Should I be steered away from the C63 due to this forum?
I don't care about things like "cheap interior materials", "door lock pins annoying" "more amg badging on the interior". what i care about are these 5 things:
1) combined city/highway mileage - what are you getting? i'm in stop-n-go every day. my 20 mile communte takes 50 minutes. my gti rated at 22/30 mpg is getting 25 consitently. what can i expect form a c63?
2) rear tire wear - do they really only last 8-10k miles w/o driving hard? i have conti dw's on my gti with 10k and still have more than 60% tread left.
3) brake life/excessive dust - will pads last 20k miles? the gti is on 55k with original pads, zero dust ever. the c230 i used to have would have black wheels in a week and pads/rotors needed changed every 15k-20k miles.
4) drivers seat bolster wear - every car i have looked at, even with 15k miles has had signs of wear. is it impossible for them to not wear?
5) daily comfort - i read the seats are not good for long commutes and the suspension is uncomfortable. i've driven maybe 6 cars and no issue with a test drive, but what about after 45 minutes?
Any help and honest feedback is appreciated. I have a deal pending and at this point, leaning towards passing. TIA.
that's like comparing apples to oranges . the car will last as long as you want it to . if you drive like bat out of hell , then any car won't last . if you are that worried about brakes , gas milage and tire wear , then i suggest you stick with your GTI .
But, you gotta pay to play. Yes, it's bad on gas and tires... but so what. It's an incredible machine that's the most fun driving you'll probably ever have.
Don't read those negative threads. I don't. I love my car - and I don't want to draw my attention to something I might not have noticed otherwise.
I don't care about things like "cheap interior materials", "door lock pins annoying" "more amg badging on the interior". what i care about are these 5 things:
1) combined city/highway mileage - what are you getting? i'm in stop-n-go every day. my 20 mile communte takes 50 minutes. my gti rated at 22/30 mpg is getting 25 consitently. what can i expect form a c63?
2) rear tire wear - do they really only last 8-10k miles w/o driving hard? i have conti dw's on my gti with 10k and still have more than 60% tread left.
3) brake life/excessive dust - will pads last 20k miles? the gti is on 55k with original pads, zero dust ever. the c230 i used to have would have black wheels in a week and pads/rotors needed changed every 15k-20k miles.
4) drivers seat bolster wear - every car i have looked at, even with 15k miles has had signs of wear. is it impossible for them to not wear?
5) daily comfort - i read the seats are not good for long commutes and the suspension is uncomfortable. i've driven maybe 6 cars and no issue with a test drive, but what about after 45 minutes?
Any help and honest feedback is appreciated. I have a deal pending and at this point, leaning towards passing. TIA.
1. Seriously? Buy a civic or a prius.
2. See #1
3. When you have big brakes, you're going to have big dust.
4. Depends on how you take care of them, they're very aggressive seats, so they're going to get wear no matter what you do, but it's not horrible.
5. Also depends on who you're asking.
cliff notes: see #1
Trending Topics
Bottomline I'd keep the GTI as a DD and get the c63 as a fun car, because practicality isn't one of its strengths.
Last edited by cptdaz; Jan 11, 2012 at 12:29 PM.
The Best of Mercedes & AMG
The reality is that to whatever degree anyone feels they are true - they are worth it.
This car is the difference between the bus and the bullet train. It is a blast. Performance costs, but not radically.
Having said that a real bonus of this car is that they seem to have very little in the way of common issues - those things that when you mention them guys roll their eyes and say "typical for this car". Things like needing fuel pumps and injectors in the 335. My G35 had lots of those things too.
Its a 4000 lb performance car that accelerates, brakes and handles like a 'Vette but with 4 doors and a trunk - drive it hard and you'll have wear and tear. Don't drive it hard and you're a pu$$y and not a real car guy. And never own a car where the gas mileage is a make or break as to whether you can afford it.
In Car and Driver's review of an M3 the writer says "while driving this car I found myself day dreaming about the engine in the C63". Think about that - C&D is the unofficial BMW press outlet and they LOVE LOVE LOVE the M3. and still he said that.
Pay. Play. Don't look back.
1) combined city/highway mileage - what are you getting? i'm in stop-n-go every day. my 20 mile communte takes 50 minutes. my gti rated at 22/30 mpg is getting 25 consitently. what can i expect form a c63?
You care about gas milage and you're looking at a C63.... You seem intelligent.
2) rear tire wear - do they really only last 8-10k miles w/o driving hard? i have conti dw's on my gti with 10k and still have more than 60% tread left.
Mine lasted 7k. It eats tires. (I kind of like it though, I get to be a sort of tire connoisseur)
3) brake life/excessive dust - will pads last 20k miles? the gti is on 55k with original pads, zero dust ever. the c230 i used to have would have black wheels in a week and pads/rotors needed changed every 15k-20k miles.
Who cares. At 55K miles on a GTI you have original pads!? You probably have zero dust because the pads are completely gone. There is no way you pads are good. TT had 85K kms and the pads were toast.
4) drivers seat bolster wear - every car i have looked at, even with 15k miles has had signs of wear. is it impossible for them to not wear?
Yah. Don't drive it.
5) daily comfort - i read the seats are not good for long commutes and the suspension is uncomfortable. i've driven maybe 6 cars and no issue with a test drive, but what about after 45 minutes?
I drive 1.5hrs at a time back and forth from school.. I could fall asleep in the seat its so nice! By then I need to stop for gas so its not a big deal
Any help and honest feedback is appreciated. I have a deal pending and at this point, leaning towards passing. TIA.
thanks to those that were helpful...it was never meant to be compared to the gti, i'm not an idiot although some of you presume i am. what i meant by mileage is the gti is rated 22/30 and i get 25. so if the c63 is rate 12/19 can i expect 15? is that too hard of a question to answer?
as for tires, i apolgize if i think that its unrealistic that a luxury/sport sedan at this price point can't get 10k miles out of a tire that has a 340 tread rating. it is, after all, really only a c class with a bigger engine and brakes, not a gallardo.
the brake dust was just an annoyance that i've seen before, that's all. my M3 brakes get plenty dusty as well, but the pads last longer than 15k miles.
i think there is a common ground between performance and practicality and i was trying to see if this car meets that. sounds like it doesn't. i drove this back-to-back with a cts-v which i thought was a far more comfortable car, but has it's own issues, as does the e60 m5's i've driven and s4's, all have issues as do all cars. i was looking long-term though, not just based on a test drive, to see what "issues" i can live with without spending $2k/yr on maintenance.
anyway, thanks for all the input - good and bad.
little things like door lock pins can be changed if you desire... i enjoy this car immensely
i haven't gone through the trouble of actually figuring out mpg manually... but from what the car tells me... i can get up to about 21+ on a long road trip... other than that i think about 17-19 city i believe... but i stopped worrying about gas a long time ago... it takes the fun out of owning this car...
tires do wear fast, but you can get tires that will last longer if you don't plan on tracking the car... and it also depends on how often you stomp on the gas... my favorite dd tires are nexens... it's a pretty hard tire but last pretty long on this car... works great in the rain as well... i used them for like 2 years until i decided to get some tires with more grip... now i'm running michelin pss... which are in a different league in performance and cost... nexens ran me $500 or less for a set mounted and balanced
i have absolutely no problem with the comfort of this car long distance... i love the seats... if you're not used to bucket seats, it'll take a few weeks... trust me, the first time you sit down you will probably hate them... then later you'll wonder why you hated them
man, i thought stepping up to a newer mb amg would put me in a different league and weed out all the haters and immature *****s like you on forums, but i guess i was wrong.
you're right though, if someone like you owns this car, i don't want want it.
I don't care about things like "cheap interior materials", "door lock pins annoying" "more amg badging on the interior". what i care about are these 5 things:
1) combined city/highway mileage - what are you getting? i'm in stop-n-go every day. my 20 mile communte takes 50 minutes. my gti rated at 22/30 mpg is getting 25 consitently. what can i expect form a c63?
In stop and go traffic you shouldnt expect more than 14-16 MPG. For reference, I avg 14MPG in mixed hwy/street driving.
2) rear tire wear - do they really only last 8-10k miles w/o driving hard? i have conti dw's on my gti with 10k and still have more than 60% tread left.
The tires should last as long as you're easy on the throttle - thing is most folks who buy this car aren't concerned with issues like tire wear since this is a performance-oriented, high-power car. Most buyers are going to drive it harder than your standard Honda Accord.
3) brake life/excessive dust - will pads last 20k miles? the gti is on 55k with original pads, zero dust ever. the c230 i used to have would have black wheels in a week and pads/rotors needed changed every 15k-20k miles.
No way around the brake dust using OEM pads. I've been told there are aftermarket options with significantly less brake dust so that is an option. As far as brake life goes - again, this is determined by how hard you drive the car although stop and go city traffic will takes it's toll over time.
For your reference, my front pads last me about 12,000 miles and that includes about 100 passes at the drag strip and a good deal of city driving.
4) drivers seat bolster wear - every car i have looked at, even with 15k miles has had signs of wear. is it impossible for them to not wear?
Not really - it's just the way these things are. I suppose you could be more mindful of your ingress/egress technique so as not to rub against the bolsters, however, these sits are so aggressively bolstered that might be hard.
5) daily comfort - i read the seats are not good for long commutes and the suspension is uncomfortable. i've driven maybe 6 cars and no issue with a test drive, but what about after 45 minutes?
IMO the seats are very comfortable but might be considered uncomfortable by bigger people and those not used to the agggressive bolstering.
The suspension can be jarring at times, but driving on NYC roads always are. Probably less of an issue for those living in areas with better roads.
Any help and honest feedback is appreciated. I have a deal pending and at this point, leaning towards passing. TIA.
man, i thought stepping up to a newer mb amg would put me in a different league and weed out all the haters and immature *****s like you on forums, but i guess i was wrong.
you're right though, if someone like you owns this car, i don't want want it.
Whoever raised you did a fantastic job.
Last edited by BK63amg; Jan 11, 2012 at 01:17 PM.
Although I dont have a C63 AMG YET, I figured let me chime in because I do have an INfiniti G37s Coupe. I barely get 16 driving city and I don't punch it or drive it hard like some other rascals do. Tires on that car lasted me 18K miles and my commute is only 6.4 miles to and from work.
there are better cars for the job if you're doing it for image. You can get 10k of tires if you get all seasons and again, drive it like a granny. And again, we come back to the question of why you would want to own a high performance car as a replacement for your GTI.
I use mine as a DD, I drive between 50 and 60 miles each way to and from work (I am a consultant), part of that driving is in Washington DC.. not exactly known for being friendly to commuting in any way.. That said
1) When I drive through the city for whatever reason, I tend to avg 12 to 15mpg, when I drive to various offices around the beltway against traffic, I tend to avg 18 to 21 depending on how I feel and how aggressive I am driving... and I drive it like I stole it.
2) Some will crucify me for this.. but after going through 2 sets of tires in a year, I switched to the Conti all season DWS's, and they seem to be a good middle ground between summer tires and my aggressive nature, I drive hard, and have yet to lose control, but I would not take them to the track. They have so far lasted me a year, and their is still plenty of tread left.
3) Brake dust is a part of the big brake package, just wash your car regularly. As for how long they last, I still have around 30% pad left, and they are the original brake pads when I got the car at 14k miles, I now have 55k miles on the clock. I do engine brake alot (that has more to do with listening to the engine wind down and gurgle and make angry noises..) so that may make a big difference.
4) They are seats, they will wear, get over it.
5) This one is more individual specific, I personally have no problems with the seats, and have gone on business trips that had me driving for 5 to 6 hours at a time. My wife is 6'1 and built like a runner (since she is one), the side bolsters stab her in the ribs, she does not like the seats at all.... If your a larger individual, this may be an issue.
1) combined city/highway mileage - what are you getting? i'm in stop-n-go every day. my 20 mile communte takes 50 minutes. my gti rated at 22/30 mpg is getting 25 consitently. what can i expect form a c63?
2) rear tire wear - do they really only last 8-10k miles w/o driving hard? i have conti dw's on my gti with 10k and still have more than 60% tread left.
3) brake life/excessive dust - will pads last 20k miles? the gti is on 55k with original pads, zero dust ever. the c230 i used to have would have black wheels in a week and pads/rotors needed changed every 15k-20k miles.
4) drivers seat bolster wear - every car i have looked at, even with 15k miles has had signs of wear. is it impossible for them to not wear?
5) daily comfort - i read the seats are not good for long commutes and the suspension is uncomfortable. i've driven maybe 6 cars and no issue with a test drive, but what about after 45 minutes?
Any help and honest feedback is appreciated. I have a deal pending and at this point, leaning towards passing. TIA.








