Should I consider the E43 AMG a real AMG?
take your pick
Last edited by RobbieRob; Aug 9, 2017 at 01:11 AM.

there is A LOT of complaining about comfort and luxury ride deterioration as the e63S progresses more towards a trackable super sedan than it progresses towards a luxury grocery getter. If people can't stand it in comfort mode what's the point of buying it?
95% of these Amg's will never see a track. My point is that this car has gravited apparently a solid step more towards purist amg than is has toward luxury smooth cruiser.
most buying this car realize it's not a svelte gtr or gt3, hell many have THOSE true track cars in their stables that also own the e63S.
people need to decide what they want out of this car; don't give up on me yet!
Last edited by PeterUbers; Aug 9, 2017 at 02:41 AM.
As I mentioned, Porsche was profitable without the junk SUVs/cars it sells now. Porsche was profitable before they decided to make the Cayenne. So it doesn't make sense at all to argue that Porsche needs the junk SUVs/cars in order to produce its core sportscars.
I have a lot of respect for AMG not least for coming out with cars like the AMG GT, which has a lot of features that Porsche has actually removed from its sportscars as it has watered them down and made them less driver-focused. I just don't want to see AMG going down the same road as Porsche.
As far as the 911 is concerned, that car has been a work in progress since 1965. Each model is better than the last. I base my opinion on what I read and my experience of Porsche ownership. I have owned 8 Porsches since 1983.
And yes, during the 90's; Wiedeking became CEO in 1993 and Toyota had first officially published TPS in 1992.
There are literally whole books written about Toyota's impact on Porsche and specifically 986 production, and we could probably fill a small library with all the literature about TPS/TQM/Kaizen and the impact it has had on business and industry, automotive or otherwise. Strongly recommend people read about it - the TPS principles are not only good lessons for business and perhaps life in general, but of particular interest to car fans.
Love that you are holding on to your 240SX btw, was having lunch with some friends today and the S13 came up randomly in conversation.
Last edited by gengar; Aug 9, 2017 at 06:57 PM.
Yes, it's still fully oem and problem free, other than the dead headlight switches and the rust on the oem steel wheels and body from that 8-years period in NJ and New Orleans when my place had no garage. From time to time, I'm thinking of taking it to a shop to get it completely cleaned up and restored.
The Best of Mercedes & AMG
I also referenced TQM, Total Quality Management. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Total_quality_management




I wanted to point out a few things about the new E class. I had a loaner car for the past 3 days and noticed a few things about it. Yes it was an E 300, not a 43 but the things I noticed should be on the 43 and probably the 63 as well.
1. The car does fell bigger.
2. The rear doors though feel smaller. It felt more like trying to get into the rear of a CLS and having to duck your head to get into the rear.
3. The inside does look amazing but those 4 vents under the screen are strange and feel out of place.
4. The technology and ability to change things is overwhelming. There is so much to control, could it be to much? Although I still had similar problems with Carplay too.
5. It has considerably faster Internet connection. (On a side note and to be funny, I booked marked a bunch of BMW, Audi, and Porsche pages in the Web browser.)
6. The center volume control is horrible. It's touchy and doesn't react quickly enough to adjustments. Just give me a knob please.
7. The new smaller "antenna" on the roof is much nicer and doesn't look 80's anymore to me.
8. When the eco mode stops the car at a stop, you still have power steering which is nice, but eco still cuts itself back on anytime you change modes. Annoying!!
9. Even in this car I heard the rear wheels "thud" over bumps and cracks in the road. The car is smooth on flat pavement, but bumps, cracks, and potholes make the suspension jump and move around on the road. It feels unstable over rough roads. Yes, I noticed this a long time ago on 3 different 43s I've driven.
10. The headrest are nice! They are let like resting your head on a soft pillow. Huge improvement.
Ok, 11. I want a real gear shifter and not the flimsy stalk shifter.
Just my 2 cents. Take it as you wish about the new E class.
Last edited by BACnMercedes; Aug 17, 2017 at 10:13 PM.
I wanted to point out a few things about the new E class. I had a loaner car for the past 3 days and noticed a few things about it. Yes it was an E 300, not a 43 but the things I noticed should be on the 43 and probably the 63 as well.
1. The car does fell bigger.
2. The rear doors though feel smaller. It felt more like trying to get into the rear of a CLS and having to duck your head to get into the rear.
3. The inside does look amazing but those 4 vents under the screen are strange and feel out of place.
4. The technology and ability to change things is overwhelming. There is so much to control, could it be to much? Although I still had similar problems with Carplay too.
5. It has considerably faster Internet connection. (On a side note and to be funny, I booked marked a bunch of BMW, Audi, and Porsche pages in the Web browser.)
6. The center volume control is horrible. It's touchy and doesn't react quickly enough to adjustments. Just give me a knob please.
7. The new smaller "antenna" on the roof is much nicer and doesn't look 80's anymore to me.
8. When the eco mode stops the car at a stop, you still have power steering which is nice, but eco still cuts itself back on anytime you change modes. Annoying!!
9. Even in this car I heard the rear wheels "thud" over bumps and cracks in the road. The car is smooth on flat pavement, but bumps, cracks, and potholes make the suspension jump and move around on the road. It feels unstable over rough roads. Yes, I noticed this a long time ago on 3 different 43s I've driven.
10. The headrest are nice! They are let like resting your head on a soft pillow. Huge improvement.
Ok, 11. I want a real gear shifter and not the flimsy stalk shifter.
Just my 2 cents. Take it as you wish about the new E class.
Nice for the look but bad for the practicality.



