Considering 05 s600.... Reliable?
I'm reading conflicting reviews.
Im currently in an ml500, best vehicle I've ever owned, hands down...the most reliable tank, ever.
I want a family friendly sedan, so an s600 seemed appropriate.
Are they reliability nightmares? Problematic?
We own our own shop, so I'm not concerned with labor costs, just downtime, and headaches....
Any advice? Specifics to keep an eye out for?
Thanks!
Em
Are they generally problematic? We do our own work, and the basic maintenance parts do not seem outrageous.
More complicated in what way? They all seem to have endless amenities, which always pose a complication as the miles go up... But are there any points specific to the s600 that are prone to commonly fail?
The main cost/maintenance difference in a 600 is the ABC suspension, which is more costly to repair and more failure prone than the airmatic available in the lesser engine cars.
Even though you do your own work so labor costs don't matter, I still wouldn't recommend it because the part prices are outrageous for the S600. $1,200 for coil packs on one bank, and they are an extremely common failure item. Now imagine dealing with two failing coil packs. They are not like normal coil packs on normal cars where each cylinder has its own coil pack that costs ~$30. If and when your coil pack fails (inevitable & common), you must buy it for the whole cylinder bank when only one or two cylinders start to misfire on one bank.
Oh yeah not to mention the ABC suspension on top of that, which also is a really common failure item and has ridiculously priced parts and you can not work on the ABC suspension yourself unless you are a master Mercedes mechanic (or else you will just break more things in the suspension system).
Please, just go with the S430 or S500. If you really like the S600 and are committed to buying it, then go for it. They are amazing machines when in proper working order. Be warned though, because it is a huge risk. There is just far too much involvement required to have them working perfectly.
ABC needs work to keep running, but it can be done - see the thread in my signature.
https://mbworld.org/forums/s-class-w...2003-s600.html
Last edited by Welwynnick; Jun 12, 2016 at 06:42 AM.
I know the airbag systems in the cars can be changed out for coilovers... Will swapping those in disable the ABC system? Since I'm assuming some sensors necessary would no longer be there?
Trending Topics
The Best of Mercedes & AMG
So, simple soldering would be able to repair them, instead of needing to replace them at thousands of dollars for new units.
That is a huge relief, and something we can easily do ourselves.
https://mbworld.org/forums/s-class-w...pack-s600.html
Now onto my concern with the ABC system...
That's not bad at all, lower then I expected, actually.
This is not seeming terribly outrageous, cost wise.
The engines themselves are pretty stout, from what I'm reading?



The response from the OP is almost always the same - they do it!
In most cases the car is purchased, OP loves it because of the power and the amazing ride. Things break, OP fixes it and continues to enjoy their car.
Practically speaking, moving from an ML to an S Class as a family hauler - the trunk on the S is somewhat small because of where the gas tank is and the S600 doesn't have 4 wheel drive, if either of these items are important to you.
The engine seems stout from my reading, and that is the biggest ticket item on the list.
A roof rack can always be added if the trunk space doesn't cut it.
We are keeping the ML, not replacing it (so, in bad weather, we have the awd capabilities).
Our other cars are not so kid friendly, and we really need a secondary car that we all could fit in and satisfy my driver enthusiast itch at the same time. This seemed to check all categories.
But, if you really can do your own work, then it's do-able. I bought my car in 2012 with 59,000 on it and it has 86,000 on it now. I'm on a multi day road trip, through the NorthEast. It's the best road trip car ever built.
Coil packs may break. I've got 86,000 miles on the original left side pack, and the right side pack was repaired for $275 when I replaced the plugs this year. See these guys: http://www.v12icpack.com - they can repair your pack, or rebuild the whole pack for $700. Not cheap, but half the dealer price on a new pack.
ABC can be serviced. I rebuilt both valve bodies for about $12 in parts. Add $65 for fluid. I had one hose repaired at my local hydraulic shop, $150, and bought the pulse damper hose from an on line source, $275. I replaced three of the accumulators, $650, the filter, $40, and then did a "rodeo" with another five liters of fluid. About $1,200 all in and the system is working great.
You must buy a STAR/DAS system. The best $500 you will ever spend.
For those who say "get a different car" - it's like telling a guy that wants to buy an F-14 that he should buy a Lear jet because it's easier and cheaper to own...well...yeah...that's true...but you didn't shop for an F-14 because it was cheap to own...you wanted it because it was the most awesome fighter ever built and you're willing to put in the maintenance work.
The S600 is an F-14. Big, complex, fast and, in the end, awesome.
My husband is usually quite leery of my hair brained car purchase schemes. But he's, thankfully, very much on board with this one, since he's going to be the one doing the work.... Hahaha
Now comes the task of selling my 3000GT spyder to make room for something the kids can fit in... Thank you for the replies. I really appreciate it.
So, simple soldering would be able to repair them, instead of needing to replace them at thousands of dollars for new units.
That is a huge relief, and something we can easily do ourselves.
https://mbworld.org/forums/s-class-w...pack-s600.html
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Ignition-C...-/351103984609
Or you can these guys to rebuild your coil-packs for you:
http://www.v12icpack.com/
Or you can salvage good coils from a scrap coil-pack and fit those. Howard and I both did the latter, and both are working fine to this day.
ABC is a concern, but you absolutely must read these:
https://mbworld.org/forums/s-class-w...2003-s600.html
http://api.viglink.com/api/click?for...gspot.co.uk%2F
https://mbworld.org/forums/m275-v12-...on-thread.html
The V12TT would be half the car without ABC, and I certainly wouldn't have one without it. Its complicated, and you can't trust mechanics, but it is maintainable.
Nick
My husband is usually quite leery of my hair brained car purchase schemes. But he's, thankfully, very much on board with this one, since he's going to be the one doing the work.... Hahaha
Now comes the task of selling my 3000GT spyder to make room for something the kids can fit in... Thank you for the replies. I really appreciate it.
As far as my experience with the S600...the only things that have broken on me were things that I have directly or indirectly caused. I did the ECU/TCU tune and shortly thereafter, my 95,000 mile stock coil assembly went out. That was expected. I was doing preventive maintenance and replacing the pulleys and belt on the front of the engine and cracked my radiator in the process (apparently the large factory quick-disconnect is very prone to cracking and if it is disturbed much it will go to leaking). Apart from that, it's literally just been standard preventive maintenance I have done. One noisy wheel bearing. Brake pads. Oil changes. Transmission fluid change. Etc.
You should expect parts to be expensive and you should expect to break other things while you are making repairs if you don't REALLY take your time and be careful. But as far as things going wrong mechanically just out of the blue, I think they are extremely solid cars. And the power/response is UNREAL...makes my 15G stealth feel stock.
Knowing who you guys are, and your quality of work I am sure you will have no problem with an S600. When you get all the preventive stuff done and get it up to speed and start modding there are lots of very informative threads on here but the basics are just like with any stock turbo car...turn the boost up, improve charge cooling, improve exhaust flow, etc. Tunes are extremely expensive on this platform and the vendors are really tight-lipped/vague about specifically what they can and can't do in the tune, but the results are phenomenal and still great bang for the buck. I mean I don't know of any other platform where a flash tune is more than a couple hundred bucks...here your entry level one is $999 on sale, lol.
You would probably have a heart attack if I told you my E85 conversion on my S600 is the same as on my 3/Ss. It consists of properly oversized injectors and no other changes whatsoever. I still need to flow test the stock pump to see if I have enough to flash in the race gas tune, but it runs better than ever on my pump gas tune. I know we butted heads on the whole E85 thing on Facebook, lol. But apparently there's no control over the injector scaling in the tune (at least that's what Jerry @ Eurocharged says), so that's the only way to do it on these short of a very expensive standalone. The hardest part about modding these cars is finding out basic information about how the systems actually work (particularly the ECU and other modules control schemes for various things).
I am excited to have you guys join the platform, it would be great to have someone with similar past platform experiences to spitball mod ideas with. I hope you get a great deal on a clean one, they are hands down the most car you can get for the money anywhere.



Never had to do any repairs on the engine or transmission. All work was done by the dealer with no more than two days in the shop. Something other than routine maintenance was only at 2 or 3 year intervals. We were driving it about 9K miles/year.
We currently own 2 MB V12's and the new S65 is the 5th we have purchased, all told we have driven MB V12's over 250k miles. Yes, some of the parts and labor can get expensive out of warranty but these things are generally fix once and done.
The person who bought my 2006 S65 purchased a warranty for it last week for $3k. I have not seen the paperwork on the warranty but he tells me it is pretty all inclusive.
Being intimately familiar with the backside of the warranty business (due to being in the used car business and being pitched dozens of warranty programs from companies that were wanting us to try and attach to our car deals), it's ALWAYS a bad deal for the customer. Usually through exclusions and/or deductibles. And if it isn't a bad deal, then that warranty company will be bankrupt in short order anyway due to lack of profitability and claims depleting their reserves and then your warranty is worthless.
Almost every warranty I've seen specifically excludes any turbocharged, supercharged, 4WD, or heavy duty/commercial vehicles. That doesn't mean they won't still sell you the warranty...your vehicle just might not actually have been eligible in the first place. It's the same concept as if you buy a wrong part that doesn't actually fit your car...it's not the warranty company's responsibility to determine if the product you are purchasing applies to your vehicle...that's on you. As a rule, insurance or warranty products are always a net loss for the consumer if it's a respectable/real product, and it tends to be a very scammy industry in general so a lot of the warranties are very rarely even honored. I would never buy one personally, nor offer one to my customers. The average structure is $1,000-1,200 per year, with an expected wholesale net repair cost of $300-400/year after the deductible is applied. If the warranty on that S65 is from a legitimate company then he got very lucky and they are going to lose their *** on that deal and probably revise their contract or eligibility requirements as a result. Unless perhaps that's $3,000 for a one-year warranty. But most likely it's a 2-3 year and he's ended up with one of the thousands of shady warranty companies that won't cover much of anything.



Sorry to derail the thread, Em. I get off on a tangent easily.
Example... We had a car come in with rod knock (spun bearings).
They ONLY covered the bearing that actually spun... Not the entire crank, or labor for anything other than what was directly involved with those specific spun bearings... They only paid for remanufactured crank, etc... God. Awful. The customer was left paying the remaining balance of the work, whatever deductible they had, etc. Really no cost savings to them at all, after paying for that warranty.






