BMW vs. Benz: Mods/hacks/DIYs/retrofits
Can this sort of thing be done on the Benz platform? Since I now essentially own a S550 (car is still across the country...) from years of owning several BMW 7s, I started looking for mods/hacks/DIYs/retrofits for the Benz. Speaking of retrofits, there often features available in newer gen BMWs that can be transplanted to an older platform. And while I can always find plenty of that for BMWs, I am coming up short for the Benz. Am I just looking in the wrong places, or, is Benz more restrictive/limited or the Benz crowd simply less of the DIY type?
As an example, I saw that the MY13 M-Class supports A2DP, AVRCP, and MAP Bluetooth profiles, I know it is not available for the W221. After looking around, I don't see the possibility of a retrofit. Based upon my experience with BMWs, such retrofit would be possible and someone would have posted a DIY article. Here is one example BMW E38 DIYs/mods: http://www.e38.org/
This is not at all about bashing Benz or suggesting that it is inferior. I know better :-) I believe that there are *many* things that the Benz does very well or better than the Bavarian offering. Afterall, I am "here" and not "there". I simply want to understand the landscape better, having never owned a Benz...
Thanks.
Edit: I have to add that this Forum has been great so far. I have received great help from many members, some well above and beyond... The help this Forum provided played a crucial role in my decision to go Benz.... Cheers.
Last edited by snovvman; Feb 1, 2015 at 12:18 PM.
The problem is that the knock off tool is much more expensive (more than 20 times) than the BMW one, which is like £10 for a K+D CAN INPA adapter.
The software is also a lot more complicated, not to mention the set up.
So that's why you don't see as many people playing around with MB systems on the internet. It just isn't as popular due to a higher bar of entry.


The problem is that the knock off tool is much more expensive (more than 20 times) than the BMW one, which is like £10 for a K+D CAN INPA adapter.
The software is also a lot more complicated, not to mention the set up.
So that's why you don't see as many people playing around with MB systems on the internet. It just isn't as popular due to a higher bar of entry.
I think mercedes does tend to be very restrictive and makes it difficult to modify their cars. There are a few people on the web that do retrofits on mercs for a living like i believe mbenznl
Last edited by Nickthegreek; Feb 2, 2015 at 05:16 PM.
Can't the shop drill into the onboard computers and detected the non-authorized modification and void the warranty? I wondered that about the people that change the programming on ignition systems. In some countries you get fined for such a mod. In other places, repairs simply are excluded from warranty coverage maybe.
I guess if the car is out of warranty coverage, what does it matter.
Can't the shop drill into the onboard computers and detected the non-authorized modification and void the warranty? I wondered that about the people that change the programming on ignition systems. In some countries you get fined for such a mod. In other places, repairs simply are excluded from warranty coverage maybe.
I guess if the car is out of warranty coverage, what does it matter.
Trending Topics
If I flashed the programming on my ECM/DME (don't know what Benz calls their engine management computers) from U.S. to EU and back again, and my nav screen suffers a hardware failure, I think they would have a hard time making a case to deny warranty.
I've made many mods to my BMWs using factory software/hardware, and never once has the dealer give me a hard time. Again, don't know about Benz.
The Best of Mercedes & AMG
If I flashed the programming on my ECM/DME (don't know what Benz calls their engine management computers) from U.S. to EU and back again, and my nav screen suffers a hardware failure, I think they would have a hard time making a case to deny warranty.
I've made many mods to my BMWs using factory software/hardware, and never once has the dealer give me a hard time. Again, don't know about Benz.
I am not questioning a mod to the tail lights and warranty coverage to a failure of the power seats...
I question a modification to ignition programming and boost the engine output. If you make that mod and later on have a tranny issue BMW won't bat an eye and cover repairs under warranty? Good to know.
For the BMW GT1, someone developed a multiplexer emulator. This allowed the use of a generic cable that cost less than $100. I have not seen the same on the M-B side. I do see Chinese-made interfaces but have read that some do not work properly.
It would be great to see/explore/edit the settings and perform my own diagnostics. I realize I am taking a chance with warranty issues, but it is much too interesting to ignore. If anyone has information, please send it this way. Thanks.
BTW, this thread is primarily C3, but it will help you with learning what can be done with the STAR Diagnose system (XENTRY/DAS C3 [serial connection version] and C4 SD Connect [wireless and wired Ethernet connections version])https://mbworld.org/forums/w211-amg/...ts-o-pics.html
Last edited by Nuru; Feb 15, 2015 at 06:54 PM.


For the BMW GT1, someone developed a multiplexer emulator. This allowed the use of a generic cable that cost less than $100. I have not seen the same on the M-B side. I do see Chinese-made interfaces but have read that some do not work properly.
It would be great to see/explore/edit the settings and perform my own diagnostics. I realize I am taking a chance with warranty issues, but it is much too interesting to ignore. If anyone has information, please send it this way. Thanks.




Last edited by Nickthegreek; Feb 18, 2015 at 01:44 AM.
Last edited by Nuru; Feb 18, 2015 at 06:35 PM.






