Damn this Limiter
If you want to drive fast on the streets, you need the 911 Turbo S cab. This car is unreal.
Trending Topics
If you want to drive fast on the streets, you need the 911 Turbo S cab. This car is unreal.
The Best of Mercedes & AMG
As I stated before, if you want to drive faster (relatively safely) than 150 MPH, add a Porsche or Ferrari to your stable. My 911 Turbo S will do 198 MPH and stop in an instant.
I am simply saying that you have to be able to stop quickly and controlled when speeding around in the streets. Even though my Benz has awesome AMG brakes, they do not stop with the authority of the PCCB’s or Porsche Ceramic Composite Brakes. The PCCB’s are unreal and can bruise your ribs with repeated brake stomps.
This any a few other reasons is why I like the Porsche over the Benz to race around the streets or OC.




I am simply saying that you have to be able to stop quickly and controlled when speeding around in the streets. Even though my Benz has awesome AMG brakes, they do not stop with the authority of the PCCB’s or Porsche Ceramic Composite Brakes. The PCCB’s are unreal and can bruise your ribs with repeated brake stomps.
This any a few other reasons is why I like the Porsche over the Benz to race around the streets or OC.
When it comes to highway driving or driving on the Autobahn, the S-class even with the standard brakes (like the S500) is perfectly able to safely slow down and stop the car at any speed, including 155 mph. Have done that for years and this is what these cars are engineered for. Safe driving and braking has always been a priority over acceleration at MB and other German car manufacturers.
These kinds of comments are just plain nonsense.
Wolfman
Btw, the 155mph limiter is a self-imposed limit by the manufacturers and not guided by any laws, including in Germany.
The manufacturer sets the limit according to legal liability and the cars engineering.
The S600 is built as a luxury sports car, but luxury is first. A Porsche or Ferrari is a sports car with a little luxury (leather, radio, Nav, electric seats/windows). They are a sports cars first. The Benz can not compare to around the town sporting especially the SL65 or SLK55. They both tend to run warm under hard driving in OC in the summertime.
The Porsche and Ferrari manufacturers need not limit the car because it is built to drive at higher rates of speed and they are less likely to be liable.




The manufacturer sets the limit according to legal liability and the cars engineering.
The S600 is built as a luxury sports car, but luxury is first. A Porsche or Ferrari is a sports car with a little luxury (leather, radio, Nav, electric seats/windows). They are a sports cars first. The Benz can not compare to around the town sporting especially the SL65 or SLK55. They both tend to run warm under hard driving in OC in the summertime.
The Porsche and Ferrari manufacturers need not limit the car because it is built to drive at higher rates of speed and they are less likely to be liable.
The 250 km/h or 155 mph limit started initially when standard sedans were able to go faster and move towards the 300 km/h mark. Given German traffic conditions (high traffic density and the limited use of the left speeding lane which can easily have traffic moving 80 mph faster than the right lane), all major German manufacturers with the exception of Porsche decided to limit their cars to 155mph. But it is important to understand that this was primarily a marketing move and not appear reckless, nothing else. Porsche excluded themselves due to the fact that they were strictly a sports car manufacturer and this limit would have hurt their brand. Besides, there are very few Porsche's compared to millions of cars on German highways that can go the speed.
Today, many manufacturers offer speed delimiting directly from the factory.
The only LEGAL requirement that German car manufacturers have is that the car can be driven and handled safely at any speed it is capable of. So if it can go 180+mph then it must be safe to use from 0-180+ mph. Simple as that.
There are NO liability issues whatsoever related to speed for the manufacturer, only for the driver (in Germany). Anytime an accident occurs, a car driving above 180km/h may be considered at fault. This is the result once again of the traffic conditions, not engineering.
You also keep on bringing up speeding on streets. Throwing a car around the corner has really nothing to do with safety.
I venture out to say that a S600 is in fact much safer at high speeds that a Porsche or Ferrari, including the ability to walk away from the car in case of an accident.
It takes more than strong brakes to make a safe car. You also need well designed active and passive safety systems and you need a heavy car.
Btw, since you discuss track vs. streets, German highways are designed for speeds up to 250 mph or 400 km/h. This has actually less to do with the surface of the road but with the design of curves to keep you on the road.
Wolfman
Correct, the S600 is very safe and that is why I drive one. The object is not to get into the accident and I think the Porsche or Ferrari has a better chance of NOT getting into an accident when driving at high rates of speed.




Correct, the S600 is very safe and that is why I drive one. The object is not to get into the accident and I think the Porsche or Ferrari has a better chance of NOT getting into an accident when driving at high rates of speed.
I also believe that you get to know any cars limitation when you drive them regularly and at their limits.
Having lived in Europe and traveling by car for business I have logged countless high-speed miles on a couple of S-classes and got to know them up close and personal. A friend of mine had a Ruf conversion of a Porsche Turbo which we had taken through hours of high-speed excursions in the french burgundy. The highway there is quite curvy and a real challenge at 190+mph. So I do have a bit of experience...
Point is that this kind of driving is simply not available anywhere in the US and when we discuss why cars are being speed-limited it is valuable to understand those backgrounds.
Don't get me wrong. Porsche's and Ferraris are beautiful high perfomance cars. But in the area of accident avoidance they simply aren't better, rather the opposite. Both are more difficult to manover at high speeds, at least in real traffic conditions due to their less invasive or missing traction controls. Braking from 150+ to 0 requires a certain distance no matter how good the brakes. If that distance isn't available, a heavier car with with elaborate traction and brake controls will win.
Wolfman
Last edited by Wolfman; Jun 11, 2006 at 02:43 AM.




