Strong kick when I put in drive when cold. (‘03 automatic)




Is this an early sign of a problem?
Thank you,
Sixcarbs





> How about :
-- wait 2mn for Rpm to settle down near idle.
-- Then shift into Drive!
Even I am doing that procedure in the morning.
At rest the stack of plates in clutch packs are jammed together. By shifting at idle with lower ATF pressure forces are very limited. Clutches get separated more gently.
Fresh clean MB ATF never hurts by providing good viscosity. Tranny has no real filtration. It has magnets plus strainers. When old fluid produces a lot of contaminants valve screens endup plugged with reduced control pressure.
If your idle stays high up too long, concentrate on engine issues... OBDII scan.

Last edited by CaliBenzDriver; May 7, 2025 at 02:19 PM.





> How about :
-- wait 2mn for Rpm to settle down near idle.
-- Then shift into Drive!
Even I am doing that procedure in the morning.
At rest the stack of plates in clutch packs are jammed together. By shifting at idle with lower ATF pressure forces are very limited. Clutches get separated more gently.
Fresh clean MB ATF never hurts by providing good viscosity. Tranny has no real filtration. It has magnets plus strainers. When old fluid produces a lot of contaminants valve screens endup plugged with reduced control pressure.
If your idle stays high up too long, concentrate on engine issues... OBDII scan.

I really appreciate your wealth of knowledge and willingness to share. It is invaluable!




Maybe I have been in a rush lately??
I did have the transmission fluid changed in November after I bought the car and they ended up replacing the transmission ECU.
I really appreciate your wealth of knowledge and willingness to share. It is invaluable!
You've done necessary ATF service + new TCU.
Nothing good results from ignoring poor shifts.
How many miles on what engine type ?
If you don't have a scanner... get a $150 Launch cReader Elite for MB to read whole chassis fault report.




I really appreciate your wealth of knowledge and willingness to share. It is invaluable!




You've done necessary ATF service + new TCU.
Nothing good results from ignoring poor shifts.
How many miles on what engine type ?
If you don't have a scanner... get a $150 Launch cReader Elite for MB to read whole chassis fault report.
I was careful this morning, let it warm up longer, and things seemed better. I just heard a quiet click.
And then....
The car must have heard me talking about it. I was making a left turn onto a major boulevard after a downhill side street in heavy traffic. As I made the left I lost power. It popped into neutral. I don't recall if the gear shift actually moved, but I moved it back (Maybe I moved it forward too first). I had power again, and was getting on the highway. But then my RPM's would not drop. I was on a highway bridge in heavy flow with the revs between 3,000 and 3,500. The car would not upshift! I moved the lever sideways left and right but nothing changed.
I got off and pulled into a parking lot. I did not want to troubleshoot and end up worse than having a single gear. I pressed the C/S button moving it to "S." I shut the car off and re-started it and began driving in "S" mode and the car seemed to be shifting normally. Like I said I was not in a troubleshooting mood so I just drove home and made an appointment with my service shop Tuesday morning.
Back to the wife's B200. (sigh....)




I had just bought the car (159,000 KM) so I thought changing the transmission fluid was a good idea. The car had sat outside on a used car lot ion Germany for a year. I also told them to change some plug in the transmission known for oil leaks.
The shop reported oil leaking into the TCU and said it should be replaced and I said ok.
Trending Topics




I was careful this morning, let it warm up longer, and things seemed better. I just heard a quiet click.
And then....
The car must have heard me talking about it. I was making a left turn onto a major boulevard after a downhill side street in heavy traffic. As I made the left I lost power. It popped into neutral. I don't recall if the gear shift actually moved, but I moved it back (Maybe I moved it forward too first). I had power again, and was getting on the highway. But then my RPM's would not drop. I was on a highway bridge in heavy flow with the revs between 3,000 and 3,500. The car would not upshift! I moved the lever sideways left and right but nothing changed.
I got off and pulled into a parking lot. I did not want to troubleshoot and end up worse than having a single gear. I pressed the C/S button moving it to "S." I shut the car off and re-started it and began driving in "S" mode and the car seemed to be shifting normally. Like I said I was not in a troubleshooting mood so I just drove home and made an appointment with my service shop Tuesday morning.
Back to the wife's B200. (sigh....)
Tranny is not shifting... limp mode.
You've just had fresh service and a whole new TCU with new connector - It should shift without any second thoughts.
Feel free to scan the FAULT CODES for us before shop clears them. Danke.

+++ This may be "referred faults" by non co-operating module. Fault report would help get clues.
Last edited by CaliBenzDriver; May 8, 2025 at 08:29 PM.
The Best of Mercedes & AMG




I gave them a list of 9 items below. Now, many might see me as an easy mark to change the battery and the spark plugs. After he said the transmission was fine he added your spark plugs and battery are good, no need to change them. Total bill: $70. (Yes, seventy)
=================================================
1. Transmission issue? After a left turn on Knez Milosa the car slipped into neutral. I got it back in gear and continued onto Gazelle bridge/highway. The car would not upshift and stayed at 3000 to 3500 RPM the whole time on the highway. I stopped the car, switched from “C” to “S” and shut the car off and re-started. I drove home from New Belgrade to Dedinje in “S” and it seemed to shift fine.
Was that “Limp mode?” Is there a history of codes that can be printed before they are cleared? I remember we changed the TCU back in November.
2. Driver’s side door lock needs to be physically higher. Because it is set so low it does not open sometimes and requires key.
3. Amplifier in glovebox bolt.
4. Suspension noise- The car makes many sounds, especially in the morning. Please re-evaluate suspension bushings, ball joints, tie rods, engine mounts, and anything else that could be squeaking or knocking.
5. Spark plugs- How much to change all 12 with Bosch or NGK plugs?
6. Battery- How much to change to a quality 100 Amp-H battery?
7. Calibrate Climate Control knob calibration
8. Document any codes before clearing. Two catalytic converters were removed.
9. Electronics shop could not fix rear defroster. Everything they tested was fine. Where to go now? Do I need a new window or can it be “re-taped?”
Last edited by Sixcarbs; May 13, 2025 at 07:27 AM.




Connect a good MB scanner under the dashboard to read while set of chassis faults.
These MB cars are built to be really VOLTAGE SENSITIVE - Don't waste days to conclude battery charge was low: use a good float battery charger.
Goofy tranny is a significant disruption even for a Mercedes.
Last edited by CaliBenzDriver; May 14, 2025 at 02:25 AM.




Connect a good MB scanner under the dashboard to read while set of chassis faults.
These MB cars are built to be really VOLTAGE SENSITIVE - Don't waste days to conclude battery charge was low: use a good float battery charger.
Goofy tranny is a significant disruption even for a Mercedes.
Regarding the battery, I had just noticed mine was born with the 100 Amp and figured it couldn’t hurt.
I do not have an outlet where I park.
You are my Rabbi here and I will do my best to follow your guidance.
Thank you again




Regarding the battery, I had just noticed mine was born with the 100 Amp and figured it couldn’t hurt.
I do not have an outlet where I park.
You are my Rabbi here and I will do my best to follow your guidance.
Thank you again
Dealer can replace new batteries every month ... only you can maintain it well charged up.
Get a good scanner connected to retrieve live faults. This will guide good repairs.

Last edited by CaliBenzDriver; May 14, 2025 at 03:05 PM.


