Oil Catch Can Advice
06-13-2012, 03:10 AM
#1
Super Member
Thread Starter
Oil Catch Can Advice
Hey guys,
I have a question after seeing someones post about how there was oil sludge in their engine I was wondering why I haven't seen people talk more about oil catch cans. Do you guys think this is necessary in our cars? Does any one have any input or advice on advantages or disadvantages?
Thanks in advanced
I have a question after seeing someones post about how there was oil sludge in their engine I was wondering why I haven't seen people talk more about oil catch cans. Do you guys think this is necessary in our cars? Does any one have any input or advice on advantages or disadvantages?
Thanks in advanced
06-14-2012, 02:42 AM
#3
Super Member
Thread Starter
What caught my attention and made me to start thinking of a catch can was this thread. Does sher-judge have a point that a catch would have prevented that from happening? Does anyone have any input?
https://mbworld.org/forums/c63-amg-w...check-out.html
https://mbworld.org/forums/c63-amg-w...check-out.html
06-14-2012, 05:00 AM
#5
06-14-2012, 03:14 PM
#6
MBWorld Fanatic!
06-14-2012, 03:37 PM
#7
Former Vendor of MBWorld
Gentlemen, Please view this picture to see how we install the Oil Separator. We supply all the brackets, hardware, and hoses in the kit to install it behind the headlight. This was a revision we made on the C63 because of the congestion near the firewall. If any of you didn't receive our newest parts, please email or PM us and we will get you situated with the latest and greatest. Let us know if this helps.
Weistec Engineering
Weistec Engineering
Trending Topics
06-14-2012, 04:28 PM
#8
MBWorld Fanatic!
Gentlemen, Please view this picture to see how we install the Oil Separator. We supply all the brackets, hardware, and hoses in the kit to install it behind the headlight. This was a revision we made on the C63 because of the congestion near the firewall. If any of you didn't receive our newest parts, please email or PM us and we will get you situated with the latest and greatest. Let us know if this helps.
Weistec Engineering
Weistec Engineering
thanks again guys
06-14-2012, 09:44 PM
#9
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: Bay Area, CA
Posts: 375
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
2010 C63, 2007 X5
may be just the cover 
or a more powerful one 
06-15-2012, 11:47 AM
#12
06-15-2012, 11:56 AM
#13
Member
Join Date: May 2012
Posts: 163
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
C63 amg
This is my first Mercedes so I really don't know but like mitsubishi would blame anything they could on any after market part. Mercedes does have a clause under damages due to alterations or modifications. I just wonder if they would try to blame.
06-15-2012, 12:01 PM
#14
MBWorld Fanatic!
06-25-2012, 10:50 PM
#15
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2011
Location: Battle Ground WA
Posts: 344
Likes: 0
Received 5 Likes
on
5 Posts
C63AMG, NIssan NX2000, Pontiac Fiero GT
If you are asking if sludge is caused by pooled oil in the intake ,the answer is not that I know. A catch tank or oil separator is mainly used in race cars to my kowledge. Crank case pressure from (combustion)" blow-by" drives vapor and oil into the crankcase breather. Good design usually avoids this. Some race engines use vacuum pumps to reduce the turbulence and parasitic HP loss. Hate to think this is a problem on C63.
06-26-2012, 03:07 PM
#16
Super Member
Thread Starter
If you are asking if sludge is caused by pooled oil in the intake ,the answer is not that I know. A catch tank or oil separator is mainly used in race cars to my kowledge. Crank case pressure from (combustion)" blow-by" drives vapor and oil into the crankcase breather. Good design usually avoids this. Some race engines use vacuum pumps to reduce the turbulence and parasitic HP loss. Hate to think this is a problem on C63.
lol But it seems as though its not 100% necessary, as long as you change the oil and service you engine often you will be ok with out one.
06-26-2012, 07:56 PM
#17
Former Vendor of MBWorld
Gentlemen,
There are two different issues that are being discussed in this thread. The first being our Oil Separator, how it works, and what it prevents, and the oil sludge issue inside the engine.
Our Oil Separator System is designed to decrease the consumption of oil from the factory PCV system. Many vehicles come with some sort of oil separator system from the factory. This is not some kind of technology that is only seen on race cars. Look at the M113K E55 engine as an example. The factory crankcase ventilation on the M156/M159 breathes mostly between the timing cover and the engine block, and this is where the timing chain as well as many other moving parts are. Because of this, oil gets splashed and sucked in through the PCV system. It is not completely a matter of blow-by, but the design of the crankcase ventilation. The pictures on our website (http://weistec.com/m156os.html) of oil in the intake manifold is proof of what is happening over time. This can also cause many issues from serious carbon build up on valve and piston surfaces, to a loss in power from detonation, to damaging the catalyst system over time. We think this is very bad on the engine, and have seen the difference the Oil Separator can make in just one oil change period.
Oil Sludge is typically from either over heating the oil or not completing an oil change in due time. The Oil Separator can't help this, but it will prevent milky oil (air and oil mixing) because its main purpose it to separate oil and air. Hope this helps. Thanks guys!
Weistec Engineering
There are two different issues that are being discussed in this thread. The first being our Oil Separator, how it works, and what it prevents, and the oil sludge issue inside the engine.
Our Oil Separator System is designed to decrease the consumption of oil from the factory PCV system. Many vehicles come with some sort of oil separator system from the factory. This is not some kind of technology that is only seen on race cars. Look at the M113K E55 engine as an example. The factory crankcase ventilation on the M156/M159 breathes mostly between the timing cover and the engine block, and this is where the timing chain as well as many other moving parts are. Because of this, oil gets splashed and sucked in through the PCV system. It is not completely a matter of blow-by, but the design of the crankcase ventilation. The pictures on our website (http://weistec.com/m156os.html) of oil in the intake manifold is proof of what is happening over time. This can also cause many issues from serious carbon build up on valve and piston surfaces, to a loss in power from detonation, to damaging the catalyst system over time. We think this is very bad on the engine, and have seen the difference the Oil Separator can make in just one oil change period.
Oil Sludge is typically from either over heating the oil or not completing an oil change in due time. The Oil Separator can't help this, but it will prevent milky oil (air and oil mixing) because its main purpose it to separate oil and air. Hope this helps. Thanks guys!
Weistec Engineering
Last edited by Weistec; 06-26-2012 at 08:00 PM.
06-26-2012, 09:06 PM
#18
MBWorld Fanatic!
Gentlemen,
There are two different issues that are being discussed in this thread. The first being our Oil Separator, how it works, and what it prevents, and the oil sludge issue inside the engine.
Our Oil Separator System is designed to decrease the consumption of oil from the factory PCV system. Many vehicles come with some sort of oil separator system from the factory. This is not some kind of technology that is only seen on race cars. Look at the M113K E55 engine as an example. The factory crankcase ventilation on the M156/M159 breathes mostly between the timing cover and the engine block, and this is where the timing chain as well as many other moving parts are. Because of this, oil gets splashed and sucked in through the PCV system. It is not completely a matter of blow-by, but the design of the crankcase ventilation. The pictures on our website (http://weistec.com/m156os.html) of oil in the intake manifold is proof of what is happening over time. This can also cause many issues from serious carbon build up on valve and piston surfaces, to a loss in power from detonation, to damaging the catalyst system over time. We think this is very bad on the engine, and have seen the difference the Oil Separator can make in just one oil change period.
Oil Sludge is typically from either over heating the oil or not completing an oil change in due time. The Oil Separator can't help this, but it will prevent milky oil (air and oil mixing) because its main purpose it to separate oil and air. Hope this helps. Thanks guys!
Weistec Engineering
There are two different issues that are being discussed in this thread. The first being our Oil Separator, how it works, and what it prevents, and the oil sludge issue inside the engine.
Our Oil Separator System is designed to decrease the consumption of oil from the factory PCV system. Many vehicles come with some sort of oil separator system from the factory. This is not some kind of technology that is only seen on race cars. Look at the M113K E55 engine as an example. The factory crankcase ventilation on the M156/M159 breathes mostly between the timing cover and the engine block, and this is where the timing chain as well as many other moving parts are. Because of this, oil gets splashed and sucked in through the PCV system. It is not completely a matter of blow-by, but the design of the crankcase ventilation. The pictures on our website (http://weistec.com/m156os.html) of oil in the intake manifold is proof of what is happening over time. This can also cause many issues from serious carbon build up on valve and piston surfaces, to a loss in power from detonation, to damaging the catalyst system over time. We think this is very bad on the engine, and have seen the difference the Oil Separator can make in just one oil change period.
Oil Sludge is typically from either over heating the oil or not completing an oil change in due time. The Oil Separator can't help this, but it will prevent milky oil (air and oil mixing) because its main purpose it to separate oil and air. Hope this helps. Thanks guys!
Weistec Engineering
Looks like a well engineered and finished product. Could you put a PDF of installation instuctions for a C63 on your website. Always like to see what's involved in the installation prior to ordering things.
02-05-2015, 06:10 AM
#19
Member
Join Date: May 2014
Posts: 82
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
2012 C63 Sedan
Gentlemen,
There are two different issues that are being discussed in this thread. The first being our Oil Separator, how it works, and what it prevents, and the oil sludge issue inside the engine.
Our Oil Separator System is designed to decrease the consumption of oil from the factory PCV system. Many vehicles come with some sort of oil separator system from the factory. This is not some kind of technology that is only seen on race cars. Look at the M113K E55 engine as an example. The factory crankcase ventilation on the M156/M159 breathes mostly between the timing cover and the engine block, and this is where the timing chain as well as many other moving parts are. Because of this, oil gets splashed and sucked in through the PCV system. It is not completely a matter of blow-by, but the design of the crankcase ventilation. The pictures on our website (http://weistec.com/m156os.html) of oil in the intake manifold is proof of what is happening over time. This can also cause many issues from serious carbon build up on valve and piston surfaces, to a loss in power from detonation, to damaging the catalyst system over time. We think this is very bad on the engine, and have seen the difference the Oil Separator can make in just one oil change period.
Oil Sludge is typically from either over heating the oil or not completing an oil change in due time. The Oil Separator can't help this, but it will prevent milky oil (air and oil mixing) because its main purpose it to separate oil and air. Hope this helps. Thanks guys!
Weistec Engineering
There are two different issues that are being discussed in this thread. The first being our Oil Separator, how it works, and what it prevents, and the oil sludge issue inside the engine.
Our Oil Separator System is designed to decrease the consumption of oil from the factory PCV system. Many vehicles come with some sort of oil separator system from the factory. This is not some kind of technology that is only seen on race cars. Look at the M113K E55 engine as an example. The factory crankcase ventilation on the M156/M159 breathes mostly between the timing cover and the engine block, and this is where the timing chain as well as many other moving parts are. Because of this, oil gets splashed and sucked in through the PCV system. It is not completely a matter of blow-by, but the design of the crankcase ventilation. The pictures on our website (http://weistec.com/m156os.html) of oil in the intake manifold is proof of what is happening over time. This can also cause many issues from serious carbon build up on valve and piston surfaces, to a loss in power from detonation, to damaging the catalyst system over time. We think this is very bad on the engine, and have seen the difference the Oil Separator can make in just one oil change period.
Oil Sludge is typically from either over heating the oil or not completing an oil change in due time. The Oil Separator can't help this, but it will prevent milky oil (air and oil mixing) because its main purpose it to separate oil and air. Hope this helps. Thanks guys!
Weistec Engineering
02-05-2015, 11:38 AM
#21
MBWorld Fanatic!
02-05-2015, 12:07 PM
#22
Super Member
I've got Weistec's can installed (it was a moderate pain in the ***), but it was worth it as it now harvests a decent amount of oil that otherwise would end up in the intake. The engine bay of the C63 is very crowded, and the PCV valve is tucked tight against the firewall. I ended up running the lines around the dipstick, which ain't ideal, but still works. Just be real careful during install and don't break the PCV valve or brackets, or drop any of the hardware. HTH
