PZero vs. Pilot Sport 4S - Initial Impressions

The E63 came with a set of PZeros. The tires were put on at 9,800 miles so they were still pretty new. The problem with the car in general is that it is too harsh (otherwise it’s the most fun I’ve had on 4 wheels in a long time).
To mitigate the harshness I took the advice of several on this board and reduced the tire pressure to 35PSi. This helped a lot, but I was still not satisfied. So I ordered a set of Michelin PS4s after reading/watching a multitude of reviews.
They were installed a couple of days ago and here are my first impressions:
-when I picked up the car they were just as bad, but the installer had the pressure at 60 PSi(!!)
-after dropping the pressure to 35PSi, I can say they are smoother than the PZeros at that pressure, but not by orders of magnitude
-as to road noise, I measured the PZeros and now the PS4s using the sound app on my Apple Watch (not the most precision instrument). I drove on the same stretch of road, at the same speeds on a day with no wind. At 30 MPH the sound level was identical, at 70 it went from 68dB to 66dB. Still worse than our Audi Q8 (with 22” Continentals) at 64 dB. Even though the sound level at slow speed is the same, and at higher speeds only slightly improved, the tire noise is more pleasant than with the PZeros (personal opinion).
As an aside my car does have the Acoustic Comfort Package. Based on how noisy it is with that, I can’t imagine buying one without this package. Also several reviewers have said that Mercedes always provides cars with this package for reviews (FWIW).
So the question is, was it worth replacing perfectly good tires with new ones at a cost of $1,700? I would say yes, but it isn’t a night and day difference. If I knew the difference was this small, I would have opted for the following option right away.
Since I plan to track the car, I am also thinking of getting some 19” rims and even more subtle tires for daily driving and keeping the others for the track. Will update if and when that happens.
As an aside, I also tested a 2021 recently and it is a HUGE improvement in comfort mode if with 20” rims. May end up going for that in a year or so.
Hopefully this helps someone with the same concerns.








Ivan MacKenzie.





if you want factory 19 setup, you can consider this example.
if you go aftermarket, try to get them as close to the factory specs, esp. the offset. I do not recommend to get any aftermarket wheels that gave deep concave design, esp. the front ones because it could cause fitment and clearance issue with the big brake calliper
Trending Topics
My car came with Pirelli tires and I eventually put on Michelin. I think the ride and noise from the Michelin are somewhat better than the Pirelli, but the grip and wear of the Michelin are so far much better.
The Best of Mercedes & AMG
Last edited by ENCT; Apr 22, 2021 at 08:03 PM.
I wonder if MB sets it that way for the boat ride here the dealership mistakenly thinks that the best pressures and replicates that for delivery???




has anyone tried All seasons?




has anyone tried All seasons?

One thing the acoustic package does do is reduce the sound of the exhaust inside the car. Occasionally I'll open up the pano roof and roll down the windows when driving around town at low speeds. I forget just how loud the exhaust can be in Sport+ when you put the spurs to it at a stop light.




265/35/20 is not on the list. I opted for 255/35/20. there is a 1% in speedo difference. I would have lost about 3.5mm in ride height. It is immaterial in variance to me.
If you go 19", then yes, those are the suggested/recommended tire size. The alternate size you may consider is 255/40/19 front and 285/35/19 on the Michelin PS A/S 4 which both will result in a 1% in speedo difference. The ride height of around 3.5mm would be lost on this setup.
https://www.michelin.ca/en/auto/tire...t-all-season-4
https://www.willtheyfit.com/index.ph...9-5&offset2=25
You are free to explore other brands (like Continental) as well if you do choose to go 19", the ride is likely be a bit better per se.




https://www.tirerack.com/tires/tests...y.jsp?ttid=241
You can use this as a general reference. It is a very close result among all the tires tested, mind you, the Michelin PS A/S 4 has been upgraded with some improvements over the 3+.




The E63 came with a set of PZeros. The tires were put on at 9,800 miles so they were still pretty new. The problem with the car in general is that it is too harsh (otherwise it’s the most fun I’ve had on 4 wheels in a long time).
To mitigate the harshness I took the advice of several on this board and reduced the tire pressure to 35PSi. This helped a lot, but I was still not satisfied. So I ordered a set of Michelin PS4s after reading/watching a multitude of reviews.
They were installed a couple of days ago and here are my first impressions:
-when I picked up the car they were just as bad, but the installer had the pressure at 60 PSi(!!)
-after dropping the pressure to 35PSi, I can say they are smoother than the PZeros at that pressure, but not by orders of magnitude
-as to road noise, I measured the PZeros and now the PS4s using the sound app on my Apple Watch (not the most precision instrument). I drove on the same stretch of road, at the same speeds on a day with no wind. At 30 MPH the sound level was identical, at 70 it went from 68dB to 66dB. Still worse than our Audi Q8 (with 22” Continentals) at 64 dB. Even though the sound level at slow speed is the same, and at higher speeds only slightly improved, the tire noise is more pleasant than with the PZeros (personal opinion).
As an aside my car does have the Acoustic Comfort Package. Based on how noisy it is with that, I can’t imagine buying one without this package. Also several reviewers have said that Mercedes always provides cars with this package for reviews (FWIW).
So the question is, was it worth replacing perfectly good tires with new ones at a cost of $1,700? I would say yes, but it isn’t a night and day difference. If I knew the difference was this small, I would have opted for the following option right away.
Since I plan to track the car, I am also thinking of getting some 19” rims and even more subtle tires for daily driving and keeping the others for the track. Will update if and when that happens.
As an aside, I also tested a 2021 recently and it is a HUGE improvement in comfort mode if with 20” rims. May end up going for that in a year or so.
Hopefully this helps someone with the same concerns.
see my post from the last year
https://mbworld.org/forums/w213-amg/...ml#post8228066
Hope this helps.




Thanks!
Erik




Front: https://www.mbpartsworld.com/oem-par...21340126007x21
Rear: https://www.mbpartsworld.com/oem-par...21340127007x21
Tires are 265/40 R19 front and rear.
My invoice shows 213-401-46-00-7X21 as the part number for the rear wheels, which is different that what I linked above. I searched for the invoice part number but couldn't find it anywhere, so I searched for "Amg 10-Spoke Wheel 48.3 Cm (19 Inch) rear" and that's how I found the above link. Comparing the car image with the image shown for the fronts, I would say it's the correct part number.
Ivan MacKenzie.





