Alignment - Steering issues...
#1
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2003
Posts: 166
Likes: 0
Received 6 Likes
on
2 Posts
2005 E55, 2002 CLK55, 2005 SLK350 also a 2009 BMW 335-IX
Alignment - Steering issues...
Hello Folks,
I have a 2002 CLK55 that I bought pre-owned about a year ago. It had 6K on it when it got it.
The previous owner had custom wheels and tires on it, but the original AMG Monoblocks and Michelin Pilots were stored and put back on the car right before it was delivered to me. So essentially the OEM wheels and tires were brand new when I got the car.
This is the first car I have owned with a recirculating ball steering system. All the others are/were rack and pinion types. Is it just me, or does the MB steering lack the crisp and direct feel I am used to from the rack and pinion system?
Also, the car seemed to wander around the road, especially on worn pavement (the grooves and humps) where the tires compress the asphalt into little channels on either side of the lane center. I had the car aligned at the dealer two weeks ago, and $100 later, I can't really say there has been much of an improvement.
Is this a function of the alignment, steering, wide tires or what? Any help would be appreciated.
Best to all,
JM
I have a 2002 CLK55 that I bought pre-owned about a year ago. It had 6K on it when it got it.
The previous owner had custom wheels and tires on it, but the original AMG Monoblocks and Michelin Pilots were stored and put back on the car right before it was delivered to me. So essentially the OEM wheels and tires were brand new when I got the car.
This is the first car I have owned with a recirculating ball steering system. All the others are/were rack and pinion types. Is it just me, or does the MB steering lack the crisp and direct feel I am used to from the rack and pinion system?
Also, the car seemed to wander around the road, especially on worn pavement (the grooves and humps) where the tires compress the asphalt into little channels on either side of the lane center. I had the car aligned at the dealer two weeks ago, and $100 later, I can't really say there has been much of an improvement.
Is this a function of the alignment, steering, wide tires or what? Any help would be appreciated.
Best to all,
JM
#2
Answers:
1) Recirculating ball steering is definitely not on a par with rack and pinion, in terms of feel *or* precision. It is the biggest drawback of this car, imo. The C32's rack and pinion system is much better, but I liked the looks (and engine) of the CLK55 much better...still, it's a pity that it doesn't have both.
2) The wandering over ridges, etc. you are describing is called tramlining. Alignment can sometimes help a bit, but will never eliminate it. You are correct in your third assumption, that wider tires are the main cause. Here is an article that TireRack has about tramlining:
TireRack's tramlining info page
2) The wandering over ridges, etc. you are describing is called tramlining. Alignment can sometimes help a bit, but will never eliminate it. You are correct in your third assumption, that wider tires are the main cause. Here is an article that TireRack has about tramlining:
TireRack's tramlining info page
#3
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: Randolph, New Jersey
Posts: 273
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
2002 C32 AMG
Improv - Your Right on the MONEY Amigo - The Steering of the CLK55 is it's weakness links - It simply does not communicate with the driver. I never feel as if I have complete control regarding the steering feedback. I gotta say, more and more I miss the Porsche Platform.
#4
Yeah, nothing I've ever driven has steering feel like the Porsches...
....part of which is due to the R&P, and even more importantly, they don't have a heavy engine over the front wheels dampening the feedback. Fantastic steering; it feels like your hands are gliding over the road.
Sorry to hear of your engine woes, btw...keep us posted, and good luck!!
Sorry to hear of your engine woes, btw...keep us posted, and good luck!!
#5
the feed back is not good!
that's why I lowered my clk55 using 1 and 2 pads and konis shocks. It improved a little bit especially when driving at high speeds in the freeway. But low speed, forget about it because the power steering really kicks in like in most luxury cars.
#6
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2003
Posts: 166
Likes: 0
Received 6 Likes
on
2 Posts
2005 E55, 2002 CLK55, 2005 SLK350 also a 2009 BMW 335-IX
Thanks to all for the replies.
As far as the steering feel goes, I don't think I will ever buy another car that does not have rack and pinion steering. I would have expected better from MB and AMG. Well, maybe it's time to try a new E55! Or as 5439cc indicated somewhere else... can you spell PORSCHE?
Thanks to Improviz for the link to the tramlining information. It looks like there's not much that can be done for that. It's less of a problem as speed increases, so I guess I'll have to drive faster.
Valentine One don't fail me now!
Happy Motoring...
As far as the steering feel goes, I don't think I will ever buy another car that does not have rack and pinion steering. I would have expected better from MB and AMG. Well, maybe it's time to try a new E55! Or as 5439cc indicated somewhere else... can you spell PORSCHE?
Thanks to Improviz for the link to the tramlining information. It looks like there's not much that can be done for that. It's less of a problem as speed increases, so I guess I'll have to drive faster.
Valentine One don't fail me now!
Happy Motoring...
#7
Member
Where for $100 & steering
I am having an alignment at my next service ~48k miles and the dealer here in San Jose, Calif. wants $325 (front and rear, complete. Where are MBZ dealers doing this for $100?
Also, I love my CLK55 but I do think the steering is CLK320 grade. I took a high performance driving class and found that high speed lane changes were a lot harder than in BMW M3s and even 330s. I just could not get the steering wheel from lock to lock anywhere near as quick, putting my top speed right in there with Jag sedans even though I had more rubber on the road, more HP etc.
Also, I love my CLK55 but I do think the steering is CLK320 grade. I took a high performance driving class and found that high speed lane changes were a lot harder than in BMW M3s and even 330s. I just could not get the steering wheel from lock to lock anywhere near as quick, putting my top speed right in there with Jag sedans even though I had more rubber on the road, more HP etc.
Trending Topics
#8
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2003
Posts: 166
Likes: 0
Received 6 Likes
on
2 Posts
2005 E55, 2002 CLK55, 2005 SLK350 also a 2009 BMW 335-IX
Alignment costs...
Well, I can't comment on West Coast MBZ Maintenance prices, but here in "Fly-Over" country (the Midwest) the alignment was $106.27, complete. That was for the front and rear alignment and to straighten the steering wheel too.
And I will say again, the biggest disappointment I have with the car is the lack of steering feel and precision. I have driven many cars, most of them much lower in price, that beat the CLK55 hands down in this area.
Now, on the other hand... WHAT AN ENGINE!
And I will say again, the biggest disappointment I have with the car is the lack of steering feel and precision. I have driven many cars, most of them much lower in price, that beat the CLK55 hands down in this area.
Now, on the other hand... WHAT AN ENGINE!
#9
MBWorld Fanatic!
My alignment was under $135 but its a little far for you to go to my dealer.
If you know of a good alignment shop, you might be able to use my "before and after" numbers on my clk. Its too big a file to attach so PM me and I will send it to you.
I found out the hard way that MB doesn't let go of the settings to anyone.
You also might need the MB camber kit.
If you know of a good alignment shop, you might be able to use my "before and after" numbers on my clk. Its too big a file to attach so PM me and I will send it to you.
I found out the hard way that MB doesn't let go of the settings to anyone.
You also might need the MB camber kit.
#10
Super Member
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: Silicon valley
Posts: 538
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
Audi C7.5 S6
Custom Alignment-Balance in Mountain View
Custom Alignment-Balance is one of the best in the bay area. (650) 961-5311, 2599 Wyandotte St, MV, CA
I noticed the CLK55 handles a little like a police cruiser, same kind of steering box. I love the exhaust burble of the CLK55.
Even a Mustang has Rack and Pinion, since at least 1988.
Besides the C32, what other Mercedes have Rack & pinion?
Don
I noticed the CLK55 handles a little like a police cruiser, same kind of steering box. I love the exhaust burble of the CLK55.
Even a Mustang has Rack and Pinion, since at least 1988.
Besides the C32, what other Mercedes have Rack & pinion?
Don
#11
Super Member
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: Silicon valley
Posts: 538
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
Audi C7.5 S6
2003 CLK55 has rack and pinion
On the mbusa website, just found that the 2003 CLK55 has rack & pinion, the 2002 CLK55 has Recirculating-ball steering.
I wonder how much the parts cost to convert?
MB is progressing.
Don
I wonder how much the parts cost to convert?
MB is progressing.
Don
Last edited by m444; 02-09-2004 at 04:28 PM.
#13
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Nov 2001
Location: Georgia
Posts: 2,619
Likes: 0
Received 51 Likes
on
41 Posts
E 63S Wagon Renntech, E55 Renntech, SL65, SL 55 030, ML, bunch of old ones--they come, they go...
High end...
are you sure that the wheels/tires were all that were changed? Most of us who do wheels tires are going to do a bit of suspension as well, even if it's just springs--and although I fully agree about the recir ball steering--I'll bet you've got some camber issues in the front. Could be that your previous owner took some stuff off, or put the OE back on, or left some of both. This will aggravate the tramlining and general poor feel in the steering, as the front tires may be dancing on just the inside of your tires. A bolt kit is abailable for the 208 (uses a 202 part number), and with a quality alignment, won't make it feel like a Porsche or BMW, but a much better Benz.
Hope this helps...
allen
Hope this helps...
allen
#14
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2003
Posts: 166
Likes: 0
Received 6 Likes
on
2 Posts
2005 E55, 2002 CLK55, 2005 SLK350 also a 2009 BMW 335-IX
Thanks for the pointers...
I really don't know if anything other than the wheels and tires were changed. Would the MB dealer who did the alignment see anything wrong with the camber settings, or notice non-factory parts?
They had the print out results of the alignment there, but I did not get a copy. Should I go back and ask to see that alignment report to look at the camber numbers?
Thanks.
They had the print out results of the alignment there, but I did not get a copy. Should I go back and ask to see that alignment report to look at the camber numbers?
Thanks.
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)