Who's has better engineering Italians or Germans?
#26
MBWorld Fanatic!
Being 100% of Italian descent, I am somewhat biased towards Italian products....and aspire to one day own both a Ferrari and Lamborghini. However, I do think that the Germans are the better "technical" engineers. Having owned an E39 M5, Audi RS6 and now CL65, I have witnessed the marvels of German engineering. However, if you are talking about engineering design in the aesthetic sense, then the Italians win out. Both groups of engineers have passion for cars...the Germans focused on the precision of the mechanicals...the Italians focused on the ethereal delights. Two different philosophies....which is probably best combined in VAG's ownership of Lamborghini. I have been to Ferrari's factory in Maranello and Lamborghini's factory in S'Agata Bolognese. The Lamborghiini folks were soooooo extremely nice and genuinely excited to see someone who knows and loves their products. The Ferrari experience was a bit disappointing..everything there was all about $$$'s and overall very cold. So my choice has a Bull on the key chain...preferrably an LP640.
Tom
Tom
#27
MBWorld Fanatic!
The Japanese Do, why did you not include them?
The japanese carmakers are way ahead of the Italians and slightly ahead of the Germans. I would not want to own one, I personally hate Japanese cars, but look at some of the stuff they are doing now and it's amazing. I'm not just talking "go fast engineering" I talking about automotive engineering in general. Hybrid tachnology, fuel cell technology, safety technology, the japs are the hands down leaders I'm sorry to say. But like I said, would not want one in my garage...unless it has 2 wheels.
The japanese carmakers are way ahead of the Italians and slightly ahead of the Germans. I would not want to own one, I personally hate Japanese cars, but look at some of the stuff they are doing now and it's amazing. I'm not just talking "go fast engineering" I talking about automotive engineering in general. Hybrid tachnology, fuel cell technology, safety technology, the japs are the hands down leaders I'm sorry to say. But like I said, would not want one in my garage...unless it has 2 wheels.
Last edited by jrcart; 04-04-2008 at 12:19 PM.
#28
Super Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2005
Location: Chicago, IL
Posts: 648
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
'08 S65, '04 Range Rover(The House), '06 Lexus GS 300(Wifey's), '02 Sea Ray 360 Sundancer
The Japanese Do, why did you not include them?
The japanese carmakers are way ahead of the Italians and slightly ahead of the Germans. I would not want to own one, I personally hate Japanese cars, but look at some of the stuff they are doing now and it's amazing. I'm not just talking "go fast engineering" I talking about automotive engineering in general. Hybrid tachnology, fuel cell technology, safety technology, the japs are the hands down leaders I'm sorry to say. But like I said, would not want one in my garage...unless it has 2 wheels.
The japanese carmakers are way ahead of the Italians and slightly ahead of the Germans. I would not want to own one, I personally hate Japanese cars, but look at some of the stuff they are doing now and it's amazing. I'm not just talking "go fast engineering" I talking about automotive engineering in general. Hybrid tachnology, fuel cell technology, safety technology, the japs are the hands down leaders I'm sorry to say. But like I said, would not want one in my garage...unless it has 2 wheels.
#29
MBWorld Fanatic!
Like I said, I would never own one, but you have to give them their props on some of the stuff they have been doing the past 5 years. Even their F1 effort is looking strong with Honda this season. Toyota/Lexus has been kicking butt in their sports car effort (Daytona Protos). The next generation NSX replacement looks like it's going to be a Ferrari killer. They lead the way in hybrids and are going to lead the way with their fuel cell technology. The question was "who has the best engineering", I just feel you can't leave out the japs, when they are clearly the cream of the crop right now, as must as it pains me to admit that. The question was not "who offers the most exotic machinery?".
#31
Super Member
Why does it pain you to admit it? Lean, Kanban, Six Sigma, etc... Japanese does not have great INNOVATION, but they have exceptional ENGINEERING and PROCESS.
#32
MBWorld Fanatic!
Your comment sums it up best, they do not have great innovation...for the most part, but they can take someone elses concept, let's say a BMW 5 series and take it to a whole new level. Infinity has done that with the M45. Have you been in one of those M45's? Incredible car, and I have owned an M5. Yes, their process controls are copied by the entire world...Germans included. I just don't think I could bring myself to buy one. Don't ask me why????? I have owned dozens of Honda, Suzuki, Yamaha and Kawasaki motorcycles though, double standard I guess.
#33
Super Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2005
Location: Chicago, IL
Posts: 648
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
'08 S65, '04 Range Rover(The House), '06 Lexus GS 300(Wifey's), '02 Sea Ray 360 Sundancer
Like I said, I would never own one, but you have to give them their props on some of the stuff they have been doing the past 5 years. Even their F1 effort is looking strong with Honda this season. Toyota/Lexus has been kicking butt in their sports car effort (Daytona Protos). The next generation NSX replacement looks like it's going to be a Ferrari killer. They lead the way in hybrids and are going to lead the way with their fuel cell technology. The question was "who has the best engineering", I just feel you can't leave out the japs, when they are clearly the cream of the crop right now, as must as it pains me to admit that. The question was not "who offers the most exotic machinery?".
#34
Super Member
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: Toronto, Canada
Posts: 573
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
540 6spd
In terms of sports cars I think the Italians win.
The Germans got the CGT which is one of the most beautiful pieces of engineering ever. It does prove that when the Germans want to they can build a piece to complete with the best Italian jobs.
MB SLR isn't on the same level as those cars. It's performance may be right up there but in terms of engineering ... meh.
BMW is missing in action.
Poor representation by the Germans is the reason they lose.
Audi / Lambo
The Germans got the CGT which is one of the most beautiful pieces of engineering ever. It does prove that when the Germans want to they can build a piece to complete with the best Italian jobs.
MB SLR isn't on the same level as those cars. It's performance may be right up there but in terms of engineering ... meh.
BMW is missing in action.
Poor representation by the Germans is the reason they lose.
Audi / Lambo
Last edited by MidniteBluBenz; 04-05-2008 at 09:04 PM.
#37
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Caribbean/Florida/Colorado
Posts: 3,642
Likes: 0
Received 11 Likes
on
11 Posts
E-ZGO 53hp., 1999 E 430 sport, 2004 E 55, 2008 Tahoe LTZ on 24"s
In terms of sports cars I think the Italians win.
The Germans got the CGT which is one of the most beautiful pieces of engineering ever. It does prove that when the Germans want to they can build a piece to complete with the best Italian jobs.
MB SLR isn't on the same level as those cars. It's performance may be right up there but in terms of engineering ... meh.
BMW is missing in action.
Poor representation by the Germans is the reason they lose.
Audi / Lambo
The Germans got the CGT which is one of the most beautiful pieces of engineering ever. It does prove that when the Germans want to they can build a piece to complete with the best Italian jobs.
MB SLR isn't on the same level as those cars. It's performance may be right up there but in terms of engineering ... meh.
BMW is missing in action.
Poor representation by the Germans is the reason they lose.
Audi / Lambo
Agree BMW never saw the ball, M1 RIP.
#38
That being said, while japanese quality is certainly very high - quality is not the same as engineering. They could easily be included in the discussion, however.
#39
Your comment sums it up best, they do not have great innovation...for the most part, but they can take someone elses concept, let's say a BMW 5 series and take it to a whole new level. Infinity has done that with the M45. Have you been in one of those M45's? Incredible car, and I have owned an M5. Yes, their process controls are copied by the entire world...Germans included. I just don't think I could bring myself to buy one. Don't ask me why????? I have owned dozens of Honda, Suzuki, Yamaha and Kawasaki motorcycles though, double standard I guess.
#40
Super Member
First of all, Lean and 6Sigma are not japanese process disciplines. Actually, all of the major manufacturers (including domestic) use Lean,6Sigma (and frankly Kanban is not a discipline - it's a method). In many cases the japanese introduced those concepts well after US and other manufacturers.
That being said, while japanese quality is certainly very high - quality is not the same as engineering. They could easily be included in the discussion, however.
That being said, while japanese quality is certainly very high - quality is not the same as engineering. They could easily be included in the discussion, however.
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)