What parameters does the MHP Tune for the Engine Control Unit really control?
#76
MBWorld Fanatic!
I don't think Andy deserves an explanation to you guys for anything. You guys are the engineers not us, why are you asking us? If you need help maybe you should ask Andy politely. I have never been a fan of either company and this is just another reason to dislike PC even more. Good job making PC look bad. You guys should be apologizing to evosport for making such a useless thread, all you are doing is making PC look unprofessional and petty while also getting other forum members into unnecessary arguments.
#78
So IBM is developing a new server product. They find a message forum about servers and gets on, starts a thread: "We are building/about to sell a server product. Lets have a technical discussion about how HP builds a similar product. We would like you to give us specific technical details on how HP's product works."
After the ensuing WTF fallout, IBM replies "Wait, I thought we could have a technical discussion of our competitor's product. All we really want is for someone who knows how it works to put the details here so we can validate our product and possibly steal some of their ideas."
Brilliant strategy, Powerchip.
After the ensuing WTF fallout, IBM replies "Wait, I thought we could have a technical discussion of our competitor's product. All we really want is for someone who knows how it works to put the details here so we can validate our product and possibly steal some of their ideas."
Brilliant strategy, Powerchip.
These are my first thoughts after reading the OP's thread.
Good to have some soap opera drama to fill my void after the holiday weekend.
![rolf](https://mbworld.org/forums/images/smilies/rofl.gif)
#79
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: California, USA
Posts: 9,137
Likes: 0
Received 4 Likes
on
4 Posts
E63 P30, CL500 Sport
Good info. And I agree, this thread is all over the place.
If we were really trying to understand how each of those cars were performing in relation to their modifications, we would also want to know things like trap speed, 60-ft times, whether the cars had P31 package to begin with, whether the cars had LSD (does the LSD even make that noticable of a difference at the track for our cars? *sorry tangent), in addition to the factors that you mentioned.
I'm also looking forward to this season furthering the stat pool.
If we were really trying to understand how each of those cars were performing in relation to their modifications, we would also want to know things like trap speed, 60-ft times, whether the cars had P31 package to begin with, whether the cars had LSD (does the LSD even make that noticable of a difference at the track for our cars? *sorry tangent), in addition to the factors that you mentioned.
I'm also looking forward to this season furthering the stat pool.
#82
That is all very good information. Thank you.
#83
Also, I didn't know they tuned the 63 AMG. Do you know of any C63's with their tune on it?
#84
They said they are attempting to enter the 63 and 55 market with a full line of modifications. They hope to get this done by the end of the year, although they would not commit to anything or even whether they will definitely manufacture other parts for our cars.
So it still may be up in the air. But this could mean another option for LT's, exhaust, intake, etc.
Also, I asked them how they tune the TCM and whether they know of a way to tune the transmission through the ECU, and the representative that I spoke with (who was not a tuner or engineer) said that he knew of no way to tune any part of the 63 AMG transmissions through the ECU.
Please understand that I'm just passing along information that was told to me. Perhaps, the Hennessy rep that I spoke to is wrong. I should know more once he talks to his engineer.
Last edited by SonnyakaPig; 09-07-2010 at 04:44 PM.
#85
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: orlando,fl
Posts: 341
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
e55
I just called Hennessy and spoke with them. They said right now they can sell an ECU tune and a TCM tune.
They said they are attempting to enter the 63 and 55 market with a full line of modifications. They hope to get this done by the end of the year, although they would not commit to anything or even whether they will definitely manufacture other parts for our cars.
So it still may be up in the air. But this could mean another option for LT's, exhaust, intake, etc.
Also, I asked them how they tune the TCM and whether they know of a way to tune the transmission through the ECU, and the representative that I spoke with (who was not a tuner or engineer) said that he knew of no way to tune any part of the 63 AMG transmissions through the ECU.
Please understand that I'm just passing along information that was told to me. Perhaps, the Hennessy rep that I spoke to is wrong. I should know more once he talks to his engineer.
They said they are attempting to enter the 63 and 55 market with a full line of modifications. They hope to get this done by the end of the year, although they would not commit to anything or even whether they will definitely manufacture other parts for our cars.
So it still may be up in the air. But this could mean another option for LT's, exhaust, intake, etc.
Also, I asked them how they tune the TCM and whether they know of a way to tune the transmission through the ECU, and the representative that I spoke with (who was not a tuner or engineer) said that he knew of no way to tune any part of the 63 AMG transmissions through the ECU.
Please understand that I'm just passing along information that was told to me. Perhaps, the Hennessy rep that I spoke to is wrong. I should know more once he talks to his engineer.
Last edited by vinnyz; 09-07-2010 at 05:01 PM.
#86
Super Member
So IBM is developing a new server product. They find a message forum about servers and gets on, starts a thread: "We are building/about to sell a server product. Lets have a technical discussion about how HP builds a similar product. We would like you to give us specific technical details on how HP's product works."
After the ensuing WTF fallout, IBM replies "Wait, I thought we could have a technical discussion of our competitor's product. All we really want is for someone who knows how it works to put the details here so we can validate our product and possibly steal some of their ideas."
Brilliant strategy, Powerchip.
After the ensuing WTF fallout, IBM replies "Wait, I thought we could have a technical discussion of our competitor's product. All we really want is for someone who knows how it works to put the details here so we can validate our product and possibly steal some of their ideas."
Brilliant strategy, Powerchip.
Hard to believe pretty much everyone here fell for this.
Powerchip: "Ummmm... how does that MHP guy do it?"
Users: "Well, it goes like this....."
![rolf](https://mbworld.org/forums/images/smilies/rofl.gif)
#88
MBWorld Fanatic!
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: Prague, Czech Republic
Posts: 1,194
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
2009 C63, 2007 GL 450
I just called Hennessy and spoke with them. They said right now they can sell an ECU tune and a TCM tune.
They said they are attempting to enter the 63 and 55 market with a full line of modifications. They hope to get this done by the end of the year, although they would not commit to anything or even whether they will definitely manufacture other parts for our cars.
So it still may be up in the air. But this could mean another option for LT's, exhaust, intake, etc.
Also, I asked them how they tune the TCM and whether they know of a way to tune the transmission through the ECU, and the representative that I spoke with (who was not a tuner or engineer) said that he knew of no way to tune any part of the 63 AMG transmissions through the ECU.
Please understand that I'm just passing along information that was told to me. Perhaps, the Hennessy rep that I spoke to is wrong. I should know more once he talks to his engineer.
They said they are attempting to enter the 63 and 55 market with a full line of modifications. They hope to get this done by the end of the year, although they would not commit to anything or even whether they will definitely manufacture other parts for our cars.
So it still may be up in the air. But this could mean another option for LT's, exhaust, intake, etc.
Also, I asked them how they tune the TCM and whether they know of a way to tune the transmission through the ECU, and the representative that I spoke with (who was not a tuner or engineer) said that he knew of no way to tune any part of the 63 AMG transmissions through the ECU.
Please understand that I'm just passing along information that was told to me. Perhaps, the Hennessy rep that I spoke to is wrong. I should know more once he talks to his engineer.
#89
All I can say is run-away. Ship you ECU to Hennessy and you might see it in 10 months as it will end up in another car. This is total BS and I have not seen one MB tuned car from them. Vipers yes, and that is a whole different story. I wouldn't go down the using Hennessy road...trust me on this. Mine was a five figure mistake with them.
I'm sorry to hear you had a bad experience with them. Five figures, ouch. Thanks for the heads up.
#92
SPONSOR
Wow, this thread has really gotten out of control.
Can we all take a few steps back and see if we can still salvage it?
I will be happy to provide any knowledge that I have on this subject. I very rarely share any information I have with other tuners, but I feel that this subject has been abused over and over and it's time to figure out what is real or not.
I think in order for this to work, we need to come up with some direct questions on the subject.
I'll start......
Can the TCU (Transmission Control Unit) be tuned via the ECU (Engine Control Unit)?
What do YOU consider "tuning" the TCU? IMO, if the software on the TCU (flash memory) is changed, and the TCU then reads this new information upon boot up, then it's tuned. Again, that's my opinion and that may differ from Powerchip.
If the flash memory inside the TCU remains unchanged (same checksum as when it was rolled off the assembly line), is it fair to say that the TCU is not tuned?
As many of you know, we are competitors with Powerchip. I'm not here to take sides, but MY customers ask me if this is possible and I want to make sure I'm providing the right answer.
I have access to 2000+ maps within the C63 ECU and will be happy to provide any details I can on this subject......
Jerry
Can we all take a few steps back and see if we can still salvage it?
I will be happy to provide any knowledge that I have on this subject. I very rarely share any information I have with other tuners, but I feel that this subject has been abused over and over and it's time to figure out what is real or not.
I think in order for this to work, we need to come up with some direct questions on the subject.
I'll start......
Can the TCU (Transmission Control Unit) be tuned via the ECU (Engine Control Unit)?
What do YOU consider "tuning" the TCU? IMO, if the software on the TCU (flash memory) is changed, and the TCU then reads this new information upon boot up, then it's tuned. Again, that's my opinion and that may differ from Powerchip.
If the flash memory inside the TCU remains unchanged (same checksum as when it was rolled off the assembly line), is it fair to say that the TCU is not tuned?
As many of you know, we are competitors with Powerchip. I'm not here to take sides, but MY customers ask me if this is possible and I want to make sure I'm providing the right answer.
I have access to 2000+ maps within the C63 ECU and will be happy to provide any details I can on this subject......
Jerry
#93
Thank you for your contribution, Jerry.
Do you have experience changing the stall speed of the torque converter through the ECU?
Also, what is the brake stall speed for a stock C63? I've been told that the stock stall speed for lockup is like 2400 rpms, but I don't think that is also the brake stall speed. What is your experience, if you don't mind sharing.
Do you have experience changing the stall speed of the torque converter through the ECU?
Also, what is the brake stall speed for a stock C63? I've been told that the stock stall speed for lockup is like 2400 rpms, but I don't think that is also the brake stall speed. What is your experience, if you don't mind sharing.
#94
Banned
Join Date: Aug 2007
Posts: 2,735
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
CLK 63 Black Series, 2009 S550, 2011 Range Rover Supercharged, BMW F800 GS Anniv Edition
Wow, this thread has really gotten out of control.
Can we all take a few steps back and see if we can still salvage it?
I will be happy to provide any knowledge that I have on this subject. I very rarely share any information I have with other tuners, but I feel that this subject has been abused over and over and it's time to figure out what is real or not.
I think in order for this to work, we need to come up with some direct questions on the subject.
I'll start......
Can the TCU (Transmission Control Unit) be tuned via the ECU (Engine Control Unit)?
What do YOU consider "tuning" the TCU? IMO, if the software on the TCU (flash memory) is changed, and the TCU then reads this new information upon boot up, then it's tuned. Again, that's my opinion and that may differ from Powerchip.
If the flash memory inside the TCU remains unchanged (same checksum as when it was rolled off the assembly line), is it fair to say that the TCU is not tuned?
As many of you know, we are competitors with Powerchip. I'm not here to take sides, but MY customers ask me if this is possible and I want to make sure I'm providing the right answer.
I have access to 2000+ maps within the C63 ECU and will be happy to provide any details I can on this subject......
Jerry
Can we all take a few steps back and see if we can still salvage it?
I will be happy to provide any knowledge that I have on this subject. I very rarely share any information I have with other tuners, but I feel that this subject has been abused over and over and it's time to figure out what is real or not.
I think in order for this to work, we need to come up with some direct questions on the subject.
I'll start......
Can the TCU (Transmission Control Unit) be tuned via the ECU (Engine Control Unit)?
What do YOU consider "tuning" the TCU? IMO, if the software on the TCU (flash memory) is changed, and the TCU then reads this new information upon boot up, then it's tuned. Again, that's my opinion and that may differ from Powerchip.
If the flash memory inside the TCU remains unchanged (same checksum as when it was rolled off the assembly line), is it fair to say that the TCU is not tuned?
As many of you know, we are competitors with Powerchip. I'm not here to take sides, but MY customers ask me if this is possible and I want to make sure I'm providing the right answer.
I have access to 2000+ maps within the C63 ECU and will be happy to provide any details I can on this subject......
Jerry
@Powerchip - I'm not sure what prompted you to start such a ridiculous thread...I can only assume there are things going on in private and this was your reaction to them. Bad move IMO.
#95
SPONSOR
Give me a little time and I'll try my best to translate my DAMOS file into english and post up what I can find.
Thank you for your contribution, Jerry.
Do you have experience changing the stall speed of the torque converter through the ECU?
Also, what is the brake stall speed for a stock C63? I've been told that the stock stall speed for lockup is like 2400 rpms, but I don't think that is also the brake stall speed. What is your experience, if you don't mind sharing.
Do you have experience changing the stall speed of the torque converter through the ECU?
Also, what is the brake stall speed for a stock C63? I've been told that the stock stall speed for lockup is like 2400 rpms, but I don't think that is also the brake stall speed. What is your experience, if you don't mind sharing.
#96
SPONSOR
In bold, above...That's the question that needs be answered. Since the TCU is buried inisde the transmission, it cannot be tuned without tearing into the trans. So, can YOU tune the TCU via the ECU ??
@Powerchip - I'm not sure what prompted you to start such a ridiculous thread...I can only assume there are things going on in private and this was your reaction to them. Bad move IMO.
@Powerchip - I'm not sure what prompted you to start such a ridiculous thread...I can only assume there are things going on in private and this was your reaction to them. Bad move IMO.
Ok, what do you consider tuning the TCU? There are things that we alter that customers may think are TCU related, but we never touch the TCU. For this reason, I cannot sell you an ECU/TCU program. That would be false advertising since you are expecting us to modify the TCU.
To answer your question, I cannot tune the TCU via the ECU.
#97
Banned
Join Date: Aug 2007
Posts: 2,735
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
CLK 63 Black Series, 2009 S550, 2011 Range Rover Supercharged, BMW F800 GS Anniv Edition
Ok, what do you consider tuning the TCU? There are things that we alter that customers may think are TCU related, but we never touch the TCU. For this reason, I cannot sell you an ECU/TCU program. That would be false advertising since you are expecting us to modify the TCU.
To answer your question, I cannot tune the TCU via the ECU.
To answer your question, I cannot tune the TCU via the ECU.
Thanks for the reply. Would you mind telling us what you alter that someone might think is TCU related? Line pressure, shift points, shift firmness ?? Lastly, have you attempted to pull the 722.9 TCU and tune it directly?
#98
#99
MBWorld Fanatic!
Ok, what do you consider tuning the TCU? There are things that we alter that customers may think are TCU related, but we never touch the TCU. For this reason, I cannot sell you an ECU/TCU program. That would be false advertising since you are expecting us to modify the TCU.
To answer your question, I cannot tune the TCU via the ECU.
To answer your question, I cannot tune the TCU via the ECU.
Maybe just post what CAN be adjusted from the ECU, things like torque management, etc, etc.
EDIT: Sorry Jerry for asking you to get deeper into this issue, you have already stepped up enough IMHO.
Thank you for your input. And I am awaiting Powerchips response below.
Last edited by MRAMG1; 09-08-2010 at 09:53 AM.
#100
Former Vendor of MBWorld
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2004
Posts: 219
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
everything
Ok, what do you consider tuning the TCU? There are things that we alter that customers may think are TCU related, but we never touch the TCU. For this reason, I cannot sell you an ECU/TCU program. That would be false advertising since you are expecting us to modify the TCU.
To answer your question, I cannot tune the TCU via the ECU.
To answer your question, I cannot tune the TCU via the ECU.
Thanks for posting and being honest about what you can and can't do.
I can confirm that your skill set that you indicate is exactly the same as Powerchips.
That is not to say both Powerchip and Eurocharged modify exactly the same maps, I'm sure we don't. I'm saying Powerchip can't reprogram the TCU by programming the engine ECU. No tuner can, it's impossible.
Your reply is the reason why I started this thread, because when MHP say the ECU tune they buy from Europe for a 63 is remapping the TCU on a 7 speed auto, it is a lie.
Obviously, it makes it an unfair playing field when a competitor tells deliberate and intentional lies in order to try to create a false competitive advantage.
There are people posting in this thread that have not disclosed that they are directly or indirectly associated with a competitor.
I have asked Internet Brands to look into this and hope that the discussion can return to the topic of MHP's 63 ECU/TCU and "CDT".
Thanks again for being a professional competitor and telling the truth.
I just wish Andy from MHP would stop trying to create an overall impression about being able to reprogram the TCU on a 7 speed auto.
He hasn't. He can't. His secret tuner hasn't and can't.
Last edited by Powerchip; 09-08-2010 at 08:39 AM.