex-spouses car. Really??? My name is the only one on the registration, and if I was going to steal my own car, that's between me and the police, not MBZ.
I come from a technology background. I've build high tech hardware and done my share of programming. The fob couldn't cost MBZ more the $25 in parts. The metal key shouldn't be more then $50 (just a key blank and few minutes to cut it). The "programming fee" really threw me for a loop. Programming is a fairly simply and quick process. Plug the key into the programming device, enter the VIN, push "Go", wait a couple of minutes. How does that equate to $270?
I know we're all paying for the privilege of driving an SL, but does MBZ think we're stupid?
I think I'll just get a $25 Apple Air Tag and be done with it.
Ok. I'll get off of my soap box now...
Last edited by Ozzie-95037; Oct 28, 2024 at 03:07 PM.
The blank blades can be purchased separately and cheaper than the dealer. A locksmith with a laser cut machine can make a copy for you. You do NOT need the blade key to use the fob.
I have purchase from NorthCoastKeyless but found out later that an independent locksmith was unable to program the fob because I have a 2015. They are currently out of stock, so you may want to get on their mailing list.
The cost to replace my lost key fob was $650 at the dealer, but I had gotten my own blade and had it cut for $50 elsewhere.
I learned that dealers usually have fobs in stock but cannot cut new blades. Instead, they order a blade already cut from Mercedes and can have it in a couple of days.
You may want to invest in some AirTags or Tile devices and attach them to all of your keys.
I have purchase from NorthCoastKeyless but found out later that an independent locksmith was unable to program the fob because I have a 2015. They are currently out of stock, so you may want to get on their mailing list.
Last edited by Ozzie-95037; Oct 28, 2024 at 08:14 PM.




I had a CLK 430 in the past and dropped my key in a bucket of oil. A replacement key was like $300 and that was round 12 years ago.
Today -- I called several (5) local MBZ dealerships to get a quote for a new key. Oh my God. I almost died. The best price I could find was $432 for the fob + $133 for the "blade" (I'm assuming that's the metal key in the fob) + $270 to program it. $887 with tax, and I have to drive the car to them (50 miles each way). I asked if I could send them a photo of the VIN from the door of the car and a copy of my registration, but No. They need to see the actual car. I was told that's in case I'm trying to steal an ex-spouses car. Really??? My name is the only one on the registration, and if I was going to steal my own car, that's between me and the police, not MBZ.
I come from a technology background. I've build high tech hardware and done my share of programming. The fob couldn't cost MBZ more the $25 in parts. The metal key shouldn't be more then $50 (just a key blank and few minutes to cut it). The "programming fee" really threw me for a loop. Programming is a fairly simply and quick process. Plug the key into the programming device, enter the VIN, push "Go", wait a couple of minutes. How does that equate to $270?
I know we're all paying for the privilege of driving an SL, but does MBZ think we're stupid?
I think I'll just get a $25 Apple Air Tag and be done with it.
Ok. I'll get off of my soap box now...
Last edited by ThatsMyDawg; Oct 29, 2024 at 09:16 AM.
Trending Topics
The Best of Mercedes & AMG








THIS THREAD is a great example of what I'm talking about; search the forums for "ebay keys" and you'll find hundreds more. The key fobs have always required the VIN to order, as they come programmed for that one car. After the 8th key you can't get another, so if you lose 8 keys (or if a succession of owners collectively lose 8 keys) the locks and ignition must be replaced.
Last edited by eddieo45; Nov 4, 2024 at 04:23 PM.
THIS THREAD is a great example of what I'm talking about; search the forums for "ebay keys" and you'll find hundreds more. The key fobs have always required the VIN to order, as they come programmed for that one car. After the 8th key you can't get another, so if you lose 8 keys (or if a succession of owners collectively lose 8 keys) the locks and ignition must be replaced.





Last edited by yteasterling; Nov 5, 2024 at 02:29 PM. Reason: Needed to Tag a user
Last edited by Ozzie-95037; Feb 11, 2025 at 06:07 PM.
With a good recap, including the body piercing, we can put together an all in 1 solution.




NorthCoastKeyless has a way to search for likely locksmiths: https://northcoastkeyless.com/auto-locksmith-finder/
Last edited by JettaRed; Feb 13, 2025 at 05:22 PM.








