W211 - Speaker only upgrade on Harmon Kardon system
- The amp I installed is 2ohm/4ohm compatible. OEM speakers are 2ohm hence I selected a compatible amp since I went back to OEM speakers. I intend to replace OEM speakers with component speakers in the new year. Your amp needs to be compatible with installed speakers. You could use 4ohm compatible amp if you intend to replace OEM speakers with 4ohm ones.
- 3-way speakers will work fine but I have no experience with 3-way 6.5" round speakers.
- As enclosed sub would be the easiest option to install and it will give you a nice thump.




Last edited by pinebaron; Feb 1, 2010 at 07:58 PM.




Thanks
Christian




Thanks
Christian
https://mbworld.org/forums/e-class-w...h-4200dvd.html
The Best of Mercedes & AMG




https://mbworld.org/forums/e-class-w...h-4200dvd.html








The weird thing is, I saw the tweeter with 4ohms. I keep reading that the speakers are 2ohms. I can only guess that the stock woofer is also 4ohms, and that they are wired in parallel to produce 2ohms right? Pinebaron, can you confirm this when you pulled out the front woofer?
The reason I'm shopping for the tweeter only is because I notice crackling noise on my front left tweeter only. The woofers, like you I will keep because I have no problem with their sound. Also, I have been researching about DIYmobileaudio.com and you can select each component of drivers to match your needs. You can get raw drivers from Scanspeak, Vifa, Dayton, Peerless, and Seas for less than a hundred bucks. These drivers are used in audiophile speaker systems that cost over a thousand dollars a pair. Scanspeak I believe make the drivers for Alpine F1 Status witch are over $1200 a pair.
The weird thing is, I saw the tweeter with 4ohms. I keep reading that the speakers are 2ohms. I can only guess that the stock woofer is also 4ohms, and that they are wired in parallel to produce 2ohms right? Pinebaron, can you confirm this when you pulled out the front woofer?
The reason I'm shopping for the tweeter only is because I notice crackling noise on my front left tweeter only. The woofers, like you I will keep because I have no problem with their sound. Also, I have been researching about DIYmobileaudio.com and you can select each component of drivers to match your needs. You can get raw drivers from Scanspeak, Vifa, Dayton, Peerless, and Seas for less than a hundred bucks. These drivers are used in audiophile speaker systems that cost over a thousand dollars a pair. Scanspeak I believe make the drivers for Alpine F1 Status witch are over $1200 a pair.
The weird thing is, I saw the tweeter with 4ohms. I keep reading that the speakers are 2ohms. I can only guess that the stock woofer is also 4ohms, and that they are wired in parallel to produce 2ohms right? Pinebaron, can you confirm this when you pulled out the front woofer?
The reason I'm shopping for the tweeter only is because I notice crackling noise on my front left tweeter only. The woofers, like you I will keep because I have no problem with their sound. Also, I have been researching about DIYmobileaudio.com and you can select each component of drivers to match your needs. You can get raw drivers from Scanspeak, Vifa, Dayton, Peerless, and Seas for less than a hundred bucks. These drivers are used in audiophile speaker systems that cost over a thousand dollars a pair. Scanspeak I believe make the drivers for Alpine F1 Status witch are over $1200 a pair.
In regards to what is found in the DIY route .. many of these drivers are fairly good and inexpensive, BUT it is a lengthy trial and error voyage. Even when 'on paper' parameters line up, it still might not be a suitable driver for YOU. Also mind you the majority of DIY'ers ( myself included both personally and professionally) using this method are are actively processed where tuning is a breeze. With the OE configuration you are limited to the T/A and passbands already preselected.
Overall you may get lucky and find something that works for you, alternatively and more common your search and labor could take more time than anticipated.
In regards to what is found in the DIY route .. many of these drivers are fairly good and inexpensive, BUT it is a lengthy trial and error voyage. Even when 'on paper' parameters line up, it still might not be a suitable driver for YOU. Also mind you the majority of DIY'ers ( myself included both personally and professionally) using this method are are actively processed where tuning is a breeze. With the OE configuration you are limited to the T/A and passbands already preselected.
Overall you may get lucky and find something that works for you, alternatively and more common your search and labor could take more time than anticipated.




emilner, for a center speaker that fits with no problems, check out the Hertz HL70.4, it has to be the .4 model though as it is the new version. i just used it in a 5.1 system with a separate tweeter, and I can only say phenomenal![/quote]
After 6 months of trying various things, and being ready to return the car or rip the whole audio out and have something decent insalled, (because I am an audio purist and I have no fun driving a car with substandard sound), last week I fixed it.
As I mentioned, i am a purist. All virtual surround systems (e.g. Dolby PLII, etc) always soudned wrong to me nd first thing to do would be to switch them off. But MB sounded better (although still horrible) with Logic 7 on. i could not understand why. And then I realised that even with Logic 7 off, there was some sound coming out of central speaker and the to satellites next to the subwoofer. This was against the logic (at least my logic). Mid-rage mixed into a central channel? I thought this might explain the horrible flat sound, no power, and lack of ability to localise sounds.
So the first thing was to disconnect the central speaker. What a change! All of a sudden, things were clear, localizable and powerful. There was however still a bit of funny high-pitch echo coming from behind. Guess what I did - disconnected the satellites. Now it sounds excellent - very close to what I was used to on the Volvo. Bass is bass, and drums sound like drums, and even violin sounds like violin on classical music. Of course Logic 7 is off (when I turn it on it turns the sound into flat plastic bass and treble, because middles cannot melt into the central anymore).
So I saved myself a good couple of $000s by switching off and disconnecting all pieces of Logic7. The amp, good set of speakers, and no fiddling with what is a good stereo recording is all I need.
I would however appreciate a real surround system that can play DVD-A or SACD.
My audio rules for home and car are:
Down with mp3!!!
Down with virtual surround!!!
Long live proper speakers!!!
And i do not care if you think otherwise.
Joyjay
In the meantime, I will listen to the new level of audio, appreciate/critique quality of sound from OEM speakers and decide if I should upgrade door speakers. I don't really need more base but for those of you who cannot live without extreme base, you should just get an amp and initially drive OEM subwoofer to establish its capacity and durability. 10" subs are readily available.
I've taken loads of pictures but need to sequence them properly, add a little narrative prior to publishing them on my web site; give me a few days.
Let me know if you have any questions and I will explain or add more pictures to the site.
I've been looking into the whole topic and I'm loving this project so much, I'm actually looking into doing a similar project of my own, however, I don't have the HK sound system in my car, I do have the second option however, the "premium" sound system, in short, I only lack the parcel shelf speakers and subwoofer but everything else is there, including the center speaker in the dashboard. Everything is also driven by an amplifier which is hidden under the piece of plastic in the trunk area near the backseats.
Would it be still possible for me to simply throw in another aftermarket amplifier and rewire the existing sound system to said amp? Or would that be an really bad idea?
I'm not sure if the non hk "premium" speakers are far worse or how much they can handle or if it's even remotely possible, quite new to this I must say, although I have been adding options and modifications to my W211 with success so far.
Would love to hear from you guys, any information is appreciated!


