When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
Big Purchase in a few,please help! GS 350 Lexus vs ES350 MB
I'm making a huge purchase today and I'm having a hard time deciding on which vehicle to take. The analogy I use is Iphone vs Android. The GS has all the bells and whistles but the MB is sleek and has all the style..
In the LONG run, which would be the better buy? The E350 has 45k miles and priced at $27k and the GS350 has 30k mikes and prices at $31k.The both ride smooth and nice to look at lol but I need more help. The salesman is more of a Lexus guy so he's pretty bias but please offer your options. FYI, I will be getting a 5/6 yr warranty on either one when purchased.
I had the same choice a while ago and found that the E350 rode better, accelerated better, handled better and was more attractive. However, those opinions are mine, subjective . You should drive each and get the one that feels best to you. I do think that the E will look better and hold its value longer than the Lexus, though.
i see the merc is configured with distronic plus and park assist(not sure as the pics aren't clear for "park" button)
If it is 4matic. I would prefer Merc, else I prefer Merc
Good luck
I was in the market for the same 2 cars. Although in the 2011 range. Lexus imo is a much more reliable car. That said I ended up with a e550.
lexus...well it's a Lexus. The #1 most reliable car every year. At heart I'm a Toyota/ Lexus guy. I do however love my new e550.
I'm making a huge purchase today and I'm having a hard time deciding on which vehicle to take. The analogy I use is Iphone vs Android. The GS has all the bells and whistles but the MB is sleek and has all the style..
In the LONG run, which would be the better buy? The E350 has 45k miles and priced at $27k and the GS350 has 30k mikes and prices at $31k.The both ride smooth and nice to look at lol but I need more help.
It depends: are you making this purchase purely from a fiscal standpoint? Or are you making it from an aesthetic/satisfaction/enjoyment standpoint?
Lots of factors and variables here that'd determine if you're comparing apples to apples: are both cars the same MY? Are the comparably equipped? Are they still under factory warranty? etc?
If money is an issue for you, then obviously you'd go with the less expensive choice, but if money isn't an issue I'd say take both on an extended test drive and buy the one that gives you most comfort/satisfaction/enjoyment.
I buy MB diesels for last 25 years and good luck finding Lexus with one.
For me 35-40 mpg Mercedes is the cheapest vehicle to drive ever.
And yes, even I am not very touchy about prestige, I found out I don't mind it.
Even though benz looks better and i bet drives better and handles lol smart choice would be the lexus, interior wise its alot of new tech and imo looks better aswell.
ive owned a 2013 gs350 f sport it was nice
Benz u may need warranty or extra cash for repairs where lexus u can take all over the country as long as u have money to put gas haha
but having said that if u buy the lexus u will miss that german car feel but u will get piece of mind if ur like me who doesn't like car problems or have time for it
I had the same choice a while ago and found that the E350 rode better, accelerated better, handled better and was more attractive. However, those opinions are mine, subjective . You should drive each and get the one that feels best to you. I do think that the E will look better and hold its value longer than the Lexus, though.
did you decide to purchase the Lexus or the MB? How's the car driving for you now? Any issues?
What has been your own experience with both brands?
I've test drive hem both and they both honestly have a very smooth ride that I'm looking for. They're about the same in size. The Lexus has so many bells and whistles in the inside while the MB has almost the same features but they stand out more in the Lexus. The MB has that undeniable color scheme but the 45k miles is 15k more then what the Lexus has but the MB is cheaper. There's a give and take with each one. The MB exterior looks like a BOSS while the Lexus interior looks like a BOSS. They both drive like thre brand new as well..
It depends: are you making this purchase purely from a fiscal standpoint? Or are you making it from an aesthetic/satisfaction/enjoyment standpoint?
Lots of factors and variables here that'd determine if you're comparing apples to apples: are both cars the same MY? Are the comparably equipped? Are they still under factory warranty? etc?
If money is an issue for you, then obviously you'd go with the less expensive choice, but if money isn't an issue I'd say take both on an extended test drive and buy the one that gives you most comfort/satisfaction/enjoyment.
Thanks for you feedback! That def helps. They're pretty comparable to me but is 45k too many miles for a 2014 priced at 27k?
Thanks for you feedback! That def helps. They're pretty comparable to me but is 45k too many miles for a 2014 priced at 27k?
$27k is darn good for a 2014 E-Class. Not sure how much lower you think you're going to find one for?
I've read your comments, and the big concern for you seems to be price and mileage. In my opinion you can't have both.
If you are concerned with 45,000 miles, then the first question I would ask is when was the car put in service. For example, if it was purchased in June or July of 2013, then technically the car has been driven for 4 years, so 45,000 miles over a four year time frame is a little over 11,000 miles a year...which is less than one would put on a car in a lease. If the car was put into service in 2014, then over a three-year period, it means the car was driven around 15,000 miles a year, which is still average nowadays.
Like I said earlier, instead of focusing on only two aspects, you must make sure you're comparing apples to apples and not apples to oranges, trying to justify a certain price or a certain mileage.
$27k is darn good for a 2014 E-Class. Not sure how much lower you think you're going to find one for?
I've read your comments, and the big concern for you seems to be price and mileage. In my opinion you can't have both.
If you are concerned with 45,000 miles, then the first question I would ask is when was the car put in service. For example, if it was purchased in June or July of 2013, then technically the car has been driven for 4 years, so 45,000 miles over a four year time frame is a little over 11,000 miles a year...which is less than one would put on a car in a lease. If the car was put into service in 2014, then over a three-year period, it means the car was driven around 15,000 miles a year, which is still average nowadays.
Like I said earlier, instead of focusing on only two aspects, you must make sure you're comparing apples to apples and not apples to oranges, trying to justify a certain price or a certain mileage.
27k is high pls go on cars.com and u will find 1 fir under 25k easily
Toyota / Lexus is the gold standard for reliability.
Any car can go pear-shaped, but the odds are stacked in your favor with Toyota / Lexus versus nearly everything else on the road.
<><><>
Despite a ~100hp deficit, recall the GS350 F-Sport nearly beat the CTS V-Sport in one or more comparisons back in ~'13-14. Therefore, I think it's safe to say the GS will be more of a driver's car than the E350. (Disclaimer: I don't have any seat time with the E350. And I'd be driving a GS today if it was offered with some muscle to rival or at least come close to the M278 in the E550.)
I have a 2010 E350 and really like it. Has luxury (comfort) suspension, but still fairly harsh.
But, the Lexus is the better car for reliability and resale (if that matters). Johnny Rad said it and it is true.
Not sure what year models you are presenting, but both are harsh riding cars. More recent GS models are supposed to ride better.
Absoulutely must take both for 30-60 minute test drives over rough roads. Tell sales rep to shut up and not distract you. Pay attention to ride and noise levels-turn the audio off.
Both are going to be expensive to service and repair, but MB probably moreso because you will have to do it more often.
As for interior vs. exterior, both are important. BUT you will spend a lot more time inside riding in it than outside looking at it.
If you get the MB, definitely get the extended warranty from MBUSA - you will need it.
Not an easy decision, good luck.
The e350 is going to depreciate like crazy just look at how the 2010/2011 models are going for i can get a nice loaded one for like 15k ez if i look around where the gs is still selling for 20k n up with high miles and not even loaded
its a ez decison if u know what u want out of a car
do u want prestige and attitude? Benz
do u want piece of mind and resale ? Lexus
Even though benz looks better and i bet drives better and handles lol smart choice would be the lexus, interior wise its alot of new tech and imo looks better aswell.
ive owned a 2013 gs350 f sport it was nice
Benz u may need warranty or extra cash for repairs where lexus u can take all over the country as long as u have money to put gas haha
but having said that if u buy the lexus u will miss that german car feel but u will get piece of mind if ur like me who doesn't like car problems or have time for it
Originally Posted by dildil
27k is high pls go on cars.com and u will find 1 fir under 25k easily
Originally Posted by dildil
you obviously didnt do ur research
Originally Posted by dildil
The e350 is going to depreciate like crazy just look at how the 2010/2011 models are going for i can get a nice loaded one for like 15k ez if i look around where the gs is still selling for 20k n up with high miles and not even loaded
its a ez decison if u know what u want out of a car
do u want prestige and attitude? Benz
do u want piece of mind and resale ? Lexus
do u wanna have lil bit fun? Lexus
do u want a drivers car ? Benz
OK, you took it there:
Based on your above posts, you obviously didn't consult your dictionary.
-only 28 cars nationwide under $27k and under 45k miles
-most of them are base Luxury models (not that there's anything wrong with that)
-none of them are from MB dealerships or CPO'd
-none of them are fully loaded (or even decently equipped, for that matter)
-lots are from mom-and-pop used cars lots, draw your own conclusions from there...
So, like I said, if you are comparing apples to apples and want to check all the boxes, then $27k is a good price...and if you want to be cheap and try to steal one for $21k, then you get what you pay for!
When you are ready to offer something objective and substantial to the OP or to the thread, instead of subjective smart-Alec remarks trying to refute what's already mentioned, then let us know.
Last edited by tresean1; Jun 11, 2017 at 07:00 PM.
Mercedes SLR McLaren 722 S Is Extremely Rare Example Modified by McLaren
Slideshow: A one-of-one U.S.-spec Mercedes-Benz SLR McLaren Roadster became even rarer after a factory-backed transformation at McLaren's headquarters.
