Anyone else disappointed with the w205?
Thread Starter
Junior Member
Joined: May 2008
Posts: 47
Likes: 2
From: Alexandria, VA
'17 C300 Sport, P2, Pano, Black; '17 Jetta GLI White
Anyone else disappointed with the w205?
Finally traded in my w204 2008 C300 Sport for a new 2016 c300. What a downgrade. Rougher ride, poor cornering, swimmy suspension, cant leave in sport mode, cant shut off eco, worse sound system, rougher transmission, the list goes on. Can't believe people think this car was improved. Has anyone been able to improve the suspension? This thing wobbles like an old buick lesabre. Also pitches forward on braking using too much front brake. Just disappointing.
Just dont get it. My 2008 rode and handled better. Seems like i would need to get a 450 or better to get the same ride.
Just dont get it. My 2008 rode and handled better. Seems like i would need to get a 450 or better to get the same ride.
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: May 2008
Posts: 7,653
Likes: 560
2016 C300
That's not even the worst part. The worst part is these dealers who are kidnapping W204 owners and refusing to release them unless they trade their beloved cars in on a W205 without allowing so much as a simple test drive. It's criminal!
Member
Joined: Dec 2015
Posts: 145
Likes: 33
From: New York
2014 E350 Coupe (previous), 2016 C450 AMG Sport (previous), 2020 GLE450 (previous), 2021 S580 (now)
The only thing you should be disappointed in is yourself for apparently choosing to NOT drive the 2016 C300 or learn anything about the vehicle and its features before choosing to buy one.
The W205 C300 is a great vehicle in its own right, but as far as your personal opinion of it is concerned...ya played yourself.
The W205 C300 is a great vehicle in its own right, but as far as your personal opinion of it is concerned...ya played yourself.
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: May 2008
Posts: 7,653
Likes: 560
2016 C300
Originally Posted by LOGOSDJ
The only thing you should be disappointed in is yourself for apparently choosing to NOT drive the 2016 C300 or learn anything about the vehicle and its features before choosing to buy one.
The W205 C300 is a great vehicle in its own right, but as far as your personal opinion of it is concerned...ya played yourself.
The W205 C300 is a great vehicle in its own right, but as far as your personal opinion of it is concerned...ya played yourself.
Thread Starter
Junior Member
Joined: May 2008
Posts: 47
Likes: 2
From: Alexandria, VA
'17 C300 Sport, P2, Pano, Black; '17 Jetta GLI White
The only thing you should be disappointed in is yourself for apparently choosing to NOT drive the 2016 C300 or learn anything about the vehicle and its features before choosing to buy one.
The W205 C300 is a great vehicle in its own right, but as far as your personal opinion of it is concerned...ya played yourself.
The W205 C300 is a great vehicle in its own right, but as far as your personal opinion of it is concerned...ya played yourself.
The suspension is what really does it for me though. When I take a turn at 25, the car should hug the corner, not lean over on its side. Or when you brake hard, it shouldn't pitch forward. Not sure what has changed but its for the worse so I cant call it a "great vehicle." They have gone back in time.
As for the little nuances like not staying in sport mode or being able to turn off the eco, thats just annoying and flat out stupid.
Played myself? Hardly. Its just a car and I have more than one. Just disappointed in this one. I thought it would be my new daily driver but I guess I will drive my Jetta GLI and save this for long trips or give it to my mom.
Thread Starter
Junior Member
Joined: May 2008
Posts: 47
Likes: 2
From: Alexandria, VA
'17 C300 Sport, P2, Pano, Black; '17 Jetta GLI White
LOL! It was dying. multiple oil leaks, needed an overhaul.
Trending Topics
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: May 2008
Posts: 7,653
Likes: 560
2016 C300
Originally Posted by purefunk
Yes and no. Of course I drove it a couple times. Drove a few different models but its hard to gauge the performance of it on a few test drives unless you drive the AMG versus the 300. Taking it on long distance drives that I had done before and having it for a few weeks is more of a test IMO.
The suspension is what really does it for me though. When I take a turn at 25, the car should hug the corner, not lean over on its side. Or when you brake hard, it shouldn't pitch forward. Not sure what has changed but its for the worse so I cant call it a "great vehicle." They have gone back in time.
As for the little nuances like not staying in sport mode or being able to turn off the eco, thats just annoying and flat out stupid.
Played myself? Hardly. Its just a car and I have more than one. Just disappointed in this one. I thought it would be my new daily driver but I guess I will drive my Jetta GLI and save this for long trips or give it to my mom.
The suspension is what really does it for me though. When I take a turn at 25, the car should hug the corner, not lean over on its side. Or when you brake hard, it shouldn't pitch forward. Not sure what has changed but its for the worse so I cant call it a "great vehicle." They have gone back in time.
As for the little nuances like not staying in sport mode or being able to turn off the eco, thats just annoying and flat out stupid.
Played myself? Hardly. Its just a car and I have more than one. Just disappointed in this one. I thought it would be my new daily driver but I guess I will drive my Jetta GLI and save this for long trips or give it to my mom.
The default Agility mode and Eco Stop issues are well publicized. No pre-purchase research?
You have a lot of cars but one of your "fleet" was a nine year old beater C on its last breath and another is a Jetta? Is there a Yugo in there somewhere?
I mean, there's nothing wrong with preferring a prior gen to the new version. I liked my W220 S more than my W221 in a lot of respects but nothing about the 221 surprised me. Pluses and minuses for each.
I can say personally the 204 struck me as a bit of a turd. When the S was in the shop I'd beg for any loaner other than a 204. Just felt cheap, looked cheap and drove cheap to me.
On the other hand when I got a 205 loaner I decided to trade the S and order one. Forget the relative merits of the 204 vs 205. I don't understand how you can buy a car (any car) that has handling characteristics you loathe.
MB World Stories
The Best of Mercedes & AMG
Manual Mercedes? 6 Times Sindelfingen Let Drivers Have All The Fun
Verdad Gallardo
Mercedes SLR McLaren 722 S Is Extremely Rare Example Modified by McLaren
Verdad Gallardo
8 Classic Boxy Mercedes Designs That Have Aged Like Fine Wine
Verdad Gallardo
Flawlessly Restored Mercedes 190E Evo II Heads to Auction
Verdad Gallardo
Electric Mercedes C-Class Unveiled: 11 Things You Need to Know
Verdad Gallardo
Mercedes EQS Gets A Major Update: Everything You Need to Know
Verdad Gallardo
5 Underrated Mercedes-Benz Models That Don't Get the Love They Deserve
Verdad Gallardo
Mercedes 300D Has Pushed Well Past 1 Million Miles and It Ain't Stopping
Verdad Gallardo
10 Most Reliable Mercedes-Benz Models You Can Buy Used
Verdad Gallardo
Member
Joined: Jan 2016
Posts: 229
Likes: 9
2016 C300
I'm always confused by the hyperbolic statements about how bad a car is on these forums. For example, the massive body lean at 25 mph described here. Not one review of the car has suggested this is the case, yet here we have a poster indicating that the chassis is so poorly sorted that, if he's to be believed, the car is borderline unsafe to drive.
Member
Joined: Mar 2017
Posts: 233
Likes: 13
2018 C350Te Wagon
But of course these kind of threads makes all the difference. That said, I actually knew the suspension never would be as fit and steering as direct as my 320. I wasn't opting for it either, but then again I've only driven the 205 on comfort steel suspension and mine will have Airmatic. So I am hoping for a better ride.
As far as drive modes, it takes you a good two seconds to change. And you took it for a good ride but it was more like a test IMO! What does that even mean?
Thread Starter
Junior Member
Joined: May 2008
Posts: 47
Likes: 2
From: Alexandria, VA
'17 C300 Sport, P2, Pano, Black; '17 Jetta GLI White
Hey, its my fault 100%. I had a few test drives and then set up an appointment to pick up a new one on a different day. I should have drove it more but I didn't because I never had a problem with the dealership. Its not hyperbole, its fact. When you take a corner at 25 the car leans over on its side and pitches forward on stopping. I didn't notice it on the final test drive. Again, my fault.
In any case, this forum has always been helpful (maybe not this post but I do enjoy the replies). I was searching last night and found some posts where c300 Sport was delivered with comfort suspension. Checked mine last night and I have Sport Trim but comfort suspension installed at final assembly in Alabama. Called my dealership. Waiting on their response.
Mike 5215, If you think having 3 cars is a fleet, then I guess I have one. Although I did have a fleet of tractor trailers once for my sod business. The Jetta GLI is fun to drive though and handles better in corners. Never owned a Yugo but had a Datsun 510 in college.
In any case, this forum has always been helpful (maybe not this post but I do enjoy the replies). I was searching last night and found some posts where c300 Sport was delivered with comfort suspension. Checked mine last night and I have Sport Trim but comfort suspension installed at final assembly in Alabama. Called my dealership. Waiting on their response.
Mike 5215, If you think having 3 cars is a fleet, then I guess I have one. Although I did have a fleet of tractor trailers once for my sod business. The Jetta GLI is fun to drive though and handles better in corners. Never owned a Yugo but had a Datsun 510 in college.
Member
Joined: Mar 2017
Posts: 233
Likes: 13
2018 C350Te Wagon
Hey, its my fault 100%. I had a few test drives and then set up an appointment to pick up a new one on a different day. I should have drove it more but I didn't because I never had a problem with the dealership. Its not hyperbole, its fact. When you take a corner at 25 the car leans over on its side and pitches forward on stopping. I didn't notice it on the final test drive. Again, my fault.
In any case, this forum has always been helpful (maybe not this post but I do enjoy the replies). I was searching last night and found some posts where c300 Sport was delivered with comfort suspension. Checked mine last night and I have Sport Trim but comfort suspension installed at final assembly in Alabama. Called my dealership. Waiting on their response.
Mike 5215, If you think having 3 cars is a fleet, then I guess I have one. Although I did have a fleet of tractor trailers once for my sod business. The Jetta GLI is fun to drive though and handles better in corners. Never owned a Yugo but had a Datsun 510 in college.
In any case, this forum has always been helpful (maybe not this post but I do enjoy the replies). I was searching last night and found some posts where c300 Sport was delivered with comfort suspension. Checked mine last night and I have Sport Trim but comfort suspension installed at final assembly in Alabama. Called my dealership. Waiting on their response.
Mike 5215, If you think having 3 cars is a fleet, then I guess I have one. Although I did have a fleet of tractor trailers once for my sod business. The Jetta GLI is fun to drive though and handles better in corners. Never owned a Yugo but had a Datsun 510 in college.
Hope it sorts out for you
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: May 2008
Posts: 7,653
Likes: 560
2016 C300
Hey, its my fault 100%. I had a few test drives and then set up an appointment to pick up a new one on a different day. I should have drove it more but I didn't because I never had a problem with the dealership. Its not hyperbole, its fact. When you take a corner at 25 the car leans over on its side and pitches forward on stopping. I didn't notice it on the final test drive. Again, my fault.
In any case, this forum has always been helpful (maybe not this post but I do enjoy the replies). I was searching last night and found some posts where c300 Sport was delivered with comfort suspension. Checked mine last night and I have Sport Trim but comfort suspension installed at final assembly in Alabama. Called my dealership. Waiting on their response.
Mike 5215, If you think having 3 cars is a fleet, then I guess I have one. Although I did have a fleet of tractor trailers once for my sod business. The Jetta GLI is fun to drive though and handles better in corners. Never owned a Yugo but had a Datsun 510 in college.
In any case, this forum has always been helpful (maybe not this post but I do enjoy the replies). I was searching last night and found some posts where c300 Sport was delivered with comfort suspension. Checked mine last night and I have Sport Trim but comfort suspension installed at final assembly in Alabama. Called my dealership. Waiting on their response.
Mike 5215, If you think having 3 cars is a fleet, then I guess I have one. Although I did have a fleet of tractor trailers once for my sod business. The Jetta GLI is fun to drive though and handles better in corners. Never owned a Yugo but had a Datsun 510 in college.
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Sep 2014
Posts: 1,822
Likes: 33
From: Whitefield, NH
2015 C300 Sport: Palladium, Premium, Multimedia, Leather, BLIS
I had a Datsun 510 years ago too. It was called the poor man's BMW back then, and was a lot of fun to drive.
My C300 Sport handles fairly well, and I really have no complaints about lean in turns or dive under heavy braking. I did have a base C300 for a while, and that was not nearly as solid feeling in hard cornering ... usually felt like it was understeering. For me, the steel sport suspension with its 18" tires works just fine. Decent, not great, ride and competent handling. Overall, this car compares well to my two previous Audi A4's.
I have owned several sports cars over the years, attended a few high performance driving and rally schools, and have some time on the track. While my C300 certainly does not feel like a sports car, it does offer a reasonable compromise between comfort and street handling. I would never track it, but it does do fine in its role as my daily driver.
In the case of the OP's issues, I wonder if something is out of whack. Suspension components, tires, wheels, alignment? I don't know, but that description of the car's handling is anything but typical.
My C300 Sport handles fairly well, and I really have no complaints about lean in turns or dive under heavy braking. I did have a base C300 for a while, and that was not nearly as solid feeling in hard cornering ... usually felt like it was understeering. For me, the steel sport suspension with its 18" tires works just fine. Decent, not great, ride and competent handling. Overall, this car compares well to my two previous Audi A4's.
I have owned several sports cars over the years, attended a few high performance driving and rally schools, and have some time on the track. While my C300 certainly does not feel like a sports car, it does offer a reasonable compromise between comfort and street handling. I would never track it, but it does do fine in its role as my daily driver.
In the case of the OP's issues, I wonder if something is out of whack. Suspension components, tires, wheels, alignment? I don't know, but that description of the car's handling is anything but typical.
Thread Starter
Junior Member
Joined: May 2008
Posts: 47
Likes: 2
From: Alexandria, VA
'17 C300 Sport, P2, Pano, Black; '17 Jetta GLI White
I had a Datsun 510 years ago too. It was called the poor man's BMW back then, and was a lot of fun to drive.
My C300 Sport handles fairly well, and I really have no complaints about lean in turns or dive under heavy braking. I did have a base C300 for a while, and that was not nearly as solid feeling in hard cornering ... usually felt like it was understeering. For me, the steel sport suspension with its 18" tires works just fine. Decent, not great, ride and competent handling. Overall, this car compares well to my two previous Audi A4's.
I have owned several sports cars over the years, attended a few high performance driving and rally schools, and have some time on the track. While my C300 certainly does not feel like a sports car, it does offer a reasonable compromise between comfort and street handling. I would never track it, but it does do fine in its role as my daily driver.
In the case of the OP's issues, I wonder if something is out of whack. Suspension components, tires, wheels, alignment? I don't know, but that description of the car's handling is anything but typical.
My C300 Sport handles fairly well, and I really have no complaints about lean in turns or dive under heavy braking. I did have a base C300 for a while, and that was not nearly as solid feeling in hard cornering ... usually felt like it was understeering. For me, the steel sport suspension with its 18" tires works just fine. Decent, not great, ride and competent handling. Overall, this car compares well to my two previous Audi A4's.
I have owned several sports cars over the years, attended a few high performance driving and rally schools, and have some time on the track. While my C300 certainly does not feel like a sports car, it does offer a reasonable compromise between comfort and street handling. I would never track it, but it does do fine in its role as my daily driver.
In the case of the OP's issues, I wonder if something is out of whack. Suspension components, tires, wheels, alignment? I don't know, but that description of the car's handling is anything but typical.
Mike, how do I tell if they are run flats? They are 18 inch continental pro contact? And what else should I have the dealer change if its an option to give it the right ride.
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: May 2008
Posts: 7,653
Likes: 560
2016 C300
If they're OEM they're runflats. A lot of us are running the MPSS and have added a Seal & Fill kit in the trunk in the event of a flat. They ride and handle much better, are quieter and last longer than the RFs. Since it's a lease and needs to be returned with RFs I just threw mine in the garage when I first got the car.
As far as the car having the wrong suspension, I'd be shocked if the dealer put themselves on the hook for that. Unless you had the car built. Then there's a problem. I think you'd have to resort to self help and get a set of aftermarket springs and a camber bolt set from K Mac. Probably around $700 installed if I recall from previous threads.
If the appearance of the higher ride height isn't a concern and you just want to firm the car's handling up, going to a 19" wheel with a lower offset up might do it. Like a 35mm offset up front especially will widen the stance and resist body lean more, as will a shorter, stiffer sidewall on a 19" vs an 18".
As far as the car having the wrong suspension, I'd be shocked if the dealer put themselves on the hook for that. Unless you had the car built. Then there's a problem. I think you'd have to resort to self help and get a set of aftermarket springs and a camber bolt set from K Mac. Probably around $700 installed if I recall from previous threads.
If the appearance of the higher ride height isn't a concern and you just want to firm the car's handling up, going to a 19" wheel with a lower offset up might do it. Like a 35mm offset up front especially will widen the stance and resist body lean more, as will a shorter, stiffer sidewall on a 19" vs an 18".
MBWorld Fanatic!
Joined: Mar 2015
Posts: 1,581
Likes: 114
From: Mass
2026 GLE 53 Coupe
I test drove a 2015 C300 4Matic with the base suspension before buying, and I thought the suspension was WAY too soft. So I made sure to order a C300 "Sport" with the "sport suspension" and the 19" AMG wheels. I thought that setup was great on my old 2015 C300, which I then traded a year later for my current C450 because of my thirst for even more power!
Last edited by MASSC450; Apr 11, 2017 at 11:49 AM.
Member
Joined: Jan 2016
Posts: 229
Likes: 9
2016 C300
Hey, its my fault 100%. I had a few test drives and then set up an appointment to pick up a new one on a different day. I should have drove it more but I didn't because I never had a problem with the dealership. Its not hyperbole, its fact. When you take a corner at 25 the car leans over on its side and pitches forward on stopping. I didn't notice it on the final test drive. Again, my fault.
In any case, this forum has always been helpful (maybe not this post but I do enjoy the replies). I was searching last night and found some posts where c300 Sport was delivered with comfort suspension. Checked mine last night and I have Sport Trim but comfort suspension installed at final assembly in Alabama. Called my dealership. Waiting on their response.
Mike 5215, If you think having 3 cars is a fleet, then I guess I have one. Although I did have a fleet of tractor trailers once for my sod business. The Jetta GLI is fun to drive though and handles better in corners. Never owned a Yugo but had a Datsun 510 in college.
In any case, this forum has always been helpful (maybe not this post but I do enjoy the replies). I was searching last night and found some posts where c300 Sport was delivered with comfort suspension. Checked mine last night and I have Sport Trim but comfort suspension installed at final assembly in Alabama. Called my dealership. Waiting on their response.
Mike 5215, If you think having 3 cars is a fleet, then I guess I have one. Although I did have a fleet of tractor trailers once for my sod business. The Jetta GLI is fun to drive though and handles better in corners. Never owned a Yugo but had a Datsun 510 in college.
Thread Starter
Junior Member
Joined: May 2008
Posts: 47
Likes: 2
From: Alexandria, VA
'17 C300 Sport, P2, Pano, Black; '17 Jetta GLI White
Well, my dealership values loyalty. My salesman called me and swore up and down it was a sport. I told him to look up the VIN and he verified the suspension was comfort. So long story short, the GM worked with MBUSA who was the lease holder and they canceled the lease and put me in a sport. I have no idea how but I picked it up an hour ago. Can't believe how painless it was. The salesman actually said it was his mistake (even though it was mine) and told me he doesn't like unsatisfied customers. He wants customers for life. The GM said when these things happen, people need to report it right away like I did so they can fix it. This one drives exactly how it should. I probably wouldn't have made the call if it wasn't for this forum and the old threads I found.
Member
Joined: Jan 2016
Posts: 229
Likes: 9
2016 C300
Well, my dealership values loyalty. My salesman called me and swore up and down it was a sport. I told him to look up the VIN and he verified the suspension was comfort. So long story short, the GM worked with MBUSA who was the lease holder and they canceled the lease and put me in a sport. I have no idea how but I picked it up an hour ago. Can't believe how painless it was. The salesman actually said it was his mistake (even though it was mine) and told me he doesn't like unsatisfied customers. He wants customers for life. The GM said when these things happen, people need to report it right away like I did so they can fix it. This one drives exactly how it should. I probably wouldn't have made the call if it wasn't for this forum and the old threads I found.
